1195 - "ÏÑ┘å┘æ Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ┘ä┘à ┘èϼÏ╣┘ä Ï┤┘üϺÏí Ïú┘àϬ┘è ┘ü┘è┘àϺ Ï¡Ï▒┘æ┘à Ï╣┘ä┘è┘çϺ"
Ï░┘âÏ▒┘ç Ϻ┘äϡϺ┘üÏ© ┘ü┘è Ͻ┘äϺϽϮ ┘à┘êϺÏÂÏ╣:
┘éϺ┘ä ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏú┘ê┘ä: Ï▒┘êϺ┘ç ÏúÏ¿┘ê ϻϺ┘êÏ» (1) ┘à┘å ϡϻ┘èϽ Ïú┘à Ï│┘ä┘àÏ®" (2)
┘ê┘éϺ┘ä ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äϽϺ┘å┘è: ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ÏúÏ¿┘ê ┘èÏ╣┘ä┘ë ┘êÏÁϡϡ┘ç ϺϿ┘å ϡϿϺ┘å" (3)
┘ê┘éϺ┘ä ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äϽϺ┘äϽ: ┘ê┘ä┘ç (Ïú┘è ÏúÏ¿┘è ϻϺ┘êÏ») Ï╣┘å Ïú┘à Ï│┘ä┘àÏ® ┘àÏ▒┘ü┘êÏ╣Ϻ: ┘üÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç" (4)
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ÏúÏ¡┘àÏ» ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äÏúÏ┤Ï▒ϿϮ" (159) ┘êϺϿ┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è Ϻ┘äÏ»┘å┘èϺ ┘ü┘è "Ï░┘à Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ│┘âÏ▒" (12) ┘êÏúÏ¿┘ê ┘èÏ╣┘ä┘ë (6966) ┘êϺϿ┘å ϡϿϺ┘å (1391) ┘êϺ┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘ä┘âÏ¿┘èÏ▒" (23/ 326 - 327) ┘êϺ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è (10/ 5) ┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘é Ï╣┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è ÏÑÏ│ϡϺ┘é Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èϿϺ┘å┘è Ï╣┘å Ï¡Ï│Ϻ┘å Ï¿┘å ┘àϫϺÏ▒┘é ┘éϺ┘ä: ┘éϺ┘äϬ Ïú┘à Ï│┘ä┘àÏ®: ϺÏ┤Ϭ┘âϬ ϺϿ┘åÏ® ┘ä┘èÏî ┘ü┘Ä┘å┘ÄÏ¿┘ÄÏ░┘ÆÏ¬┘Å ┘ä┘çϺ ┘ü┘è ┘â┘Å┘ê┘ÆÏ▓Ïî ┘üϻϫ┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘åÏ¿┘è - ÏÁ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ┘êÏ│┘ä┘à - ┘ê┘ç┘ê ┘èÏ║┘ä┘èÏî ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä "┘àϺ ┘çÏ░Ϻσ " ┘ü┘éϺ┘äϬ: ÏÑ┘å┘æ ϺϿ┘åϬ┘è ϺÏ┤Ϭ┘âϬ ┘ü┘åÏ¿Ï░┘åϺ ┘ä┘çϺ ┘çÏ░ϺÏî ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä "ÏÑ┘å┘æ Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ┘ä┘à ┘èϼÏ╣┘ä Ï┤┘üϺÏí┘â┘à ┘ü┘è Ï¡Ï▒Ϻ┘à"
┘ê┘ü┘è ┘ä┘üÏ© "┘ü┘è┘àϺ Ï¡Ï▒┘æ┘à Ï╣┘ä┘è┘â┘à".
┘éϺ┘ä ϺϿ┘å Ï¡Ï▓┘à: ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äϡϻ┘èϽ ϿϺÏÀ┘ä ┘äÏú┘å┘æ Ï▒Ϻ┘ê┘è┘ç Ï│┘ä┘è┘àϺ┘å Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èϿϺ┘å┘è ┘ê┘ç┘ê ┘àϼ┘ç┘ê┘ä" Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ¡┘ä┘ë 1/ 233
┘é┘äϬ: Ï¿┘ä ┘ç┘ê ┘àÏ╣Ï▒┘ê┘ü ┘ê┘ç┘ê Ï│┘ä┘è┘àϺ┘å Ï¿┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è Ï│┘ä┘è┘àϺ┘å ÏúÏ¿┘ê ÏÑÏ│ϡϺ┘é Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èϿϺ┘å┘è Ϻ┘ä┘â┘ê┘ü┘è ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ ┘ä┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ│ϬϮ ┘ê┘êϽ┘é┘ç ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ╣┘è┘å ┘êÏúÏ¿┘ê ϡϺϬ┘à ┘êϺ┘ä┘åÏ│ϺϪ┘è ┘êÏúÏ¿┘ê ϻϺ┘êÏ» ┘êϺ┘äÏ╣ϼ┘ä┘è ┘êϺ┘äϻϺÏ▒┘éÏÀ┘å┘è ┘êÏ║┘èÏ▒┘ç┘à.
┘êÏ¡Ï│Ϻ┘å Ï¿┘å ┘àϫϺÏ▒┘é Ï░┘âÏ▒┘ç ϺϿ┘å ϡϿϺ┘å ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äϽ┘éϺϬ" Ï╣┘ä┘ë ┘éϺÏ╣ϻϬ┘ç ┘ê┘ä┘à ┘èÏ░┘âÏ▒ Ï╣┘å┘ç Ï▒Ϻ┘ê┘èϺ ÏÑ┘äϺ ÏúϿϺ ÏÑÏ│ϡϺ┘é Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èϿϺ┘å┘è ┘ü┘ç┘ê ┘àϼ┘ç┘ê┘äÏî ┘ê┘äϺ ┘è┘ÅÏ»Ï▒┘ë ┘ç┘ä ┘ä┘é┘è Ïú┘à Ï│┘ä┘àÏ® Ïú┘à ┘äϺ.
┘ê┘éÏ» ÏÁÏ¡ Ϻ┘äϡϻ┘èϽ ┘à┘å ┘é┘ê┘ä ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ│Ï╣┘êÏ» Ï░┘âÏ▒┘ç Ϻ┘äϿϫϺÏ▒┘è ┘ü┘è "ÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡┘ç" (┘üϬϡ 12/ 180) ϬÏ╣┘ä┘è┘éϺ ┘êÏ¿ÏÁ┘èÏ║Ï® Ϻ┘äϼÏ▓┘à.
┘éϺ┘ä: ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ│Ï╣┘êÏ» ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ│┘æ┘Ä┘â┘ÄÏ▒: ÏÑ┘å┘æ Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ┘ä┘à ┘èϼÏ╣┘ä Ï┤┘üϺÏí┘â┘à ┘ü┘è┘àϺ Ï¡┘ÄÏ▒┘æ┘Ä┘à Ï╣┘ä┘è┘â┘à"
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äϡϺ┘üÏ©: ┘é┘äϬ: ┘éÏ» Ï▒┘ê┘èϬ Ϻ┘äÏúϽÏ▒ Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ░┘â┘êÏ▒ ┘ü┘è "┘ü┘êϺϪϻ" Ï╣┘ä┘è Ï¿┘å Ï¡Ï▒Ï¿ Ϻ┘äÏÀϺϪ┘è (5) Ï╣┘å Ï│┘ü┘èϺ┘å Ï¿┘å Ï╣┘Å┘è┘è┘åÏ® Ï╣┘å ┘à┘åÏÁ┘êÏ▒ Ï╣┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è ┘êϺϪ┘ä ┘éϺ┘ä: ϺÏ┤Ϭ┘â┘ë Ï▒ϼ┘ä ┘à┘åϺ ┘è┘éϺ┘ä ┘ä┘ç: Ï«┘èϽ┘à Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘äÏ╣ϻϺÏí ϻϺÏí ϿϿÏÀ┘å┘ç ┘è┘éϺ┘ä ┘ä┘ç Ϻ┘äÏÁ┘üÏ▒ ┘ü┘åÏ╣Ϭ ┘ä┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ│┘æ┘Ä┘â┘ÄÏ▒ ┘üÏúÏ▒Ï│┘ä ÏÑ┘ä┘ë ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ│Ï╣┘êÏ» ┘èÏ│Ïú┘ä┘ç ┘üÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç. ┘êÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ϺϿ┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è Ï┤┘èϿϮ (8/ 23) Ï╣┘å ϼÏ▒┘èÏ▒ Ï╣┘å ┘à┘åÏÁ┘êÏ▒ ┘êÏ│┘åÏ»┘ç ÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡ Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ï┤Ï▒ÏÀ Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èÏ«┘è┘å (6)Ïî ┘êÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ÏúÏ¡┘àÏ» ┘ü┘è ┘âϬϺϿ "Ϻ┘äÏúÏ┤Ï▒ϿϮ" (117) ┘êϺ┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘ä┘âÏ¿┘èÏ▒" (9714 ┘ê9715 ┘ê 9716) ┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é ÏúÏ¿┘è ┘êϺϪ┘ä (7) ┘åÏ¡┘ê┘çÏî ┘êÏ▒┘ê┘è┘åϺ ┘ü┘è ┘åÏ│ϫϮ ϻϺ┘êÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘åÏÁ┘èÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏÀϺϪ┘è Ï¿Ï│┘åÏ» ÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡ Ï╣┘å ┘àÏ│Ï▒┘ê┘é (8) ┘éϺ┘ä: ┘éϺ┘ä Ï╣Ͽϻ Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç- ┘ç┘ê ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ│Ï╣┘êÏ»-: ┘äϺ ϬÏ│┘é┘êϺ Ïú┘ê┘äϺϻ┘â┘à Ϻ┘äÏ«┘àÏ▒ ┘üÏÑ┘å┘æ┘ç┘à ┘ê┘äÏ»┘êϺ Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘üÏÀÏ▒Ï® ┘êÏÑ┘å┘æ Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ┘ä┘à ┘èϼÏ╣┘ä Ï┤┘üϺÏí┘â┘à ┘ü┘è┘àϺ Ï¡Ï▒┘æ┘à Ï╣┘ä┘è┘â┘à. ┘êÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ϺϿ┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è Ï┤┘èϿϮ ┘à┘å ┘êϼ┘ç ÏóÏ«Ï▒ Ï╣┘å ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ│Ï╣┘êÏ» ┘âÏ░┘ä┘âÏî ┘êÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ ÏÑÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘ç┘è┘à Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï▒Ï¿┘è ┘ü┘è "Ï║Ï▒┘èÏ¿ Ϻ┘äϡϻ┘èϽ" ┘à┘å ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘ä┘êϼ┘ç ┘éϺ┘ä: ÏúϬ┘è┘åϺ Ï╣Ͽϻ Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ┘ü┘è ┘àϼϻÏ▒┘è┘å Ïú┘ê ┘àÏ¡ÏÁÏ¿┘è┘å ┘åÏ╣Ϭ ┘ä┘ç┘à Ϻ┘äÏ│┘âÏ▒ ┘üÏ░┘âÏ▒ ┘àϽ┘ä┘ç" Ϻ┘ä┘üϬϡ 12/ 181
┘êÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç Ï╣Ͽϻ Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï▓Ϻ┘é (17102) ┘êϺ┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘ä┘âÏ¿┘èÏ▒" (9717) ┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é Ï¡┘àϺϻ Ï╣┘å ÏÑÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘ç┘è┘à ┘éϺ┘ä: ┘éϺ┘ä ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ│Ï╣┘êÏ»: ┘äϺ ϬÏ│┘é┘êϺ Ïú┘ê┘äϺϻ┘â┘à Ϻ┘äÏ«┘àÏ▒Ïî Ï¿┘åÏ¡┘ê Ï▒┘êϺ┘èÏ® ┘àÏ│Ï▒┘ê┘é.
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ç┘èϽ┘à┘è: ┘êÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ┘ç ┘à┘å┘éÏÀÏ╣ ┘êÏ▒ϼϺ┘ä┘ç Ï▒ϼϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡" Ϻ┘ä┘àϼ┘àÏ╣ 5/ 72
┘êÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ÏúÏ¡┘àÏ» ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äÏúÏ┤Ï▒ϿϮ" (133) Ï╣┘å ┘àÏ¡┘àÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘üÏÂ┘è┘ä Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘äÏ╣┘äϺÏí Ï╣┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è┘ç Ï╣┘å ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ│Ï╣┘êÏ» ┘éϺ┘ä: ÏÑ┘å┘æ Ïú┘ê┘äϺϻ┘â┘à ┘ê┘äÏ»┘êϺ Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘üÏÀÏ▒Ï® ┘ü┘äϺ ϬÏ│┘é┘ê┘ç┘à Ϻ┘äÏ│┘âÏ▒Ïî ┘üÏÑ┘å┘æ Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣Ï▓ ┘êϼ┘ä ┘ä┘à ┘èϼÏ╣┘ä Ï┤┘üϺÏí┘â┘à ┘ü┘è┘àϺ Ï¡Ï▒┘æ┘à Ï╣┘ä┘è┘â┘à.
┘êÏ▒┘êϺϬ┘ç Ͻ┘éϺϬ ÏÑ┘äϺ Ïú┘å┘æ Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ│┘èÏ¿ Ï¿┘å Ï▒Ϻ┘üÏ╣ ┘ä┘à ┘è┘ä┘é ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ│Ï╣┘êÏ».
1196 - "ÏÑ┘å┘æ Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ┘ä┘à ┘èϼÏ╣┘ä Ï┤┘üϺÏí┘â┘à ┘ü┘è┘àϺ Ï¡Ï▒┘æ┘à Ï╣┘ä┘è┘â┘à"
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äϡϺ┘üÏ©: ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ÏúÏ¿┘ê ┘èÏ╣┘ä┘ë ┘êÏÁϡϡ┘ç ϺϿ┘å ϡϿϺ┘å ┘à┘å ϡϻ┘èϽ Ïú┘à Ï│┘ä┘àÏ® ┘éϺ┘äϬ: ϺÏ┤Ϭ┘âϬ Ï¿┘åϬ ┘ä┘è ┘ü┘åÏ¿Ï░Ϭ ┘ä┘çϺ ┘ü┘è ┘â┘Å┘êÏ▓┘ì ┘üϻϫ┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘åÏ¿┘è - ÏÁ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ┘êÏ│┘ä┘à - ┘ê┘ç┘ê ┘èÏ║┘ä┘è ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä "┘àϺ ┘çÏ░Ϻσ " ┘üÏúϫϿÏ▒Ϭ┘ç ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä: ┘üÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç" (9)
Ϻ┘åÏ©Ï▒ Ϻ┘äϡϻ┘èϽ Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è ┘éÏ¿┘ä┘ç.
__________
(1) Ϻ┘äϡϻ┘èϽ ┘ä┘à Ïúϼϻ┘ç ┘ü┘è Ï│┘å┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è ϻϺ┘êÏ» ┘ê┘ä┘èÏ│ ┘ç┘ê ┘ü┘è┘çÏî ┘êÏúÏ©┘å┘ç ┘ê┘ç┘àϺ ┘à┘å Ϻ┘äϡϺ┘üÏ© Ïú┘ê ┘ç┘ê ϬÏÁÏ¡┘è┘ü ┘üÏÑ┘å┘æ┘ç ┘éÏ» Ï░┘âÏ▒ Ϻ┘äϡϻ┘èϽ ┘ü┘è ┘âϬϺϿ Ϻ┘äÏúÏ┤Ï▒ϿϮ- ϿϺϿ Ï┤Ï▒Ï¿ Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘ä┘êϺÏí ┘êϺ┘äÏ╣Ï│┘ä ┘ê┘åÏ│Ï¿┘ç ÏÑ┘ä┘ë ÏúÏ¿┘è ┘èÏ╣┘ä┘ë ┘êϺϿ┘å ϡϿϺ┘åÏî ┘êÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘ä┘àÏÀϺ┘äÏ¿ Ϻ┘äÏ╣Ϻ┘ä┘èÏ®" (2462) ┘ê┘åÏ│Ï¿┘ç ÏÑ┘ä┘ë ÏúÏ¿┘è ┘èÏ╣┘ä┘ëÏî ┘êÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç Ϻ┘ä┘ç┘èϽ┘à┘è ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘ä┘àϼ┘àÏ╣" (5/ 86) ┘ê┘åÏ│Ï¿┘ç ÏÑ┘ä┘ë ÏúÏ¿┘è ┘èÏ╣┘ä┘ë ┘êϺ┘äÏ¿Ï▓ϺÏ▒Ïî ┘êÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ│ϫϺ┘ê┘è ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘ä┘à┘éϺÏÁÏ»" (ÏÁ 119) ┘ê┘åÏ│Ï¿┘ç ÏÑ┘ä┘ë ϺϿ┘å ϡϿϺ┘å ┘êÏúÏ¿┘è ┘èÏ╣┘ä┘ë ┘êϺ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è.
┘ê┘à┘àϺ ┘è┘é┘ê┘è Ïú┘å┘æ ÏúϿϺ ϻϺ┘êÏ» ┘ä┘à ┘èÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç Ïú┘å┘æ Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ϻ┘ê┘è Ï╣┘å Ïú┘à Ï│┘ä┘àÏ® ┘ê┘ç┘ê Ï¡Ï│Ϻ┘å Ï¿┘å ┘àϫϺÏ▒┘é Ϻ┘ä┘â┘ê┘ü┘è ┘ä┘èÏ│Ϭ ┘ä┘ç Ï▒┘êϺ┘èÏ®
┘ü┘è Ϻ┘ä┘âϬϿ Ϻ┘äÏ│ϬϮ ┘ê┘äÏ░┘ä┘â ┘ä┘à ┘èϬÏ▒ϼ┘à ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äϬ┘çÏ░┘èÏ¿" ┘êϬ┘êϺϿÏ╣┘ç.
(2) 1/ 352 (┘âϬϺϿ Ϻ┘ä┘êÏÂ┘êÏí- ϿϺϿ ÏúÏ¿┘êϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏÑÏ¿┘ä)
(3) 12/ 181 (┘âϬϺϿ Ϻ┘äÏúÏ┤Ï▒ϿϮ- ϿϺϿ Ï┤Ï▒ϺϿ Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘ä┘êϺÏí ┘êϺ┘äÏ╣Ï│┘ä)
(4) 17/ 21 (┘âϬϺϿ Ϻ┘äϺÏ╣ϬÏÁϺ┘à- ϿϺϿ Ϻ┘äϺ┘éϬϻϺÏí Ï¿Ï│┘å┘å Ï▒Ï│┘ê┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç - ÏÁ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ┘êÏ│┘ä┘à -)
(5) ┘ê┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é┘ç ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ϺϿ┘å Ï╣Ͽϻ Ϻ┘äÏ¿Ï▒ ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äϬ┘à┘ç┘èÏ»" (24/ 200)
┘êÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ÏúÏ¡┘àÏ» ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äÏúÏ┤Ï▒ϿϮ" (130) Ï╣┘å Ï│┘ü┘èϺ┘å Ï¿┘å Ï╣┘è┘è┘åÏ® Ï¿┘ç.
(6) ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ç┘èϽ┘à┘è: ┘êÏ▒ϼϺ┘ä┘ç Ï▒ϼϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡" Ϻ┘ä┘àϼ┘àÏ╣ 5/ 86
(7) ┘ê┘à┘å ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç Ï╣Ͽϻ Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï▓Ϻ┘é (17097┘ê 17098) ┘êϺ┘äÏÀϡϺ┘ê┘è ┘ü┘è "Ï┤Ï▒Ï¡ Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ╣Ϻ┘å┘è" (1/ 108) ┘êÏúÏ¿┘ê Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èÏ« ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äÏú┘éÏ▒Ϻ┘å" (136) ┘êϺ┘äϡϺ┘â┘à (4/ 218) ┘êϺ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è (10/ 5) ┘êϺ┘äÏ«ÏÀÏ¿ ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äÏúÏ│┘àϺÏí Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ¿┘ç┘àÏ®" (ÏÁ 71 ┘ê 72)
(8) ┘êÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ┘àÏ│ϻϻ ┘ü┘è "┘àÏ│┘åÏ»┘ç" (Ϻ┘ä┘àÏÀϺ┘äÏ¿ 2522) Ï╣┘å ┘èÏ¡┘è┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘éÏÀϺ┘å Ï╣┘å Ï│┘ü┘èϺ┘å Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘äÏúÏ╣┘àÏ┤ Ï╣┘å ┘àÏ│┘ä┘à Ï╣┘å ┘àÏ│Ï▒┘ê┘é Ï¿┘ç.
(9) 12/ 181 (┘âϬϺϿ Ϻ┘äÏúÏ┤Ï▒ϿϮ- ϿϺϿ Ï┤Ï▒ϺϿ Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘ä┘êϺÏí ┘êϺ┘äÏ╣Ï│┘ä)
Ϻ┘ä┘âϬϺϿ: Ïú┘å┘É┘èÏ│┘ŠϺ┘äÏ│┘æ┘ÄϺÏ▒┘è ┘ü┘è ϬϫÏ▒┘èϼ ┘ê┘ÄϬϡ┘é┘è┘é Ϻ┘äÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ Ϻ┘äϬ┘è Ï░┘âÏ▒┘çϺ Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘ÄϺ┘üÏ© ϺϿ┘å Ï¡┘ÄϼÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏ╣Ï│┘é┘äϺ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è ┘ü┘ÄϬϡ Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘ÄϺÏ▒┘è
Ϻ┘ä┘àÏñ┘ä┘ü: ÏúÏ¿┘ê Ï¡Ï░┘è┘üÏ®Ïî ┘åÏ¿┘è┘ä Ï¿┘å ┘à┘åÏÁ┘êÏ▒ Ï¿┘å ┘èÏ╣┘é┘êÏ¿ Ï¿┘å Ï│┘äÏÀϺ┘å Ϻ┘äÏ¿ÏÁϺÏ▒Ï® Ϻ┘ä┘â┘ê┘èϬ┘è
Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ¡┘é┘é: ┘åÏ¿┘è┘ä Ï¿┘å ┘à┘Ä┘åÏÁ┘êÏ▒ Ï¿┘å ┘è┘ÄÏ╣┘é┘êÏ¿ Ϻ┘äÏ¿ÏÁϺÏ▒Ï®
Ï░┘âÏ▒┘ç Ϻ┘äϡϺ┘üÏ© ┘ü┘è Ͻ┘äϺϽϮ ┘à┘êϺÏÂÏ╣:
┘éϺ┘ä ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏú┘ê┘ä: Ï▒┘êϺ┘ç ÏúÏ¿┘ê ϻϺ┘êÏ» (1) ┘à┘å ϡϻ┘èϽ Ïú┘à Ï│┘ä┘àÏ®" (2)
┘ê┘éϺ┘ä ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äϽϺ┘å┘è: ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ÏúÏ¿┘ê ┘èÏ╣┘ä┘ë ┘êÏÁϡϡ┘ç ϺϿ┘å ϡϿϺ┘å" (3)
┘ê┘éϺ┘ä ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äϽϺ┘äϽ: ┘ê┘ä┘ç (Ïú┘è ÏúÏ¿┘è ϻϺ┘êÏ») Ï╣┘å Ïú┘à Ï│┘ä┘àÏ® ┘àÏ▒┘ü┘êÏ╣Ϻ: ┘üÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç" (4)
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ÏúÏ¡┘àÏ» ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äÏúÏ┤Ï▒ϿϮ" (159) ┘êϺϿ┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è Ϻ┘äÏ»┘å┘èϺ ┘ü┘è "Ï░┘à Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ│┘âÏ▒" (12) ┘êÏúÏ¿┘ê ┘èÏ╣┘ä┘ë (6966) ┘êϺϿ┘å ϡϿϺ┘å (1391) ┘êϺ┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘ä┘âÏ¿┘èÏ▒" (23/ 326 - 327) ┘êϺ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è (10/ 5) ┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘é Ï╣┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è ÏÑÏ│ϡϺ┘é Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èϿϺ┘å┘è Ï╣┘å Ï¡Ï│Ϻ┘å Ï¿┘å ┘àϫϺÏ▒┘é ┘éϺ┘ä: ┘éϺ┘äϬ Ïú┘à Ï│┘ä┘àÏ®: ϺÏ┤Ϭ┘âϬ ϺϿ┘åÏ® ┘ä┘èÏî ┘ü┘Ä┘å┘ÄÏ¿┘ÄÏ░┘ÆÏ¬┘Å ┘ä┘çϺ ┘ü┘è ┘â┘Å┘ê┘ÆÏ▓Ïî ┘üϻϫ┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘åÏ¿┘è - ÏÁ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ┘êÏ│┘ä┘à - ┘ê┘ç┘ê ┘èÏ║┘ä┘èÏî ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä "┘àϺ ┘çÏ░Ϻσ " ┘ü┘éϺ┘äϬ: ÏÑ┘å┘æ ϺϿ┘åϬ┘è ϺÏ┤Ϭ┘âϬ ┘ü┘åÏ¿Ï░┘åϺ ┘ä┘çϺ ┘çÏ░ϺÏî ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä "ÏÑ┘å┘æ Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ┘ä┘à ┘èϼÏ╣┘ä Ï┤┘üϺÏí┘â┘à ┘ü┘è Ï¡Ï▒Ϻ┘à"
┘ê┘ü┘è ┘ä┘üÏ© "┘ü┘è┘àϺ Ï¡Ï▒┘æ┘à Ï╣┘ä┘è┘â┘à".
┘éϺ┘ä ϺϿ┘å Ï¡Ï▓┘à: ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äϡϻ┘èϽ ϿϺÏÀ┘ä ┘äÏú┘å┘æ Ï▒Ϻ┘ê┘è┘ç Ï│┘ä┘è┘àϺ┘å Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èϿϺ┘å┘è ┘ê┘ç┘ê ┘àϼ┘ç┘ê┘ä" Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ¡┘ä┘ë 1/ 233
┘é┘äϬ: Ï¿┘ä ┘ç┘ê ┘àÏ╣Ï▒┘ê┘ü ┘ê┘ç┘ê Ï│┘ä┘è┘àϺ┘å Ï¿┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è Ï│┘ä┘è┘àϺ┘å ÏúÏ¿┘ê ÏÑÏ│ϡϺ┘é Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èϿϺ┘å┘è Ϻ┘ä┘â┘ê┘ü┘è ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ ┘ä┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ│ϬϮ ┘ê┘êϽ┘é┘ç ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ╣┘è┘å ┘êÏúÏ¿┘ê ϡϺϬ┘à ┘êϺ┘ä┘åÏ│ϺϪ┘è ┘êÏúÏ¿┘ê ϻϺ┘êÏ» ┘êϺ┘äÏ╣ϼ┘ä┘è ┘êϺ┘äϻϺÏ▒┘éÏÀ┘å┘è ┘êÏ║┘èÏ▒┘ç┘à.
┘êÏ¡Ï│Ϻ┘å Ï¿┘å ┘àϫϺÏ▒┘é Ï░┘âÏ▒┘ç ϺϿ┘å ϡϿϺ┘å ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äϽ┘éϺϬ" Ï╣┘ä┘ë ┘éϺÏ╣ϻϬ┘ç ┘ê┘ä┘à ┘èÏ░┘âÏ▒ Ï╣┘å┘ç Ï▒Ϻ┘ê┘èϺ ÏÑ┘äϺ ÏúϿϺ ÏÑÏ│ϡϺ┘é Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èϿϺ┘å┘è ┘ü┘ç┘ê ┘àϼ┘ç┘ê┘äÏî ┘ê┘äϺ ┘è┘ÅÏ»Ï▒┘ë ┘ç┘ä ┘ä┘é┘è Ïú┘à Ï│┘ä┘àÏ® Ïú┘à ┘äϺ.
┘ê┘éÏ» ÏÁÏ¡ Ϻ┘äϡϻ┘èϽ ┘à┘å ┘é┘ê┘ä ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ│Ï╣┘êÏ» Ï░┘âÏ▒┘ç Ϻ┘äϿϫϺÏ▒┘è ┘ü┘è "ÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡┘ç" (┘üϬϡ 12/ 180) ϬÏ╣┘ä┘è┘éϺ ┘êÏ¿ÏÁ┘èÏ║Ï® Ϻ┘äϼÏ▓┘à.
┘éϺ┘ä: ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ│Ï╣┘êÏ» ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ│┘æ┘Ä┘â┘ÄÏ▒: ÏÑ┘å┘æ Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ┘ä┘à ┘èϼÏ╣┘ä Ï┤┘üϺÏí┘â┘à ┘ü┘è┘àϺ Ï¡┘ÄÏ▒┘æ┘Ä┘à Ï╣┘ä┘è┘â┘à"
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äϡϺ┘üÏ©: ┘é┘äϬ: ┘éÏ» Ï▒┘ê┘èϬ Ϻ┘äÏúϽÏ▒ Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ░┘â┘êÏ▒ ┘ü┘è "┘ü┘êϺϪϻ" Ï╣┘ä┘è Ï¿┘å Ï¡Ï▒Ï¿ Ϻ┘äÏÀϺϪ┘è (5) Ï╣┘å Ï│┘ü┘èϺ┘å Ï¿┘å Ï╣┘Å┘è┘è┘åÏ® Ï╣┘å ┘à┘åÏÁ┘êÏ▒ Ï╣┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è ┘êϺϪ┘ä ┘éϺ┘ä: ϺÏ┤Ϭ┘â┘ë Ï▒ϼ┘ä ┘à┘åϺ ┘è┘éϺ┘ä ┘ä┘ç: Ï«┘èϽ┘à Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘äÏ╣ϻϺÏí ϻϺÏí ϿϿÏÀ┘å┘ç ┘è┘éϺ┘ä ┘ä┘ç Ϻ┘äÏÁ┘üÏ▒ ┘ü┘åÏ╣Ϭ ┘ä┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ│┘æ┘Ä┘â┘ÄÏ▒ ┘üÏúÏ▒Ï│┘ä ÏÑ┘ä┘ë ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ│Ï╣┘êÏ» ┘èÏ│Ïú┘ä┘ç ┘üÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç. ┘êÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ϺϿ┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è Ï┤┘èϿϮ (8/ 23) Ï╣┘å ϼÏ▒┘èÏ▒ Ï╣┘å ┘à┘åÏÁ┘êÏ▒ ┘êÏ│┘åÏ»┘ç ÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡ Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ï┤Ï▒ÏÀ Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èÏ«┘è┘å (6)Ïî ┘êÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ÏúÏ¡┘àÏ» ┘ü┘è ┘âϬϺϿ "Ϻ┘äÏúÏ┤Ï▒ϿϮ" (117) ┘êϺ┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘ä┘âÏ¿┘èÏ▒" (9714 ┘ê9715 ┘ê 9716) ┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é ÏúÏ¿┘è ┘êϺϪ┘ä (7) ┘åÏ¡┘ê┘çÏî ┘êÏ▒┘ê┘è┘åϺ ┘ü┘è ┘åÏ│ϫϮ ϻϺ┘êÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘åÏÁ┘èÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏÀϺϪ┘è Ï¿Ï│┘åÏ» ÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡ Ï╣┘å ┘àÏ│Ï▒┘ê┘é (8) ┘éϺ┘ä: ┘éϺ┘ä Ï╣Ͽϻ Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç- ┘ç┘ê ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ│Ï╣┘êÏ»-: ┘äϺ ϬÏ│┘é┘êϺ Ïú┘ê┘äϺϻ┘â┘à Ϻ┘äÏ«┘àÏ▒ ┘üÏÑ┘å┘æ┘ç┘à ┘ê┘äÏ»┘êϺ Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘üÏÀÏ▒Ï® ┘êÏÑ┘å┘æ Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ┘ä┘à ┘èϼÏ╣┘ä Ï┤┘üϺÏí┘â┘à ┘ü┘è┘àϺ Ï¡Ï▒┘æ┘à Ï╣┘ä┘è┘â┘à. ┘êÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ϺϿ┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è Ï┤┘èϿϮ ┘à┘å ┘êϼ┘ç ÏóÏ«Ï▒ Ï╣┘å ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ│Ï╣┘êÏ» ┘âÏ░┘ä┘âÏî ┘êÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ ÏÑÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘ç┘è┘à Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï▒Ï¿┘è ┘ü┘è "Ï║Ï▒┘èÏ¿ Ϻ┘äϡϻ┘èϽ" ┘à┘å ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘ä┘êϼ┘ç ┘éϺ┘ä: ÏúϬ┘è┘åϺ Ï╣Ͽϻ Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ┘ü┘è ┘àϼϻÏ▒┘è┘å Ïú┘ê ┘àÏ¡ÏÁÏ¿┘è┘å ┘åÏ╣Ϭ ┘ä┘ç┘à Ϻ┘äÏ│┘âÏ▒ ┘üÏ░┘âÏ▒ ┘àϽ┘ä┘ç" Ϻ┘ä┘üϬϡ 12/ 181
┘êÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç Ï╣Ͽϻ Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï▓Ϻ┘é (17102) ┘êϺ┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘ä┘âÏ¿┘èÏ▒" (9717) ┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é Ï¡┘àϺϻ Ï╣┘å ÏÑÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘ç┘è┘à ┘éϺ┘ä: ┘éϺ┘ä ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ│Ï╣┘êÏ»: ┘äϺ ϬÏ│┘é┘êϺ Ïú┘ê┘äϺϻ┘â┘à Ϻ┘äÏ«┘àÏ▒Ïî Ï¿┘åÏ¡┘ê Ï▒┘êϺ┘èÏ® ┘àÏ│Ï▒┘ê┘é.
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ç┘èϽ┘à┘è: ┘êÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ┘ç ┘à┘å┘éÏÀÏ╣ ┘êÏ▒ϼϺ┘ä┘ç Ï▒ϼϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡" Ϻ┘ä┘àϼ┘àÏ╣ 5/ 72
┘êÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ÏúÏ¡┘àÏ» ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äÏúÏ┤Ï▒ϿϮ" (133) Ï╣┘å ┘àÏ¡┘àÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘üÏÂ┘è┘ä Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘äÏ╣┘äϺÏí Ï╣┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è┘ç Ï╣┘å ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ│Ï╣┘êÏ» ┘éϺ┘ä: ÏÑ┘å┘æ Ïú┘ê┘äϺϻ┘â┘à ┘ê┘äÏ»┘êϺ Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘üÏÀÏ▒Ï® ┘ü┘äϺ ϬÏ│┘é┘ê┘ç┘à Ϻ┘äÏ│┘âÏ▒Ïî ┘üÏÑ┘å┘æ Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣Ï▓ ┘êϼ┘ä ┘ä┘à ┘èϼÏ╣┘ä Ï┤┘üϺÏí┘â┘à ┘ü┘è┘àϺ Ï¡Ï▒┘æ┘à Ï╣┘ä┘è┘â┘à.
┘êÏ▒┘êϺϬ┘ç Ͻ┘éϺϬ ÏÑ┘äϺ Ïú┘å┘æ Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ│┘èÏ¿ Ï¿┘å Ï▒Ϻ┘üÏ╣ ┘ä┘à ┘è┘ä┘é ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ│Ï╣┘êÏ».
1196 - "ÏÑ┘å┘æ Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ┘ä┘à ┘èϼÏ╣┘ä Ï┤┘üϺÏí┘â┘à ┘ü┘è┘àϺ Ï¡Ï▒┘æ┘à Ï╣┘ä┘è┘â┘à"
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äϡϺ┘üÏ©: ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ÏúÏ¿┘ê ┘èÏ╣┘ä┘ë ┘êÏÁϡϡ┘ç ϺϿ┘å ϡϿϺ┘å ┘à┘å ϡϻ┘èϽ Ïú┘à Ï│┘ä┘àÏ® ┘éϺ┘äϬ: ϺÏ┤Ϭ┘âϬ Ï¿┘åϬ ┘ä┘è ┘ü┘åÏ¿Ï░Ϭ ┘ä┘çϺ ┘ü┘è ┘â┘Å┘êÏ▓┘ì ┘üϻϫ┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘åÏ¿┘è - ÏÁ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ┘êÏ│┘ä┘à - ┘ê┘ç┘ê ┘èÏ║┘ä┘è ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä "┘àϺ ┘çÏ░Ϻσ " ┘üÏúϫϿÏ▒Ϭ┘ç ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä: ┘üÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç" (9)
Ϻ┘åÏ©Ï▒ Ϻ┘äϡϻ┘èϽ Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è ┘éÏ¿┘ä┘ç.
__________
(1) Ϻ┘äϡϻ┘èϽ ┘ä┘à Ïúϼϻ┘ç ┘ü┘è Ï│┘å┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è ϻϺ┘êÏ» ┘ê┘ä┘èÏ│ ┘ç┘ê ┘ü┘è┘çÏî ┘êÏúÏ©┘å┘ç ┘ê┘ç┘àϺ ┘à┘å Ϻ┘äϡϺ┘üÏ© Ïú┘ê ┘ç┘ê ϬÏÁÏ¡┘è┘ü ┘üÏÑ┘å┘æ┘ç ┘éÏ» Ï░┘âÏ▒ Ϻ┘äϡϻ┘èϽ ┘ü┘è ┘âϬϺϿ Ϻ┘äÏúÏ┤Ï▒ϿϮ- ϿϺϿ Ï┤Ï▒Ï¿ Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘ä┘êϺÏí ┘êϺ┘äÏ╣Ï│┘ä ┘ê┘åÏ│Ï¿┘ç ÏÑ┘ä┘ë ÏúÏ¿┘è ┘èÏ╣┘ä┘ë ┘êϺϿ┘å ϡϿϺ┘åÏî ┘êÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘ä┘àÏÀϺ┘äÏ¿ Ϻ┘äÏ╣Ϻ┘ä┘èÏ®" (2462) ┘ê┘åÏ│Ï¿┘ç ÏÑ┘ä┘ë ÏúÏ¿┘è ┘èÏ╣┘ä┘ëÏî ┘êÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç Ϻ┘ä┘ç┘èϽ┘à┘è ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘ä┘àϼ┘àÏ╣" (5/ 86) ┘ê┘åÏ│Ï¿┘ç ÏÑ┘ä┘ë ÏúÏ¿┘è ┘èÏ╣┘ä┘ë ┘êϺ┘äÏ¿Ï▓ϺÏ▒Ïî ┘êÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ│ϫϺ┘ê┘è ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘ä┘à┘éϺÏÁÏ»" (ÏÁ 119) ┘ê┘åÏ│Ï¿┘ç ÏÑ┘ä┘ë ϺϿ┘å ϡϿϺ┘å ┘êÏúÏ¿┘è ┘èÏ╣┘ä┘ë ┘êϺ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è.
┘ê┘à┘àϺ ┘è┘é┘ê┘è Ïú┘å┘æ ÏúϿϺ ϻϺ┘êÏ» ┘ä┘à ┘èÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç Ïú┘å┘æ Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ϻ┘ê┘è Ï╣┘å Ïú┘à Ï│┘ä┘àÏ® ┘ê┘ç┘ê Ï¡Ï│Ϻ┘å Ï¿┘å ┘àϫϺÏ▒┘é Ϻ┘ä┘â┘ê┘ü┘è ┘ä┘èÏ│Ϭ ┘ä┘ç Ï▒┘êϺ┘èÏ®
┘ü┘è Ϻ┘ä┘âϬϿ Ϻ┘äÏ│ϬϮ ┘ê┘äÏ░┘ä┘â ┘ä┘à ┘èϬÏ▒ϼ┘à ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äϬ┘çÏ░┘èÏ¿" ┘êϬ┘êϺϿÏ╣┘ç.
(2) 1/ 352 (┘âϬϺϿ Ϻ┘ä┘êÏÂ┘êÏí- ϿϺϿ ÏúÏ¿┘êϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏÑÏ¿┘ä)
(3) 12/ 181 (┘âϬϺϿ Ϻ┘äÏúÏ┤Ï▒ϿϮ- ϿϺϿ Ï┤Ï▒ϺϿ Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘ä┘êϺÏí ┘êϺ┘äÏ╣Ï│┘ä)
(4) 17/ 21 (┘âϬϺϿ Ϻ┘äϺÏ╣ϬÏÁϺ┘à- ϿϺϿ Ϻ┘äϺ┘éϬϻϺÏí Ï¿Ï│┘å┘å Ï▒Ï│┘ê┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç - ÏÁ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ┘êÏ│┘ä┘à -)
(5) ┘ê┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é┘ç ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ϺϿ┘å Ï╣Ͽϻ Ϻ┘äÏ¿Ï▒ ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äϬ┘à┘ç┘èÏ»" (24/ 200)
┘êÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ÏúÏ¡┘àÏ» ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äÏúÏ┤Ï▒ϿϮ" (130) Ï╣┘å Ï│┘ü┘èϺ┘å Ï¿┘å Ï╣┘è┘è┘åÏ® Ï¿┘ç.
(6) ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ç┘èϽ┘à┘è: ┘êÏ▒ϼϺ┘ä┘ç Ï▒ϼϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡" Ϻ┘ä┘àϼ┘àÏ╣ 5/ 86
(7) ┘ê┘à┘å ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç Ï╣Ͽϻ Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï▓Ϻ┘é (17097┘ê 17098) ┘êϺ┘äÏÀϡϺ┘ê┘è ┘ü┘è "Ï┤Ï▒Ï¡ Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ╣Ϻ┘å┘è" (1/ 108) ┘êÏúÏ¿┘ê Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èÏ« ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äÏú┘éÏ▒Ϻ┘å" (136) ┘êϺ┘äϡϺ┘â┘à (4/ 218) ┘êϺ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è (10/ 5) ┘êϺ┘äÏ«ÏÀÏ¿ ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äÏúÏ│┘àϺÏí Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ¿┘ç┘àÏ®" (ÏÁ 71 ┘ê 72)
(8) ┘êÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ┘àÏ│ϻϻ ┘ü┘è "┘àÏ│┘åÏ»┘ç" (Ϻ┘ä┘àÏÀϺ┘äÏ¿ 2522) Ï╣┘å ┘èÏ¡┘è┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘éÏÀϺ┘å Ï╣┘å Ï│┘ü┘èϺ┘å Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘äÏúÏ╣┘àÏ┤ Ï╣┘å ┘àÏ│┘ä┘à Ï╣┘å ┘àÏ│Ï▒┘ê┘é Ï¿┘ç.
(9) 12/ 181 (┘âϬϺϿ Ϻ┘äÏúÏ┤Ï▒ϿϮ- ϿϺϿ Ï┤Ï▒ϺϿ Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘ä┘êϺÏí ┘êϺ┘äÏ╣Ï│┘ä)
Ϻ┘ä┘âϬϺϿ: Ïú┘å┘É┘èÏ│┘ŠϺ┘äÏ│┘æ┘ÄϺÏ▒┘è ┘ü┘è ϬϫÏ▒┘èϼ ┘ê┘ÄϬϡ┘é┘è┘é Ϻ┘äÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ Ϻ┘äϬ┘è Ï░┘âÏ▒┘çϺ Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘ÄϺ┘üÏ© ϺϿ┘å Ï¡┘ÄϼÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏ╣Ï│┘é┘äϺ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è ┘ü┘ÄϬϡ Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘ÄϺÏ▒┘è
Ϻ┘ä┘àÏñ┘ä┘ü: ÏúÏ¿┘ê Ï¡Ï░┘è┘üÏ®Ïî ┘åÏ¿┘è┘ä Ï¿┘å ┘à┘åÏÁ┘êÏ▒ Ï¿┘å ┘èÏ╣┘é┘êÏ¿ Ï¿┘å Ï│┘äÏÀϺ┘å Ϻ┘äÏ¿ÏÁϺÏ▒Ï® Ϻ┘ä┘â┘ê┘èϬ┘è
Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ¡┘é┘é: ┘åÏ¿┘è┘ä Ï¿┘å ┘à┘Ä┘åÏÁ┘êÏ▒ Ï¿┘å ┘è┘ÄÏ╣┘é┘êÏ¿ Ϻ┘äÏ¿ÏÁϺÏ▒Ï®
Comment