ÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ ┘äϺϬÏÁÏ¡ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é

731 - " ϬÏ▓┘êϼ┘êϺ ┘ê┘äϺ ϬÏÀ┘ä┘é┘êϺ Ïî ┘üÏÑ┘å Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é ┘è┘çϬÏ▓ ┘ä┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ╣Ï▒Ï┤ " .
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏú┘äϿϺ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ│┘äÏ│┘äÏ® Ϻ┘äÏÂÏ╣┘è┘üÏ®:
┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣ .
Ï▒┘êϺ┘ç ÏúÏ¿┘ê ┘åÏ╣┘è┘à ┘ü┘è ÏúϫϿϺÏ▒ ÏúÏÁÏ¿┘çϺ┘å " ( 1 / 157 ) ┘êÏ╣┘å┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ»┘è┘ä┘à┘è ( 2 / 1 / 30 ) ┘êϺ┘äÏ«ÏÀ┘èÏ¿ ┘ü┘è " ϬϺÏ▒┘èÏ«┘ç " ( 12 / 191 ) ┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é Ï╣┘àÏ▒┘ê Ï¿┘å ϼ┘à┘èÏ╣ Ï╣┘å ϼ┘ê┘èÏ¿Ï▒ Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘äÏÂϡϺ┘â Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘ä┘åÏ▓Ϻ┘ä Ï¿┘å Ï│Ï¿Ï▒Ï® Ï╣┘å Ï╣┘ä┘è Ï¿┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è ÏÀϺ┘äÏ¿ ┘àÏ▒┘ü┘êÏ╣Ϻ . Ï│Ϻ┘é┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ«ÏÀ┘èÏ¿ ┘ü┘è ϬÏ▒ϼ┘àÏ® Ï╣┘àÏ▒┘ê ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ï¿Ï╣Ï» Ïú┘å ┘éϺ┘ä ┘ü┘è┘ç : " ┘âϺ┘å ┘èÏ▒┘ê┘è Ϻ┘ä┘à┘åϺ┘â┘èÏ▒ Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ┤Ϻ┘ç┘èÏ▒ Ïî ┘êϺ┘ä┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣ϺϬ Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘äÏúϽϿϺϬ " .
┘êÏ▒┘ê┘ë Ï╣┘å ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ╣┘è┘å Ïú┘å┘ç ┘éϺ┘ä ┘ü┘è┘ç : " ┘âϺ┘å ┘âÏ░ϺϿϺ Ï«Ï¿┘èϽϺ " . ┘êϺ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ Ïú┘êÏ▒Ï»┘ç ϺϿ┘å Ϻ┘äϼ┘êÏ▓┘è ┘ü┘è " Ϻ┘ä┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣ϺϬ " ┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é Ϻ┘äÏ«ÏÀ┘èÏ¿ ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä : " ┘äϺ ┘èÏÁÏ¡ ┘ü┘è┘ç Ïó┘üϺϬ Ïî Ϻ┘äÏÂϡϺ┘â ┘àϼÏ▒┘êÏ¡ Ïî ┘êϼ┘ê┘èÏ¿Ï▒ ┘ä┘èÏ│ Ï¿Ï┤┘èÏí Ïî ┘êÏ╣┘àÏ▒┘ê ┘éϺ┘ä ϺϿ┘å Ï╣Ï»┘è : ┘âϺ┘å ┘èϬ┘ç┘à
ϿϺ┘ä┘êÏÂÏ╣ " . ┘êÏú┘éÏ▒┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ│┘è┘êÏÀ┘è ┘ü┘è " Ϻ┘ä┘äÏó┘ä┘èÏí " ( Ï▒┘é┘à 1916 ϿϬÏ▒┘é┘è┘à┘è ) Ͻ┘à ϺϿ┘å Ï╣Ï▒Ϻ┘é ┘ü┘è " Ϭ┘åÏ▓┘è┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ┤Ï▒┘èÏ╣Ï® Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ▒┘ü┘êÏ╣Ï® Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘äÏúϫϿϺÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘å┘èÏ╣Ï® Ϻ┘ä┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣Ï® " ( 301 / 1 ) Ïî ┘ê┘àÏ╣ Ï░┘ä┘â ┘ü┘éÏ» Ïú┘êÏ▒Ï»┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ│┘è┘êÏÀ┘è ┘ü┘è " Ϻ┘äϼϺ┘àÏ╣ Ϻ┘äÏÁÏ║┘èÏ▒ " !
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ê┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ ┘è┘ä┘çϼ Ï¿┘ç ┘âϽ┘èÏ▒ ┘à┘å Ϻ┘äÏ«ÏÀϿϺÏí Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è┘å ┘è┘âϺϻ┘ê┘å ┘èÏÁÏ▒Ï¡┘ê┘å ϿϬϡÏ▒┘è┘à Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è ÏúϿϺϡ┘ç Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ϬϿϺÏ▒┘â ┘êϬÏ╣Ϻ┘ä┘ë Ïî ┘êÏ¿Ï╣ÏÂ┘ç┘à ┘èÏÂÏ╣ Ϻ┘ä┘é┘è┘êÏ» Ϻ┘äÏ╣┘à┘ä┘èÏ® ┘ä┘à┘åÏ╣ ┘ê┘é┘êÏ╣ Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é Ïî ┘ê┘ä┘ê┘âϺ┘å Ï¿┘àÏ¡Ï ϺϫϬ┘èϺÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏ▓┘êϼ ! ┘üÏÑ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ┤Ϭ┘â┘ë .

Ï▒Ï»: ÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ ┘äϺϬÏÁÏ¡ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é

1171 - " ┘à┘å Ϻ┘éϬÏ▒ϺϿ Ϻ┘äÏ│ϺÏ╣Ï® ϺϽ┘åϬϺ┘å ┘êÏ│Ï¿Ï╣┘ê┘å Ï«ÏÁ┘äÏ®Ïî ÏÑÏ░Ϻ Ï▒Ïú┘èϬ┘à Ϻ┘ä┘åϺÏ│ Ïú┘àϺϬ┘êϺ Ϻ┘äÏÁ┘äϺϮÏî
┘êÏúÏÂϺÏ╣┘êϺ Ϻ┘äÏú┘àϺ┘åÏ®Ïî ┘êÏú┘â┘ä┘êϺ Ϻ┘äÏ▒ϿϺÏî ┘êϺÏ│Ϭϡ┘ä┘êϺ Ϻ┘ä┘âÏ░Ï¿Ïî ┘êϺÏ│Ϭϫ┘ü┘êϺ Ϻ┘äÏ»┘àϺÏíÏî
┘êϺÏ│ϬÏ╣┘ä┘êϺ Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘åϺÏíÏî ┘êϿϺÏ╣┘êϺ Ϻ┘äÏ»┘è┘å ϿϺ┘äÏ»┘å┘èϺÏî ┘êϬ┘éÏÀÏ╣Ϭ Ϻ┘äÏúÏ▒ϡϺ┘àÏî ┘ê┘è┘â┘ê┘å Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘â┘à
ÏÂÏ╣┘üϺÏî ┘êϺ┘ä┘âÏ░Ï¿ ÏÁÏ»┘éϺÏî ┘êϺ┘äÏ¡Ï▒┘èÏ▒ ┘äϿϺÏ│ϺÏî ┘êÏ©┘çÏ▒ Ϻ┘äϼ┘êÏ▒Ïî ┘ê┘âϽÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é ┘ê┘à┘êϬ
Ϻ┘ä┘üϼÏúÏ®Ïî ┘êϺϪϬ┘à┘å Ϻ┘äϫϺϪ┘åÏî ┘êÏ«┘ê┘å Ϻ┘äÏú┘à┘è┘åÏî ┘êÏÁÏ»┘é Ϻ┘ä┘âϺÏ░Ï¿Ïî ┘ê┘âÏ░Ï¿ Ϻ┘äÏÁϺϻ┘éÏî ┘ê┘âϽÏ▒
Ϻ┘ä┘éÏ░┘üÏî ┘ê┘âϺ┘å Ϻ┘ä┘àÏÀÏ▒ ┘é┘èϩϺÏî ┘êϺ┘ä┘ê┘äÏ» Ï║┘èϩϺÏî ┘ê┘üϺÏ Ϻ┘ä┘äϪϺ┘à ┘ü┘èÏÂϺÏî ┘êÏ║ϺÏ Ϻ┘ä┘âÏ▒Ϻ┘à
Ï║┘èÏÂϺÏî ┘ê┘âϺ┘å Ϻ┘äÏú┘àÏ▒ϺÏí ┘üϼÏ▒Ï®Ïî ┘êϺ┘ä┘êÏ▓Ï▒ϺÏí ┘âÏ░Ï¿Ï®Ïî ┘êϺ┘äÏú┘à┘åϺÏí Ï«┘ê┘åÏ®Ïî ┘êϺ┘äÏ╣Ï▒┘üϺÏí Ï©┘ä┘àÏ®
Ïî ┘êϺ┘ä┘éÏ▒ϺÏí ┘üÏ│┘éÏ®Ïî ÏÑÏ░Ϻ ┘äÏ¿Ï│┘êϺ ┘àÏ│┘ê┘â Ϻ┘äÏÂÏú┘åÏî ┘é┘ä┘êÏ¿┘ç┘à Ïú┘åϬ┘å ┘à┘å Ϻ┘äϼ┘è┘üÏ® ┘êÏú┘àÏ▒ ┘à┘å
Ϻ┘äÏÁÏ¿Ï▒Ïî ┘èÏ║Ï┤┘è┘ç┘à Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ┘üϬ┘åÏ® ┘èϬ┘çϺ┘ê┘â┘ê┘å ┘ü┘è┘çϺ Ϭ┘çϺ┘ê┘â Ϻ┘ä┘è┘ç┘êÏ» Ϻ┘äÏ©┘ä┘àÏ®Ïî ┘êϬϩ┘çÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏÁ┘üÏ▒ϺÏí
- ┘èÏ╣┘å┘è Ϻ┘äÏ»┘åϺ┘å┘èÏ▒ - ┘êϬÏÀ┘äÏ¿ Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘èÏÂϺÏí - ┘èÏ╣┘å┘è Ϻ┘äÏ»Ï▒Ϻ┘ç┘à - ┘êϬ┘âϽÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏ«ÏÀϺ┘èϺÏî ┘êϬÏ║┘ä
Ϻ┘äÏú┘àÏ▒ϺÏíÏî ┘êÏ¡┘ä┘èϬ Ϻ┘ä┘àÏÁϺϡ┘üÏî ┘êÏÁ┘êÏ▒Ϭ Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ│ϺϼϻÏî ┘êÏÀ┘ê┘äϬ Ϻ┘ä┘à┘åϺϪÏ▒Ïî ┘êÏ«Ï▒ϿϬ Ϻ┘ä┘é┘ä┘êÏ¿Ïî
┘êÏ┤Ï▒ϿϬ Ϻ┘äÏ«┘à┘êÏ▒Ïî ┘êÏ╣ÏÀ┘äϬ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘êÏ»Ïî ┘ê┘ê┘äϻϬ Ϻ┘äÏú┘àÏ® Ï▒ϿϬ┘çϺÏî ┘êϬÏ▒┘ë Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘üϺϮ Ϻ┘äÏ╣Ï▒ϺϮÏî
┘ê┘éÏ» ÏÁϺÏ▒┘êϺ ┘à┘ä┘ê┘âϺÏî ┘êÏ┤ϺÏ▒┘âϬ Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ▒ϺϮ Ï▓┘êϼ┘çϺ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äϬϼϺÏ▒Ï®Ïî ┘êϬÏ┤Ï¿┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ▒ϼϺ┘ä ϿϺ┘ä┘åÏ│ϺÏíÏî
┘êϺ┘ä┘åÏ│ϺÏí ϿϺ┘äÏ▒ϼϺ┘äÏî ┘êÏ¡┘ä┘ü ϿϺ┘ä┘ä┘ç ┘à┘å Ï║┘èÏ▒ Ïú┘å ┘èÏ│Ϭϡ┘ä┘üÏî ┘êÏ┤┘çÏ» Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ▒Ïí ┘à┘å Ï║┘èÏ▒ Ïú┘å
┘èÏ│ϬÏ┤┘çÏ»Ïî ┘êÏ│┘ä┘à ┘ä┘ä┘àÏ╣Ï▒┘üÏ®Ïî ┘êϬ┘ü┘é┘ç ┘äÏ║┘èÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏ»┘è┘åÏî ┘êÏÀ┘äϿϬ Ϻ┘äÏ»┘å┘èϺ Ï¿Ï╣┘à┘ä Ϻ┘äÏóÏ«Ï▒Ï®Ïî
┘êϺϬϫÏ░ Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ║┘å┘à Ï»┘ê┘äϺÏî ┘êϺ┘äÏú┘àϺ┘åÏ® ┘àÏ║┘å┘àϺÏî ┘êϺ┘äÏ▓┘âϺϮ ┘àÏ║Ï▒┘àϺÏî ┘ê┘âϺ┘å Ï▓Ï╣┘è┘à Ϻ┘ä┘é┘ê┘à
ÏúÏ▒Ï░┘ä┘ç┘àÏî ┘êÏ╣┘é Ϻ┘äÏ▒ϼ┘ä ÏúϿϺ┘çÏî ┘êϼ┘üϺ Ïú┘à┘çÏî ┘êÏ¿Ï▒ ÏÁÏ»┘è┘é┘çÏî ┘êÏúÏÀϺÏ╣ Ï▓┘êϼϬ┘çÏî ┘êÏ╣┘äϬ
ÏúÏÁ┘êϺϬ Ϻ┘ä┘üÏ│┘éÏ® ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ│ϺϼϻÏî ┘êϺϬϫÏ░Ϭ Ϻ┘ä┘é┘è┘åϺϬ ┘êϺ┘ä┘àÏ╣ϺÏ▓┘üÏî ┘êÏ┤Ï▒ϿϬ Ϻ┘äÏ«┘à┘êÏ▒ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏÀÏ▒┘é
Ïî ┘êϺϬϫÏ░ Ϻ┘äÏ©┘ä┘à ┘üÏ«Ï▒ϺÏî ┘êÏ¿┘èÏ╣ Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘â┘àÏî ┘ê┘âϽÏ▒Ϭ Ϻ┘äÏ┤Ï▒ÏÀÏî ┘êϺϬϫÏ░ Ϻ┘ä┘éÏ▒Ïó┘å ┘àÏ▓Ϻ┘à┘èÏ▒Ïî
┘êϼ┘ä┘êÏ» Ϻ┘äÏ│ϿϺÏ╣ ÏÁ┘üϺ┘üϺÏî ┘êϺ┘ä┘àÏ│Ϻϼϻ ÏÀÏ▒┘éϺÏî ┘ê┘äÏ╣┘å ÏóÏ«Ï▒ ┘çÏ░┘ç Ϻ┘äÏú┘àÏ® Ïú┘ê┘ä┘çϺÏî ┘ü┘ä┘èϬ┘é┘êϺ (
┘âÏ░Ϻ ) Ï╣┘åÏ» Ï░┘ä┘â Ï▒┘èϡϺ Ï¡┘àÏ▒ϺÏíÏî ┘êÏ«Ï│┘üϺ ┘ê┘àÏ│ϫϺ ┘êÏó┘èϺϬ ".


ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ÏúÏ¿┘ê ┘åÏ╣┘è┘à ┘ü┘è " Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘ä┘èÏ® " ( 3/358 ) ┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é Ï│┘ê┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å Ï│Ï╣┘èÏ» Ï╣┘å ┘üÏ▒ϼ Ï¿┘å ┘üÏÂϺ┘äÏ®
Ï╣┘å Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï¿┘å Ï╣Ï¿┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å Ï╣┘à┘èÏ▒ Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘èϽ┘è Ï╣┘å Ï¡Ï░┘è┘üÏ® Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘ä┘è┘àϺ┘å ┘àÏ▒┘ü┘êÏ╣Ϻ. ┘éϺ┘ä ÏúÏ¿┘ê
┘åÏ╣┘è┘à :
" Ï║Ï▒┘èÏ¿ ┘à┘å Ï¡Ï»┘èϽ Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï¿┘å Ï╣Ï¿┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å Ï╣┘à┘èÏ▒Ïî ┘ä┘à ┘èÏ▒┘ê┘ç Ï╣┘å┘ç ┘ü┘è┘àϺ ÏúÏ╣┘ä┘à ÏÑ┘äϺ ┘üÏ▒ϼ Ï¿┘å
┘üÏÂϺ┘äÏ® ".
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ê┘ç┘ê ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü ┘â┘àϺ ┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äϡϺ┘üÏ© Ϻ┘äÏ╣Ï▒Ϻ┘é┘è ( 3/297 )Ïî ┘ê┘ü┘è┘ç Ï╣┘äÏ® ÏúÏ«Ï▒┘ë ┘ê┘ç┘è
Ϻ┘äϺ┘å┘éÏÀϺÏ╣Ïî ┘ü┘éÏ» ┘éϺ┘ä ÏúÏ¿┘ê ┘åÏ╣┘è┘à ┘ü┘è ϬÏ▒ϼ┘àÏ® Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï¿┘å Ï╣Ï¿┘èÏ» ┘çÏ░Ϻ ( 3/356 ) :
" ÏúÏ▒Ï│┘ä Ï╣┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è Ϻ┘äÏ»Ï▒ϻϺÏí ┘êÏ¡Ï░┘è┘üÏ® ┘êÏ║┘èÏ▒┘ç┘à ".
┘ê┘ä┘ä┘üÏ▒ϼ ┘ü┘è┘ç ÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ ÏóÏ«Ï▒ Ï¿┘ä┘üÏ© ÏúÏ«ÏÁÏ▒ Ϭ┘éÏ»┘à Ïó┘å┘üϺ.
┘êϺ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ ┘à┘àϺ ┘üϺϬ Ϻ┘äÏ│┘è┘êÏÀ┘è ┘êϺ┘ä┘à┘åϺ┘ê┘è ┘ü┘ä┘à ┘è┘êÏ▒ϻϺ┘ç ┘ü┘è " ϼϺ┘àÏ╣┘è┘ç┘àϺ ".

Ï▒Ï»: ÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ ┘äϺϬÏÁÏ¡ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é

3149 - ( ÏÑ┘å Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ┘èÏ¿Ï║Ï Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é Ïî ┘ê┘èÏ¡Ï¿ Ϻ┘äÏ╣ϬϺ┘é ) .
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏú┘äϿϺ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ│┘äÏ│┘äÏ® Ϻ┘äÏÂÏ╣┘è┘üÏ®:
ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü
Ï▒┘êϺ┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ»┘è┘ä┘à┘è (1/ 2/ 244) Ï╣┘å ┘àÏ¡┘àÏ» Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï¿┘èÏ╣ : ϡϻϽ┘åϺ ÏúÏ¿┘è Ï╣┘å Ï¡┘à┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘àϺ┘ä┘â Ï╣┘å ┘à┘âÏ¡┘ê┘ä Ï╣┘å ┘àÏ╣ϺÏ░ Ï¿┘å ϼϿ┘ä ┘àÏ▒┘ü┘êÏ╣Ϻ┘ï .
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ê┘çÏ░Ϻ ÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü Ïø ┘à┘âÏ¡┘ê┘ä ┘ä┘à ┘èÏ│┘àÏ╣ ┘à┘å ┘àÏ╣ϺÏ░ .
┘êÏ¡┘à┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘àϺ┘ä┘â ÏÂÏ╣┘ü┘ç ┘èÏ¡┘è┘ë ┘êÏúÏ¿┘ê Ï▓Ï▒Ï╣Ï® ┘êÏ║┘èÏ▒┘ç┘àϺ .

Ï▒Ï»: ÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ ┘äϺϬÏÁÏ¡ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é

4414 - ( ┘àϺ ÏúÏ¡┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï¡┘äϺ┘äϺ┘ï ÏúÏ¡Ï¿ ÏÑ┘ä┘è┘ç ┘à┘å Ϻ┘ä┘å┘âϺϡ Ïî ┘ê┘äϺ ÏúÏ¡┘ä Ï¡┘äϺ┘äϺ┘ï Ïú┘âÏ▒┘ç ÏÑ┘ä┘è┘ç ┘à┘å Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é ) (1) .
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏú┘äϿϺ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ│┘äÏ│┘äÏ® Ϻ┘äÏÂÏ╣┘è┘üÏ®:
┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ»┘è┘ä┘à┘è (4/ 39) Ï╣┘å ┘à┘éϺϬ┘ä Ï¿┘å Ï│┘ä┘è┘àϺ┘å Ïî Ï╣┘å Ï╣┘àÏ▒┘ê Ï¿┘å Ï┤Ï╣┘èÏ¿ Ïî Ï╣┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è┘ç Ïî Ï╣┘å ϼϻ┘ç Ï▒┘üÏ╣┘ç .
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ê┘çÏ░Ϻ ┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣ Ïø Ïó┘üϬ┘ç ┘à┘éϺϬ┘ä Ï¿┘å Ï│┘ä┘è┘àϺ┘å - ┘ê┘ç┘ê Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘äÏ«┘è Ϻ┘ä┘à┘üÏ│Ï▒ - Ïø ┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ░┘çÏ¿┘è ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äÏÂÏ╣┘üϺÏí" :
"┘éϺ┘ä ┘ê┘â┘èÏ╣ ┘êÏ║┘èÏ▒┘ç : ┘âÏ░ϺϿ" . ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äϡϺ┘üÏ© ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äϬ┘éÏ▒┘èÏ¿" :
"┘âÏ░Ï¿┘ê┘ç Ïî ┘ê┘çϼÏ▒┘ê┘ç Ïî ┘êÏ▒┘à┘è ϿϺ┘äϬϼÏ│┘è┘à" :
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ê┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ ┘à┘å Ϻ┘äÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ Ϻ┘äϬ┘è ┘è┘ä┘çϼ Ï¿┘çϺ ┘âϽ┘èÏ▒ ┘à┘å ┘âϬϺϿ ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏ╣ÏÁÏ▒ Ïø Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è┘å ┘è┘âϺϻ┘ê┘å ┘èÏÀÏ¿┘é┘ê┘å Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘à┘è┘ä ÏÑ┘ä┘ë ϬϡÏ▒┘è┘à Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é ÏÑ┘äϺ ┘äÏÂÏ▒┘êÏ▒Ï® ! ϬϼϺ┘êϿϺ┘ï ┘à┘å┘ç┘à ┘àÏ╣ Ï▒Ï║ϿϺϬ Ï¿Ï╣Ï Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘âϺ┘à Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è┘å ┘èϬÏúϽÏ▒┘ê┘å Ï¿Ï│Ï¿Ï¿ ÏÂÏ╣┘ü ÏÑ┘è┘àϺ┘å┘ç┘à ┘êϼ┘ç┘ä┘ç┘à Ï¿ÏÑÏ│┘äϺ┘à┘ç┘à ϿϺ┘äÏ¡┘à┘äϺϬ Ϻ┘äϬ┘è ┘è┘êϼ┘ç┘çϺ Ϻ┘ä┘â┘üϺÏ▒ Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘äÏ»┘è┘å Ϻ┘äÏÑÏ│┘äϺ┘à┘è ┘êϬÏ┤Ï▒┘èÏ╣ϺϬ┘ç Ïî ┘êÏ«ÏÁ┘êÏÁϺ┘ï ┘à┘å┘çϺ Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é Ïî ┘ü┘èÏ┤Ï▒Ï╣┘ê┘å ┘à┘å Ï╣┘åÏ» Ïú┘å┘üÏ│┘ç┘à ┘é┘êϺ┘å┘è┘å Ϭ┘à┘åÏ╣ ┘à┘å ÏÑ┘è┘éϺÏ╣ Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é ÏÑ┘äϺ Ï¿┘é┘è┘êÏ» ┘êÏ┤Ï▒┘êÏÀ ϺϿϬϻÏ╣┘ê┘çϺ ┘àϺ Ïú┘åÏ▓┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï¿┘çϺ ┘à┘å Ï│┘äÏÀϺ┘å Ïî ┘àÏ╣ Ï╣┘ä┘à┘ç┘à Ï¿Ïú┘å Ï¿Ï╣Ï Ϻ┘äÏ»┘ê┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘âϺ┘üÏ▒Ï® ┘éÏ» Ï▒ϼÏ╣Ϭ ┘àÏÂÏÀÏ▒Ï® ÏÑ┘ä┘ë ϬÏ┤Ï▒┘èÏ╣ Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é Ï¿┘è┘å┘ç┘à Ïø ┘àÏÁϻϺ┘éϺ┘ï ┘ä┘é┘ê┘ä┘ç ϬÏ╣Ϻ┘ä┘ë : (Ï│┘åÏ▒┘è┘ç┘à Ïó┘èϺϬ┘åϺ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏó┘üϺ┘é ┘ê┘ü┘è Ïú┘å┘üÏ│┘ç┘à ϡϬ┘ë ┘èϬϿ┘è┘å ┘ä┘ç┘à Ïú┘å┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘é) . ϬϺ┘ä┘ä┘ç ÏÑ┘å┘çϺ ┘äÏÑÏ¡Ï»┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘âÏ¿Ï▒ Ïú┘å ┘è┘â┘üÏ▒ Ï¿Ï╣Ï Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ│┘ä┘à┘è┘å Ï¿Ï┤Ï▒┘èÏ╣Ϭ┘ç┘à ϿϬÏúϽ┘èÏ▒ Ϻ┘ä┘â┘üϺÏ▒ Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç┘à ┘êϬÏÂ┘ä┘è┘ä┘ç┘à ÏÑ┘èϺ┘ç┘à Ïî ┘êÏú┘å ┘èÏñ┘à┘å Ï¿Ï╣Ï ┘çÏñ┘äϺÏí ┘ê┘ä┘ê ϺϬϿϺÏ╣Ϻ┘ï ┘äÏÁϺ┘äÏ¡┘ç┘à Ï¿┘àϺ ┘â┘üÏ▒ Ï¿┘ç Ïú┘ê┘äϪ┘â . ┘ü┘àϺ ÏúÏ┤Ï¿┘ç ┘çÏñ┘äϺÏí ┘ê┘çÏñ┘äϺÏí Ï¿┘à┘å ┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ┘ü┘è┘ç┘à : (Ïú┘ê┘äϪ┘â Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è┘å ┘èÏ»Ï╣┘ê┘å ┘èϿϬÏ║┘ê┘å ÏÑ┘ä┘ë Ï▒Ï¿┘ç┘à Ϻ┘ä┘êÏ│┘è┘äÏ® Ïú┘è┘ç┘à Ïú┘éÏ▒Ï¿ ┘ê┘èÏ▒ϼ┘ê┘å Ï▒Ï¡┘àϬ┘ç ┘ê┘èϫϺ┘ü┘ê┘å Ï╣Ï░ϺϿ┘ç ÏÑ┘å Ï╣Ï░ϺϿ Ï▒Ï¿┘â ┘âϺ┘å ┘àÏ¡Ï░┘êÏ▒Ϻ┘ï) !
┘ê┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ ┘à┘å Ϻ┘äÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ Ϻ┘äϬ┘è ┘âϺ┘å Ϻ┘äÏúÏ│ϬϺÏ░ Ϻ┘ä┘üϺÏÂ┘ä ┘àÏÁÏÀ┘ü┘ë Ϻ┘äÏ▓Ï▒┘éϺ ┘éÏ»┘à┘çϺ ÏÑ┘ä┘è Ï▒ϺÏ║ϿϺ┘ï ϬϫÏ▒┘èϼ┘çϺ ┘ä┘ç ϿϬϺÏ▒┘èÏ« (15/ 6/ 71 ┘ç┘Ç = 12/ 3/ 52┘à) .
┘ê┘éÏ» Ï▒┘ê┘è Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ Ï╣┘å ┘àÏ╣ϺÏ░ ┘àÏ▒┘ü┘êÏ╣Ϻ┘ï Ï¿┘ä┘üÏ© Ϻ┘äÏ╣ϬϺ┘é ┘à┘âϺ┘å Ϻ┘ä┘å┘âϺϡ .
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç Ϻ┘äϻϺÏ▒┘éÏÀ┘å┘è (ÏÁ 439) Ïî ┘êϺ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è (7/ 361) ┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é ÏÑÏ│┘àϺÏ╣┘è┘ä Ï¿┘å Ï╣┘èϺÏ┤ Ïî Ï╣┘å Ï¡┘à┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘àϺ┘ä┘â Ϻ┘ä┘äÏ«┘à┘è Ïî Ï╣┘å ┘à┘âÏ¡┘ê┘ä Ïî Ï╣┘å ┘àÏ╣ϺÏ░ ┘àÏ▒┘ü┘êÏ╣Ϻ┘ï :
"┘èϺ ┘àÏ╣ϺÏ░ ! ┘àϺ Ï«┘ä┘é Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï┤┘èϪϺ┘ï Ï╣┘ä┘ë ┘êϼ┘ç Ϻ┘äÏúÏ▒Ï ÏúÏ¡Ï¿ ÏÑ┘ä┘è┘ç ┘à┘å Ϻ┘äÏ╣ϬϺ┘é Ïî ┘ê┘äϺ Ï«┘ä┘é Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï┤┘èϪϺ┘ï Ï╣┘ä┘ë ┘êϼ┘ç Ϻ┘äÏúÏ▒Ï ÏúÏ¿Ï║Ï ÏÑ┘ä┘è┘ç ┘à┘å Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é Ïî ┘üÏÑÏ░Ϻ ┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ▒ϼ┘ä ┘ä┘à┘à┘ä┘ê┘â┘ç : Ïú┘åϬ Ï¡Ï▒ ÏÑ┘å Ï┤ϺÏí Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ïø ┘ü┘ç┘ê Ï¡Ï▒ Ïî ┘ê┘äϺ ϺÏ│ϬϽ┘åϺÏí ┘ä┘ç Ïî ┘êÏÑÏ░Ϻ ┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ▒ϼ┘ä ┘äϺ┘àÏ▒ÏúϬ┘ç : Ïú┘åϬ ÏÀϺ┘ä┘é ÏÑ┘å Ï┤ϺÏí Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ïî ┘ü┘ä┘ç ϺÏ│ϬϽ┘åϺÏñ┘ç Ïî ┘ê┘äϺ ÏÀ┘äϺ┘é Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç" .
Ͻ┘à ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼϺ┘ç ┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é Ï¡┘à┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï¿┘èÏ╣ : ÏúÏ«Ï¿Ï▒┘åϺ ┘èÏ▓┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘çϺÏ▒┘ê┘å : ÏúÏ«Ï¿Ï▒┘åϺ ÏÑÏ│┘àϺÏ╣┘è┘ä Ï¿┘å Ï╣┘èϺÏ┤ ... ┘üÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç ┘åÏ¡┘ê┘ç Ïî ┘éϺ┘ä Ï¡┘à┘èÏ» : ┘éϺ┘ä ┘ä┘è ┘èÏ▓┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘çϺÏ▒┘ê┘å : ┘êÏú┘è Ï¡Ï»┘èϽ ┘ä┘ê ┘âϺ┘å Ï¡┘à┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘àϺ┘ä┘â ┘àÏ╣Ï▒┘ê┘üϺ┘ï Ïî ┘é┘äϬ : ┘ç┘ê ϼϻ ÏúÏ¿┘è . ┘éϺ┘ä ┘èÏ▓┘èÏ» :Ï│Ï▒Ï▒Ϭ┘å┘è Ïî Ϻ┘äÏó┘å ÏÁϺÏ▒ Ï¡Ï»┘èϽϺ┘ï . ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è :
"┘ä┘èÏ│ ┘ü┘è┘ç ┘âÏ¿┘èÏ▒ Ï│Ï▒┘êÏ▒ Ïø┘üÏ¡┘à┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å Ï▒Ï¿┘èÏ╣ Ï¿┘å Ï¡┘à┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘àϺ┘ä┘â Ϻ┘ä┘â┘ê┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ«Ï▓ϺÏ▓ ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü ϼϻϺ┘ï Ïî ┘åÏ│Ï¿┘ç ┘èÏ¡┘è┘ë Ï¿┘å ┘àÏ╣┘è┘å ┘êÏ║┘èÏ▒┘ç ÏÑ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘âÏ░Ï¿ Ïî ┘êÏ¡┘à┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘àϺ┘ä┘â ┘àϼ┘ç┘ê┘ä Ïî ┘ê┘à┘âÏ¡┘ê┘ä Ï╣┘å ┘àÏ╣ϺÏ░ Ï¿┘å ϼϿ┘ä ┘à┘å┘éÏÀÏ╣ Ïî ┘ê┘éÏ» ┘é┘è┘ä : Ï╣┘å Ï¡┘à┘èÏ» Ïî Ï╣┘å ┘à┘âÏ¡┘ê┘ä Ïî Ï╣┘å ϫϺ┘äÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘àÏ╣ϻϺ┘å Ïî Ï╣┘å ┘àÏ╣ϺÏ░ Ï¿┘å ϼϿ┘ä Ï▒ÏÂ┘è Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘å┘ç . ┘ê┘é┘è┘ä : Ï╣┘å┘ç Ïî Ï╣┘å ┘à┘âÏ¡┘ê┘ä ÏîÏ╣┘å ┘àϺ┘ä┘â Ï¿┘å ┘èϫϺ┘àÏ▒ Ïî Ï╣┘å ┘àÏ╣ϺÏ░ Ïî ┘ê┘ä┘èÏ│ Ï¿┘àÏ¡┘ü┘êÏ© . ┘êϺ┘ä┘ä┘ç ÏúÏ╣┘ä┘à" .
┘é┘äϬ : ┘êÏ¡┘à┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘àϺ┘ä┘â Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è ϼ┘ç┘ä┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è Ïø ┘éÏ» ÏÂÏ╣┘ü┘ç ┘èÏ¡┘è┘ë ┘êÏúÏ¿┘ê Ï▓Ï▒Ï╣Ï® ┘êÏ║┘èÏ▒┘ç┘àϺ Ïî ┘ê┘äÏ░┘ä┘â ϼÏ▓┘à Ï¿ÏÂÏ╣┘ü┘ç Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘é ┘ü┘è "ÏúÏ¡┘âϺ┘à┘ç" (┘é 146/ 2) Ïî ┘êϺϿ┘å Ϻ┘ä┘é┘è┘à ┘ü┘è "Ϭ┘çÏ░┘èÏ¿ Ϻ┘äÏ│┘å┘å" (3/ 91-92) .
┘êÏ▒┘ê┘è Ϻ┘äÏ┤ÏÀÏ▒ Ϻ┘äϽϺ┘å┘è ┘à┘å Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ Ï╣┘å ϺϿ┘å Ï╣┘àÏ▒ ┘àÏ▒┘ü┘êÏ╣Ϻ┘ï Ï¿┘ä┘üÏ© :
"┘àϺ ÏúÏ¡┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï┤┘èϪϺ┘ï ÏúÏ¿Ï║Ï ÏÑ┘ä┘è┘ç ┘à┘å Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é" .
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç Ϻ┘äϡϺ┘â┘à . ┘êÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ÏúÏ¿┘ê ϻϺ┘êÏ» Ï╣┘å ┘àϡϺÏ▒Ï¿ Ï¿┘å ϻϽϺÏ▒ ┘àÏ▒Ï│┘äϺ┘ï ┘ê┘ç┘ê Ϻ┘äÏÁ┘êϺϿ Ïø ┘â┘àϺ Ï¡┘é┘éϬ┘ç ┘ü┘è "ÏÑÏ▒┘êϺÏí Ϻ┘äÏ║┘ä┘è┘ä" (252 ┘ê 2100) .
__________
(1) ┘âϬϿ Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èÏ« - Ï▒Ï¡┘à┘ç Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç - ┘ü┘ê┘é ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘ä┘àϬ┘å : " ÏúÏ╣┘èÏ» Ï¿Ï▒┘é┘à ( 6290 ) Ï¿┘ü┘êϺϪϻ ϼϻ┘èϻϮ "

Ï▒Ï»: ÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ ┘äϺϬÏÁÏ¡ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é



4777 - ( ┘äϺ ϬÏ│Ïú┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ▒ÏúÏ® Ï▓┘êϼ┘çϺ Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é ┘ü┘è Ï║┘èÏ▒ ┘â┘å┘ç┘ç ┘üϬϼϻ Ï▒┘èÏ¡ Ϻ┘äϼ┘åÏ® Ïî ┘êÏÑ┘å Ï▒┘èÏ¡┘çϺ ┘à┘å ┘àÏ│┘èÏ▒Ï® ÏúÏ▒Ï¿Ï╣┘è┘å Ï╣Ϻ┘àϺ┘ï ) .
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏú┘äϿϺ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ│┘äÏ│┘äÏ® Ϻ┘äÏÂÏ╣┘è┘üÏ®:
ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ϺϿ┘å ┘àϺϼ┘ç (1/ 632) Ïî ┘êÏ╣┘å┘ç Ϻ┘äÏÂ┘èϺÏí ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘ä┘àϫϬϺÏ▒Ï®" (63/ 10/ 1) Ï╣┘å ϼÏ╣┘üÏ▒ Ï¿┘å ┘èÏ¡┘è┘ë Ï¿┘å Ͻ┘êϿϺ┘å Ï╣┘å Ï╣┘à┘ç Ï╣┘àϺÏ▒Ï® Ï¿┘å Ͻ┘êϿϺ┘å Ï╣┘å Ï╣ÏÀϺÏí Ï╣┘å ϺϿ┘å Ï╣ϿϺÏ│ ┘àÏ▒┘ü┘êÏ╣Ϻ┘ï .
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ê┘çÏ░Ϻ ÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü Ïø ┘â┘àϺ ┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘êÏÁ┘èÏ▒┘è ┘ü┘è "Ï▓┘êϺϪϻ┘ç" (124/ 4 ┘ê 128/ 2) Ïø ┘êÏ╣┘äϬ┘ç ϼÏ╣┘üÏ▒ ┘çÏ░Ϻ ┘êÏ╣┘à┘ç Ïø ┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ░┘çÏ¿┘è :
"┘éϺ┘ä ϺϿ┘å Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ»┘è┘å┘è Ïî ┘àϼ┘ç┘ê┘ä . ┘é┘äϬ : ┘êÏ╣┘à┘ç ┘ä┘è┘å" .
(Ϻ┘ä┘â┘å┘ç) : ϼ┘ê┘çÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èÏí ┘êÏ║Ϻ┘èϬ┘ç .

Ï▒Ï»: ÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ ┘äϺϬÏÁÏ¡ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é

5894 / ┘à - ( ϬÏ▓┘êϼ┘êϺ ┘ê┘äϺ ϬÏÀ┘ä┘é┘êϺ Ïø ┘üÏÑ┘å Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é ┘è┘çϬÏ▓ ┘à┘å┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ╣Ï▒Ï┤ ) .
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏú┘äϿϺ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ│┘äÏ│┘äÏ® Ϻ┘äÏÂÏ╣┘è┘üÏ®:
┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣

. ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ϺϿ┘å Ï╣Ï»┘è ┘ü┘è (( Ϻ┘ä┘âϺ┘à┘ä )) ( 5 / 1764 ) Ïî ┘êϺ┘äÏ«ÏÀ┘èÏ¿ ┘ü┘è (( Ϻ┘äϬϺÏ▒┘èÏ« )) ( 12 / 191 ) Ïî ┘êϺ┘äÏ»┘è┘ä┘à┘è ┘ü┘è (( ┘àÏ│┘åÏ» Ϻ┘ä┘üÏ▒Ï»┘êÏ│ )) ( 2 / 30 - Ϻ┘äÏ║Ï▒ϺϪϿ ) ┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é Ï╣┘àÏ▒┘ê Ï¿┘å ϼ┘à┘èÏ╣ Ï╣┘å ϼ┘ê┘èÏ¿Ï▒ Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘äÏÂϡϺ┘â Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘ä┘åÏ▓Ϻ┘ä Ï╣┘å Ï╣┘ä┘è Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘ä┘åÏ¿┘è - ÏÁ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ┘êÏ│┘ä┘à - ┘éϺ┘ä : . . . ┘üÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç .
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ê┘çÏ░Ϻ ┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣ Ïø Ïó┘üϬ┘ç Ï╣┘àÏ▒┘ê Ï¿┘å ϼ┘à┘èÏ╣ Ïú┘ê Ï┤┘èÏ«┘ç ϼ┘ê┘èÏ¿Ï▒ Ïø ┘üÏÑ┘å┘ç┘àϺ ┘àϬÏ▒┘ê┘âϺ┘å Ïî ┘ê┘ü┘è ϬÏ▒ϼ┘àÏ® Ϻ┘äÏú┘ê┘ä Ïú┘êÏ▒Ï»┘ç ϺϿ┘å Ï╣Ï»┘è Ïî ┘êÏ▒┘ê┘ë Ï╣┘å ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ╣┘è┘å Ïú┘å┘ç ┘éϺ┘ä :
(( ┘âϺ┘å ┘âÏ░ϺϿϺ┘ï Ï«Ï¿┘èϽϺ┘ï )) .
┘ê┘éϺ┘ä ┘ü┘è ÏóÏ«Ï▒ Ϻ┘äϬÏ▒ϼ┘àÏ® :
(( ┘êÏ╣Ϻ┘àÏ® Ï▒┘êϺ┘èϺϬ┘ç ┘à┘åϺ┘â┘èÏ▒ Ïî ┘ê┘âϺ┘å ┘èϬ┘ç┘à Ï¿┘êÏÂÏ╣┘çϺ )) . ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ«ÏÀ┘èÏ¿ :
(( ┘âϺ┘å ┘èÏ▒┘ê┘è Ϻ┘ä┘à┘åϺ┘â┘èÏ▒ Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ┤Ϻ┘ç┘èÏ▒ Ïî ┘êϺ┘ä┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣ϺϬ Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘äÏúϽϿϺϬ )) .

Ï▒Ï»: ÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ ┘äϺϬÏÁÏ¡ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é



6290 - ( ┘è┘ÄϺ ┘à┘ÅÏ╣┘ÄϺÏ░┘Å ! ┘à┘ÄϺ Ï«┘Ä┘ä┘Ä┘é┘Ä Ïº┘ä┘ä┘æ┘Ä┘ç┘Å Ï┤┘Ä┘è┘ÆϪϺ┘ï Ï╣┘Ä┘ä┘Ä┘ë Ï©┘çÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏú┘ÄÏ▒┘ÆÏÂ┘É Ïú┘ÄÏ¡┘ÄÏ¿┘æ┘Ä ÏÑ┘É┘ä┘Ä┘è┘Æ┘ç┘É ┘à┘É┘å┘Ä
Ï╣┘ÉϬ┘ÄϺ┘é┘ì Ïî ┘ê┘Ä┘à┘ÄϺ Ï«┘Ä┘ä┘Ä┘é┘Ä Ïº┘ä┘ä┘æ┘Ä┘ç┘Å Ï┤┘Ä┘è┘ÆϪϺ┘ï Ï╣┘Ä┘ä┘Ä┘ë ┘ê┘Äϼ┘Æ┘ç┘É Ïº┘äÏú┘ÄÏ▒┘ÆÏÂ┘É Ïú┘ÄÏ¿┘ÆÏ║┘ÄÏÂ┘Ä ÏÑ┘É┘ä┘Ä┘è┘Æ┘ç┘É ┘à┘É┘å┘Ä Ïº┘äÏÀ┘æ┘Ä┘äϺ┘Ä┘é┘É Ïî ┘ü┘ÄÏÑ┘ÉÏ░┘ÄϺ
┘é┘ÄϺ┘ä┘Ä Ïº┘äÏ▒┘æ┘Äϼ┘Å┘ä┘Å ┘ä┘ÉÏ╣Ï¿Ï»┘ç┘É : Ïú┘Ä┘å┘ÆϬ┘Ä Ï¡┘ÅÏ▒┘æ┘î ÏÑ┘É┘å┘Æ Ï┤┘ÄϺÏí┘Ä Ïº┘ä┘ä┘æ┘Ä┘ç┘Å Ïø ┘ü┘Ä┘ç┘Å┘ê┘Ä Ï¡┘ÅÏ▒┘æ┘î Ïî ┘ê┘Ä┘äϺ┘Ä ÏºÏ│┘ÆϬ┘ÉϽ┘Æ┘å┘ÄϺÏí┘Ä ┘ä┘Ä┘ç┘Å . ┘ê┘ÄÏÑ┘ÉÏ░┘ÄϺ
┘é┘ÄϺ┘ä┘Ä ┘äϺ┘É┘à┘ÆÏ▒┘ÄÏú┘ÄϬ┘É┘ç┘É : Ïú┘Ä┘å┘ÆϬ┘É ÏÀ┘ÄϺ┘ä┘É┘é┘î ÏÑ┘É┘å┘Æ Ï┤┘ÄϺÏí┘Ä Ïº┘ä┘ä┘æ┘Ä┘ç┘Å Ïø ┘ü┘Ä┘ä┘Ä┘ç┘ŠϺÏ│┘ÆϬ┘ÉϽ┘Æ┘å┘ÄϺÏñ┘Å┘ç┘Å Ïî ┘ê┘Ä┘äϺ┘Ä ÏÀ┘Ä┘äϺ┘Ä┘é┘Ä Ï╣┘Ä┘ä┘Ä┘è┘Æ┘ç┘É ) (*) .
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏú┘äϿϺ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ│┘äÏ│┘äÏ® Ϻ┘äÏÂÏ╣┘è┘üÏ®:
┘à┘å┘âÏ▒ .
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï▓Ϻ┘é ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘ä┘àÏÁ┘å┘ü " (6/390/11331) : Ï╣┘å ÏÑÏ│┘àϺÏ╣┘è┘ä ϺϿ┘å Ï╣┘èϺÏ┤ ┘éϺ┘ä : ÏúÏ«Ï¿Ï▒┘å┘è Ï¡┘à┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘àϺ┘ä┘â : Ïú┘å┘ç Ï│┘àÏ╣ ┘à┘âÏ¡┘ê┘äϺ┘ï ┘èϡϻϽ Ï╣┘å ┘àÏ╣ϺÏ░ Ï¿┘å
ϼϿ┘ä ... ┘àÏ▒┘ü┘êÏ╣Ϻ┘ï .
┘ê┘à┘å ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘ä┘êϼ┘ç ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç Ϻ┘äϻϺÏ▒┘éÏÀ┘å┘è (4/35/94) Ïî ┘êϺϿ┘å Ï╣Ï»┘è (2/279) Ïî
┘ê┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è (7/ 361) Ïî ┘êϺϿ┘å Ϻ┘äϼ┘êÏ▓┘è ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äÏ╣┘ä┘ä " (2/155/1066) .
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ê┘çÏ░Ϻ ÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü Ïø ┘à┘å┘éÏÀÏ╣ Ïî ┘à┘âÏ¡┘ê┘ä ┘ä┘à ┘èÏ│┘àÏ╣ ┘à┘å ┘àÏ╣ϺÏ░ Ïî ┘àÏ╣ ┘â┘ê┘å┘ç
┘àÏ»┘äÏ│Ϻ┘ï . ┘êÏ¡┘à┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘àϺ┘ä┘â Ïø ┘ê┘éÏ» ϺϬ┘ü┘é┘êϺ Ï╣┘ä┘ë ϬÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü┘ç .
┘ê┘ü┘è Ï▒┘êϺ┘èÏ® ┘ä┘äϻϺÏ▒┘éÏÀ┘å┘è - ┘êÏ╣┘å┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è - Ï╣┘å Ï¡┘à┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï¿┘èÏ╣ : ┘åϺ ┘èÏ▓┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å
┘çϺÏ▒┘ê┘å : ┘åϺ ÏÑÏ│┘àϺÏ╣┘è┘ä Ï¿┘å Ï╣┘èϺÏ┤ ... Ï¿ÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ┘ç ┘åÏ¡┘ê┘ç Ïø ┘éϺ┘ä Ï¡┘à┘èÏ» :
" ┘éϺ┘ä ┘ä┘è ┘èÏ▓┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘çϺÏ▒┘ê┘å : ┘êÏú┘è Ï¡Ï»┘èϽ ┘ä┘ê ┘âϺ┘å Ï¡┘à┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘àϺ┘ä┘â Ϻ┘ä┘äÏ«┘à┘è
┘àÏ╣Ï▒┘ê┘üϺ┘ï σ ┘é┘äϬ : ┘ç┘ê ϼϻ┘è . ┘éϺ┘ä ┘èÏ▓┘èÏ» : Ï│Ï▒Ï▒Ϭ┘å┘è Ï│Ï▒Ï▒Ϭ┘å┘è! Ϻ┘äÏó┘å ÏÁϺÏ▒ Ï¡Ï»┘èϽϺ┘ï " .
┘é┘äϬ : Ï▒Ï»┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è Ï¿┘é┘ê┘ä┘ç :
"┘ä┘èÏ│ ┘ü┘è┘ç ┘âÏ¿┘èÏ▒ Ï│Ï▒┘êÏ▒ Ïø ┘üÏ¡┘à┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å Ï▒Ï¿┘èÏ╣ Ï¿┘å Ï¡┘à┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘àϺ┘ä┘â Ϻ┘ä┘â┘ê┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ«Ï▓ϺÏ▓ :
ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü ϼϻϺ┘ï Ïî ┘åÏ│Ï¿┘ç ┘èÏ¡┘è┘ë Ï¿┘å ┘àÏ╣┘è┘å ┘êÏ║┘èÏ▒┘ç ÏÑ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘âÏ░Ï¿ Ïî ┘êÏ¡┘à┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘àϺ┘ä┘â :
┘àϼ┘ç┘ê┘ä Ïî ┘ê┘à┘âÏ¡┘ê┘ä Ï╣┘å ┘àÏ╣ϺÏ░ : ┘à┘å┘éÏÀÏ╣ " .
┘êÏú┘é┘ê┘ä : ┘é┘ê┘ä┘ç ┘ü┘è Ï¡┘à┘èÏ» : "┘àϼ┘ç┘ê┘ä " ... ┘àÏ▒Ï»┘êÏ» Ïî Ï»┘çϺ┘å ┘éϺ┘ä ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ╣┘è┘å ┘êϺ┘ä┘åÏ│ϺϪ┘è :
" ┘ä┘à ┘èϡϻϽ Ï╣┘å┘ç ÏÑ┘äϺ ÏÑÏ│┘àϺÏ╣┘è┘ä Ï¿┘å Ï╣┘èϺÏ┤ " .
┘ü┘éÏ» Ï▒┘ê┘ë Ï╣┘å┘ç Ïú┘èÏÂϺ┘ï ┘àÏ╣Ϻ┘ê┘èÏ® Ï¿┘å Ï¡┘üÏÁ - ┘ê┘ç┘ê ÏÁÏ»┘ê┘é Ïî - ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ ┘å┘üÏ│┘ç Ïî
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ϺϿ┘å Ï╣Ï»┘è Ï╣┘å┘ç Ï¿ÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ┘ç Ϻ┘ä┘àϬ┘éÏ»┘à Ï¿┘ä┘üÏ© :
Ï│Ϫ┘ä Ï▒Ï│┘ê┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ÏÁ┘Ä┘ä┘æ┘Ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘æ┘Ä┘ç┘Å Ï╣┘Ä┘ä┘Ä┘è┘Æ┘ç┘É ┘ê┘ÄÏ│┘Ä┘ä┘æ┘Ä┘à┘Ä Ï╣┘å Ï▒ϼ┘ä ┘éϺ┘ä ┘äϺ┘àÏ▒ÏúϬ┘ç : Ïú┘åϬ ÏÀϺ┘ä┘é ÏÑ┘å Ï┤ϺÏí Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç σ ┘éϺ┘ä : "┘ä┘ç ϺÏ│ϬϽ┘åϺÏñ┘ç " . ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä Ï▒ϼ┘ä : ┘èϺ Ï▒Ï│┘ê┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç! ┘üÏÑ┘å ┘éϺ┘ä ┘äÏ║┘äϺ┘à┘ç : Ïú┘åϬ Ï¡Ï▒ ÏÑ┘å Ï┤ϺÏí Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç σ ┘éϺ┘ä :
" ┘èÏ╣Ϭ┘é Ïø ┘äÏú┘å Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ┘èÏ┤ϺÏí Ϻ┘äÏ╣Ϭ┘é Ïî ┘ê┘äϺ ┘èÏ┤ϺÏí Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é "!
Ͻ┘à Ï▒┘êϺ┘ç ┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ│┘èÏ¿ Ï¿┘å Ï┤Ï▒┘è┘â : Ͻ┘åϺ Ï¡┘à┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘àϺ┘ä┘â ... Ï¿┘ç Ïî ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä :
"┘äÏú┘å Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ϬϿϺÏ▒┘â ┘êϬÏ╣Ϻ┘ä┘ë ┘èÏ¡Ï¿ Ϻ┘äÏ╣ϬϺ┘é Ïî ┘ê┘èÏ¿Ï║Ï Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é " .
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ü┘çÏñ┘äϺÏí Ͻ┘äϺϽϮ ┘éÏ» Ï▒┘ê┘êϺ Ï╣┘å Ï¡┘à┘èÏ» Ïî ┘ê┘éÏ» ÏúÏ┤ϺÏ▒ ϺϿ┘å Ï╣Ï»┘è ┘ü┘è ÏóÏ«Ï▒ ϬÏ▒ϼ┘àϬ┘ç
ÏÑ┘ä┘ë Ï▒Ï» ┘é┘ê┘ä ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ╣┘è┘å ┘êϺ┘ä┘åÏ│ϺϪ┘è Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ░┘â┘êÏ▒ Ïó┘å┘üϺ┘ï Ïî ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä :
"┘êÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ┘ç ┘à┘éϻϺÏ▒ ┘àϺ ┘èÏ▒┘ê┘è┘ç ┘à┘å┘âÏ▒" .
┘ê┘éÏ» Ï▒┘ê┘ë Ï╣┘å┘ç Ï▒ϺϿÏ╣ : ┘üÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç Ϻ┘äϻϺÏ▒┘éÏÀ┘å┘è (Ï▒┘é┘à 96) ┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é Ï╣┘àÏ▒ Ï¿┘å ÏÑÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘ç┘è┘à
ϺϿ┘å ϫϺ┘äÏ» Ïø ┘åϺ Ï¡┘à┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï¡┘à┘å Ï¿┘å ┘àϺ┘ä┘â Ϻ┘ä┘äÏ«┘à┘è ... Ï¿ÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ┘ç ┘àϫϬÏÁÏ▒Ϻ┘ï Ï¿┘ä┘üÏ© :
"┘àϺ ÏúÏ¡┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï┤┘èϪϺ┘ï ÏúÏ¿Ï║Ï ÏÑ┘ä┘è┘ç ┘à┘å Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é Ïî ┘ü┘à┘å ÏÀ┘ä┘é ┘êϺÏ│ϬϽ┘å┘ë Ïø ┘ü┘ä┘ç Ͻ┘å┘èϺ┘ç " .
┘ä┘â┘å Ï╣┘àÏ▒ ┘çÏ░Ϻ : ┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äϻϺÏ▒┘éÏÀ┘å┘è :
"┘âÏ░ϺϿ Ï«Ï¿┘èϽ " . ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ«ÏÀ┘èÏ¿ ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äϬϺÏ▒┘èÏ« " (11/202) :
"┘âϺ┘å Ï║┘èÏ▒ Ͻ┘éÏ® Ïî ┘èÏ▒┘ê┘è Ϻ┘ä┘à┘åϺ┘â┘èÏ▒ Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘äÏúϽϿϺϬ " .
┘êÏ░┘âÏ▒ ┘ä┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ░┘çÏ¿┘è ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘ä┘à┘èÏ▓Ϻ┘å " Ï¡Ï»┘èϽ┘è┘å ┘à┘å┘âÏ▒┘è┘å ϼϻϺ┘ï .
Ͻ┘à ┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è Ï╣┘éÏ¿ ┘â┘äϺ┘à┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ│ϺϿ┘é :
"┘ê┘éÏ» Ï▒┘ê┘è ┘ü┘è ┘à┘éϺϿ┘äϬ┘ç Ï¡Ï»┘èϽ ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü ┘äϺ ┘èϼ┘êÏ▓ Ϻ┘äϺϡϬϼϺϼ Ï¿┘àϽ┘ä┘ç " .
Ͻ┘à Ï│Ϻ┘é Ï¿ÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ┘ç ÏÑ┘ä┘ë ϺϿ┘å Ï╣Ï»┘è Ï¿Ï│┘åÏ»┘ç ÏÑ┘ä┘ë ϺϿ┘å Ï╣ϿϺÏ│ ┘àÏ▒┘ü┘êÏ╣Ϻ┘ï Ïî ┘ê┘ü┘è┘ç :
"Ïú┘å ┘à┘å ┘éϺ┘ä ┘äÏ║┘äϺ┘à┘ç : Ïú┘åϬ Ï¡Ï▒ ÏÑ┘å Ï┤ϺÏí Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ïø ┘ü┘äϺ Ï┤┘èÏí Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç " . ┘ê┘ç┘ê ┘àÏ«Ï▒ϼ ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äÏÑÏ▒┘êϺÏí" (7/154/2071) . ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è Ï╣┘éÏ¿┘ç :
"┘ê┘ü┘è Ï¡Ï»┘èϽ ϺϿ┘å Ï╣┘àÏ▒ Ï▒┘ÄÏÂ┘É┘è┘Ä Ïº┘ä┘ä┘æ┘Ä┘ç┘Å Ï╣┘Ä┘å┘Æ┘ç┘Å ┘â┘üϺ┘èÏ®" .
┘èÏ┤┘èÏ▒ ÏÑ┘ä┘ë Ï¡Ï»┘èϽ┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è Ï░┘âÏ▒┘ç ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äϿϺϿ Ï¿┘ä┘üÏ©┘è┘å :
ÏúÏ¡Ï»┘ç┘àϺ : "ÏÑÏ░Ϻ Ï¡┘ä┘ü Ϻ┘äÏ▒ϼ┘ä ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä : ÏÑ┘å Ï┤ϺÏí Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ïø ┘ü┘éÏ» ϺÏ│ϬϽ┘å┘ë" .
┘êϺ┘äÏóÏ«Ï▒ : "┘à┘å Ï¡┘ä┘ü Ï╣┘ä┘ë ┘è┘à┘è┘å ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä : ÏÑ┘å Ï┤ϺÏí Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ïø ┘ü┘ç┘ê ϿϺ┘äÏ«┘èϺÏ▒ Ïî ÏÑ┘å Ï┤ϺÏí Ïø ┘üÏ╣┘ä Ïî
┘êÏÑ┘å Ï┤ϺÏí Ïø ┘ä┘à ┘è┘üÏ╣┘ä " .
┘ê┘ç┘ê ┘àÏ«Ï▒ϼ ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äÏÑÏ▒┘êϺÏí" Ïú┘èÏÂϺ┘ï (8/198 - 199) .
__________
(*) ┘âϬϿ Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èÏ« Ï▒Ï¡┘à┘ç Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï¿┘çϺ┘àÏ┤ Ϻ┘äÏúÏÁ┘ä : "Ϭ┘éÏ»┘à Ï¿Ï▒┘é┘à (4414) " . (Ϻ┘ä┘åϺÏ┤Ï▒) .

Ï▒Ï»: ÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ ┘äϺϬÏÁÏ¡ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é



147 - " ϬÏ▓┘êϼ┘êϺ ┘ê┘äϺ ϬÏÀ┘ä┘é┘êϺ ┘üÏÑ┘å Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é ┘è┘çϬÏ▓ ┘ä┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ╣Ï▒Ï┤ " .
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏú┘äϿϺ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ│┘äÏ│┘äÏ® Ϻ┘äÏÂÏ╣┘è┘üÏ®:
┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣ .
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ«ÏÀ┘èÏ¿ ┘ü┘è " ϬϺÏ▒┘èÏ« Ï¿Ï║ϻϺϻ " ( 12 / 191 ) ┘ê┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é┘ç ϺϿ┘å Ϻ┘äϼ┘êÏ▓┘è ( 2 /277 ) ┘ü┘è ϬÏ▒ϼ┘àÏ® Ï╣┘àÏ▒┘ê Ï¿┘å ϼ┘à┘èÏ╣ Ï╣┘å ϼ┘ê┘èÏ¿Ï▒ Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘äÏÂϡϺ┘â Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘ä┘åÏ▓Ϻ┘ä Ï¿┘å Ï│Ï¿Ï▒Ï® Ï╣┘å Ï╣┘ä┘è Ï¿┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è ÏÀϺ┘äÏ¿ ┘àÏ▒┘ü┘êÏ╣Ϻ Ïî ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä : Ï╣┘àÏ▒┘ê ┘âϺ┘å ┘èÏ▒┘ê┘è Ϻ┘ä┘à┘åϺ┘â┘èÏ▒ Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ┤Ϻ┘ç┘èÏ▒ ┘êϺ┘ä┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣ϺϬ Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘äÏúϽϿϺϬ . ┘é┘äϬ : ┘ê┘ç┘ê ┘âÏ░ϺϿ ┘ê┘éÏ» Ϭ┘éÏ»┘à ┘ä┘ç ÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ Ïî ┘êϼ┘ê┘èÏ¿Ï▒ ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü ϼϻϺ ┘êϬ┘éÏ»┘à ┘ä┘ç Ï┤┘èÏí Ïî ┘êÏ¿┘çÏ░Ϻ ÏúÏ╣┘ä┘ç ϺϿ┘å Ϻ┘äϼ┘êÏ▓┘è ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä : ┘äϺ ┘èÏÁÏ¡ .
┘êϺ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ Ïú┘êÏ▒Ï»┘ç Ϻ┘äÏÁÏ║Ϻ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è " Ϻ┘ä┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣ϺϬ " ( ÏÁ 8 ) .
┘êÏú┘éÏ▒ ϺϿ┘å Ϻ┘äϼ┘êÏ▓┘è Ϻ┘äÏ│┘è┘êÏÀ┘è ┘ü┘è " Ϻ┘ä┘äÏó┘ä┘èÏí " ( 2 / 179 ) ┘üϺ┘äÏ╣ϼϿ ┘à┘å┘ç ┘â┘è┘ü Ïú┘êÏ▒Ï»┘ç ┘à┘å Ï▒┘êϺ┘èÏ® ϺϿ┘å Ï╣Ï»┘è ┘ü┘è " Ϻ┘äϼϺ┘àÏ╣ Ϻ┘äÏÁÏ║┘èÏ▒ " Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è ϺÏ┤ϬÏ▒ÏÀ ┘ü┘è ┘à┘éÏ»┘àϬ┘ç Ïú┘å ┘èÏÁ┘ê┘å┘ç ┘à┘àϺ Ϭ┘üÏ▒Ï» Ï¿┘ç ┘âÏ░ϺϿ Ïú┘ê ┘êÏÂϺÏ╣ ! ┘êÏúÏ╣ϼϿ ┘à┘å ┘çÏ░Ϻ ϺÏ│ϬϻÏ▒Ϻ┘â Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èÏ« Ϻ┘äÏ╣ϼ┘ä┘ê┘å┘è ┘ü┘è " Ϻ┘ä┘âÏ┤┘ü " ( 1 / 304 ) Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ï¡┘â┘à Ϻ┘äÏÁÏ║Ϻ┘å┘è Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ϿϺ┘ä┘êÏÂÏ╣ Ï¿┘é┘ê┘ä┘ç : ┘ä┘â┘å Ï╣Ï▓Ϻ┘ç ┘ü┘è " Ϻ┘äϼϺ┘àÏ╣ Ϻ┘äÏÁÏ║┘èÏ▒ " ┘äϺϿ┘å Ï╣Ï»┘è Ï¿Ï│┘åÏ» ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü Ï╣┘å Ï╣┘ä┘è ! ┘ê┘â┘è┘ü ┘äϺ ┘è┘â┘ê┘å ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ ┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣Ϻ Ïî ┘ê┘éÏ» ÏÀ┘ä┘é ϼ┘àϺÏ╣Ï® ┘à┘å Ϻ┘äÏ│┘ä┘ü Ï¿┘ä ÏÁÏ¡ Ïú┘å Ϻ┘ä┘åÏ¿┘è ÏÁ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ┘êÏ│┘ä┘à ÏÀ┘ä┘é Ï▓┘êϼϬ┘ç Ï¡┘üÏÁÏ® Ï¿┘åϬ Ï╣┘àÏ▒ Ï▒ÏÂ┘è Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘å┘ç┘àϺ σ ! .

Ï▒Ï»: ÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ ┘äϺϬÏÁÏ¡ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é



1134 - " ┘âϺ┘å Ϻ┘äÏ▒ϼ┘ä ÏÑÏ░Ϻ ÏÀ┘ä┘é Ϻ┘àÏ▒ÏúϬ┘ç Ͻ┘äϺϽϺ ┘éÏ¿┘ä Ïú┘å ┘èϻϫ┘ä Ï¿┘çϺ ϼÏ╣┘ä┘ê┘çϺ ┘êϺϡϻϮ Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ï╣┘çÏ» Ï▒Ï│┘ê┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ÏÁ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ┘êÏ│┘ä┘àÏî ┘êÏúÏ¿┘è Ï¿┘âÏ▒Ïî ┘êÏÁÏ»Ï▒Ϻ ┘à┘å ÏÑ┘àϺÏ▒Ï® Ï╣┘àÏ▒Ïî ┘ü┘ä┘àϺ Ï▒Ïú┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘åϺÏ│ ┘éÏ» ϬϬϺϿÏ╣┘êϺ ┘ü┘è┘çϺÏî ┘éϺ┘ä ( ┘èÏ╣┘å┘è Ï╣┘àÏ▒ ) : Ïúϼ┘èÏ▓┘ç┘å Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç┘à ".
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏú┘äϿϺ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ│┘äÏ│┘äÏ® Ϻ┘äÏÂÏ╣┘è┘üÏ®:
┘à┘å┘âÏ▒ Ï¿┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏ│┘èϺ┘é.
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ÏúÏ¿┘ê ϻϺ┘êÏ» ( 2199 ) ┘êÏ╣┘å┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è ( 7/338 - 339 ) : ϡϻϽ┘åϺ ┘àÏ¡┘àÏ» Ï¿┘å Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘ä┘à┘ä┘â Ï¿┘å ┘àÏ▒┘êϺ┘å : ϡϻϽ┘åϺ ÏúÏ¿┘ê Ϻ┘ä┘åÏ╣┘àϺ┘å : ϡϻϽ┘åϺ Ï¡┘àϺϻ Ï¿┘å Ï▓┘èÏ» Ï╣┘å Ïú┘è┘êÏ¿ Ï╣┘å Ï║┘èÏ▒ ┘êϺϡϻ Ï╣┘å ÏÀϺ┘ê┘êÏ│ :
" Ïú┘å Ï▒ϼ┘äϺ ┘è┘éϺ┘ä ┘ä┘ç : ÏúÏ¿┘ê Ϻ┘äÏÁ┘çϿϺÏí ┘âϺ┘å ┘âϽ┘èÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏ│ÏñϺ┘ä ┘äϺϿ┘å Ï╣ϿϺÏ│ ┘éϺ┘ä : Ïú┘àϺ Ï╣┘ä┘àϬ Ïú┘å Ϻ┘äÏ▒ϼ┘ä ┘âϺ┘å ÏÑÏ░Ϻ ÏÀ┘ä┘é Ϻ┘àÏ▒ÏúϬ┘ç Ͻ┘äϺϽϺ ┘éÏ¿┘ä Ïú┘å ┘èϻϫ┘ä Ï¿┘çϺ ϼÏ╣┘ä┘ê┘çϺ ┘êϺϡϻϮ Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ï╣┘çÏ» Ï▒Ï│┘ê┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ÏÁ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ┘êÏ│┘ä┘à ┘êÏúÏ¿┘è Ï¿┘âÏ▒ ┘êÏÁÏ»Ï▒Ϻ ┘à┘å ÏÑ┘àϺÏ▒Ï® Ï╣┘àÏ▒ σ ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä ϺϿ┘å Ï╣ϿϺÏ│ : Ï¿┘ä┘ë ┘âϺ┘å Ϻ┘äÏ▒ϼ┘ä..".
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ê┘çÏ░Ϻ ÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ ┘àÏ╣┘ä┘ê┘ä Ï╣┘åÏ»┘è Ï¿ÏúÏ¿┘è Ϻ┘ä┘åÏ╣┘àϺ┘å ┘êϺÏ│┘à┘ç ┘àÏ¡┘àÏ» Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘ä┘üÏÂ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ│Ï»┘êÏ│┘è ┘ê┘ä┘éÏ¿┘ç Ï╣ϺÏ▒┘àÏî ┘ê┘ç┘ê ┘êÏÑ┘å ┘âϺ┘å Ͻ┘éÏ® ┘ü┘éÏ» ┘âϺ┘å ϺϫϬ┘äÏÀÏî ┘êÏÁ┘ü┘ç Ï¿Ï░┘ä┘â ϼ┘àϺÏ╣Ï® ┘à┘å Ϻ┘äÏúϪ┘àÏ® ┘à┘å┘ç┘à ÏúÏ¿┘ê ϻϺ┘êÏ» ┘êϺ┘ä┘åÏ│ϺϪ┘è ┘êϺ┘äϻϺÏ▒┘éÏÀ┘å┘è ┘êÏ║┘èÏ▒┘ç┘àÏî ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä ϺϿ┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è ϡϺϬ┘à ┘ü┘è " Ϻ┘äϼÏ▒Ï¡ ┘êϺ┘äϬÏ╣Ï»┘è┘ä " ( 4/1/59 ) :
" Ï│┘àÏ╣Ϭ ÏúÏ¿┘è ┘è┘é┘ê┘ä : ϺϫϬ┘äÏÀ ┘ü┘è ÏóÏ«Ï▒ Ï╣┘àÏ▒┘çÏî ┘êÏ▓Ϻ┘ä Ï╣┘é┘ä┘ç ┘ü┘à┘å Ï│┘àÏ╣ ┘à┘å┘ç ┘éÏ¿┘ä Ϻ┘äϺϫϬ┘äϺÏÀ ┘üÏ│┘àϺÏ╣┘ç ÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡ ".
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ê┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ ┘à┘å Ï▒┘êϺ┘èÏ® ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ▒┘êϺ┘å ┘ê┘ç┘ê ÏúÏ¿┘ê ϼÏ╣┘üÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏ»┘é┘è┘é┘è Ϻ┘äϽ┘éÏ®Ïî ┘ê┘äϺ ┘åÏ»Ï▒┘è ÏúÏ│┘àÏ╣ ┘à┘å┘ç ┘éÏ¿┘ä Ϻ┘äϺϫϬ┘äϺÏÀ Ïú┘à Ï¿Ï╣Ï»┘ç σ ┘ê┘çÏ░Ϻ Ï╣┘åÏ»┘è ÏúÏ▒ϼϡÏî ┘ü┘éÏ» Ï«┘ê┘ä┘ü Ï╣ϺÏ▒┘à ┘ü┘è ÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ┘ç ┘ê┘àϬ┘å┘ç. ┘üÏ▒┘êϺ┘ç Ï│┘ä┘è┘àϺ┘å Ï¿┘å Ï¡Ï▒Ï¿ Ï╣┘å Ï¡┘àϺϻ Ï¿┘å Ï▓┘èÏ» ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä : Ï╣┘å Ïú┘è┘êÏ¿ Ï╣┘å ÏÑÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘ç┘è┘à ϺϿ┘å ┘à┘èÏ│Ï▒Ï® Ï╣┘å ÏÀϺ┘ê┘êÏ│ Ï¿┘çÏî ÏÑ┘äϺ Ïú┘å┘ç ┘ä┘à ┘èÏ░┘âÏ▒ ┘ü┘è┘ç :
" ┘éÏ¿┘ä Ïú┘å ┘èϻϫ┘ä Ï¿┘çϺ ".
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ┘àÏ│┘ä┘à ( 4/182 ) ┘êϺ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è ( 7/336 ). ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä ϺϿ┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è Ï┤┘èÏ¿Ï® ( 5/26 ) : ┘åϺ Ï╣┘üϺ┘å Ï¿┘å ┘àÏ│┘ä┘à ┘éϺ┘ä : ┘åϺ Ï¡┘àϺϻ Ï¿┘å Ï▓┘èÏ» Ï¿┘ç.
┘êÏ▒┘êϺ┘ç ┘àÏ¡┘àÏ» Ï¿┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è ┘åÏ╣┘è┘à : ┘åϺ Ï¡┘àϺϻ Ï¿┘å Ï▓┘èÏ» Ï¿┘ç.
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç Ϻ┘äϻϺÏ▒┘éÏÀ┘å┘è ( 443 )Ïî ┘êϺϿ┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è ┘åÏ╣┘è┘à ÏÁÏ»┘ê┘é.
┘ü┘ç┘è Ï▓┘èϺϻϮ Ï┤ϺÏ░Ï® ÏÑ┘å ┘ä┘à ┘å┘é┘ä ┘à┘å┘âÏ▒Ï®Ïî Ϭ┘üÏ▒Ï» Ï¿┘çϺ Ï╣ϺÏ▒┘à.
┘ê┘èÏñ┘âÏ» Ï░┘ä┘â Ïú┘å Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï¿┘å ÏÀϺ┘ê┘êÏ│ ┘éÏ» Ï▒┘ê┘ë Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ Ï╣┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è┘ç ┘â┘àϺ Ï▒┘êϺ┘ç Ï│┘ä┘è┘àϺ┘å Ï¿┘å Ï¡Ï▒Ï¿ Ï¿ÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ┘ç Ï╣┘å┘ç Ï¿Ï»┘ê┘å Ϻ┘äÏ▓┘èϺϻϮ.
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ┘àÏ│┘ä┘à ┘êϺ┘ä┘åÏ│ϺϪ┘è ( 2/96 ) ┘êϺ┘äÏÀϡϺ┘ê┘è ( 2/31 ) ┘êϺ┘äϻϺÏ▒┘éÏÀ┘å┘è ( 444 ) ┘êϺ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è ┘êÏúÏ¡┘àÏ» ( 1/314 ) ┘êϺ┘äϡϺ┘â┘à Ïú┘èÏÂϺ ( 2/196 ) ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä :
" ÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡ Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ï┤Ï▒ÏÀ Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èÏ«┘è┘å ┘ê┘ä┘à ┘èÏ«Ï▒ϼϺ┘ç "Ïî ┘ê┘êϺ┘ü┘é┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ░┘çÏ¿┘è.
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ê┘ç┘ê ┘â┘àϺ ┘éϺ┘äϺÏî ÏÑ┘äϺ Ïú┘å┘ç┘àϺ ┘ê┘ç┘àϺ ┘ü┘è ϺÏ│ϬϻÏ▒Ϻ┘â┘ç┘àϺ Ï╣┘ä┘ë ┘àÏ│┘ä┘à.
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ü┘çÏ░┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ▒┘êϺ┘èϺϬ Ϻ┘äÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡Ï® Ϭϻ┘ä Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ïú┘å Ï╣ϺÏ▒┘àϺ ÏÑ┘å┘àϺ ϡϻϽ ϿϺ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ Ï¿Ï╣Ï» Ϻ┘äϺϫϬ┘äϺÏÀÏî ┘ê┘äÏ░┘ä┘â ┘ä┘à ┘èÏÂÏ¿ÏÀ┘çÏî ┘ü┘ä┘à ┘èÏ¡┘üÏ© ϺÏ│┘à Ï┤┘èÏ« Ïú┘è┘êÏ¿ ┘ü┘è┘çÏî ┘êÏ▓Ϻϻ Ϭ┘ä┘â Ϻ┘äÏ▓┘èϺϻϮ ┘ü┘ç┘è ┘äÏ░┘ä┘â Ï┤ϺÏ░Ï® Ï║┘èÏ▒ ┘àÏ¡┘ü┘êÏ©Ï® ┘ä┘àϫϺ┘ä┘üϬ┘ç Ϻ┘äϽ┘éϺϬ ┘ü┘è┘çϺÏî ┘ê┘éÏ» Ï«┘ü┘èϬ ┘çÏ░┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ╣┘äÏ® Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘äÏ╣┘äϺ┘àÏ® ϺϿ┘å Ϻ┘ä┘é┘è┘à Ïø ┘üÏÁÏ¡Ï¡ ÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ ┘ü┘è " Ï▓Ϻϻ Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ╣Ϻϻ " ( 4/55 )Ïî ┘êϺ┘åÏÀ┘ä┘ë Ï░┘ä┘â Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ╣┘ä┘é Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ( 5/249 ┘ê251 )Ïî ┘êÏúÏ╣┘ä┘ç Ϻ┘ä┘à┘åÏ░Ï▒┘è ┘ü┘è " ┘àϫϬÏÁÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏ│┘å┘å " ( 3/124 ) Ï¿┘é┘ê┘ä┘ç : " Ϻ┘äÏ▒┘êϺϮ Ï╣┘å ÏÀϺ┘ê┘êÏ│ ┘àϼϺ┘ç┘è┘ä ".
┘êÏÑÏ░Ϻ Ï╣Ï▒┘üϬ Ï░┘ä┘â ┘ü┘äϺ ┘èϼ┘êÏ▓ Ϭ┘é┘è┘èÏ» ┘ä┘üÏ© Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ Ϻ┘äÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡ Ï¿┘çϺÏî ┘â┘àϺ ┘üÏ╣┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘èÏî Ï¿┘ä ┘è┘åÏ¿Ï║┘è ϬÏ▒┘â┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘ë ÏÑÏÀ┘äϺ┘é┘ç ┘ü┘ç┘ê ┘èÏ┤┘à┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘àϻϫ┘ê┘ä Ï¿┘çϺ ┘êÏ║┘èÏ▒ Ϻ┘ä┘àϻϫ┘ê┘ä Ï¿┘çϺÏî ┘êÏÑ┘ä┘è┘â ┘ä┘üÏ© Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ ┘ü┘è " ÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡ ┘àÏ│┘ä┘à " :
" ┘âϺ┘å Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ï╣┘çÏ» Ï▒Ï│┘ê┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ÏÁ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ┘êÏ│┘ä┘àÏî ┘êÏúÏ¿┘è Ï¿┘âÏ▒Ïî ┘êÏ│┘åϬ┘è┘å ┘à┘å Ï«┘äϺ┘üÏ® Ï╣┘àÏ▒ ÏÀ┘äϺ┘é Ϻ┘äϽ┘äϺϽ ┘êϺϡϻϮÏî ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä Ï╣┘àÏ▒ Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘äÏ«ÏÀϺϿ : ÏÑ┘å Ϻ┘ä┘åϺÏ│ ┘éÏ» ϺÏ│ϬÏ╣ϼ┘ä┘êϺ ┘ü┘è Ïú┘àÏ▒ ┘éÏ» ┘âϺ┘åϬ ┘ä┘ç┘à ┘ü┘è┘ç Ïú┘åϺϮÏî ┘ü┘ä┘ê Ïú┘àÏÂ┘è┘åϺ┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç┘àÏî ┘üÏú┘àÏÂϺ┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç┘à ".
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ê┘ç┘ê ┘åÏÁ ┘äϺ ┘è┘éÏ¿┘ä Ϻ┘äϼϻ┘ä Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ïú┘å ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é Ï¡┘â┘à ┘àÏ¡┘â┘à ϽϺϿϬ Ï║┘èÏ▒ ┘à┘åÏ│┘êÏ« ┘äϼÏ▒┘èϺ┘å Ϻ┘äÏ╣┘à┘ä Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç Ï¿Ï╣Ï» ┘ê┘üϺϬ┘ç ÏÁ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ┘êÏ│┘ä┘à ┘ü┘è Ï«┘äϺ┘üÏ® ÏúÏ¿┘è Ï¿┘âÏ▒Ïî ┘êÏú┘ê┘ä Ï«┘äϺ┘üÏ® Ï╣┘àÏ▒Ïî ┘ê┘äÏú┘å Ï╣┘àÏ▒ Ï▒ÏÂ┘è Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ┘ä┘à ┘èϫϺ┘ä┘ü┘ç Ï¿┘åÏÁ ÏóÏ«Ï▒ Ï╣┘åÏ»┘ç Ï¿┘ä ϿϺϼϬ┘çϺϻ ┘à┘å┘ç ┘ê┘äÏ░┘ä┘â ϬÏ▒ϻϻ ┘é┘ä┘è┘äϺ Ïú┘ê┘ä Ϻ┘äÏú┘àÏ▒ ┘ü┘è ┘àϫϺ┘ä┘üϬ┘ç ┘â┘àϺ ┘èÏ┤Ï╣Ï▒ Ï¿Ï░┘ä┘â ┘é┘ê┘ä┘ç : " ÏÑ┘å Ϻ┘ä┘åϺÏ│ ┘éÏ» ϺÏ│ϬÏ╣ϼ┘ä┘êϺ.. ┘ü┘ä┘ê Ïú┘àÏÂ┘è┘åϺ┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç┘à.. "Ïî ┘ü┘ç┘ä ┘èϼ┘êÏ▓ ┘ä┘äϡϺ┘â┘à ┘àϽ┘ä ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äϬÏ│ϺÏñ┘ä ┘êϺ┘äϬÏ▒ϻϻ ┘ä┘ê┘âϺ┘å Ï╣┘åÏ»┘ç ┘åÏÁ Ï¿Ï░┘ä┘â σ !
┘êÏú┘èÏÂϺÏî ┘üÏÑ┘å ┘é┘ê┘ä┘ç : " ┘éÏ» ϺÏ│ϬÏ╣ϼ┘ä┘êϺ " ┘èÏ»┘ä Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ïú┘å Ϻ┘äϺÏ│ϬÏ╣ϼϺ┘ä ϡϻϽ Ï¿Ï╣Ï» Ïú┘å ┘ä┘à ┘è┘â┘åÏî ┘üÏ▒Ïú┘ë Ϻ┘äÏ«┘ä┘è┘üÏ® Ϻ┘äÏ▒ϺÏ┤Ï»Ïî Ïú┘å ┘è┘àÏÂ┘è┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç┘à Ͻ┘äϺϽϺ ┘à┘å ϿϺϿ Ϻ┘äϬÏ╣Ï▓┘èÏ▓ ┘ä┘ç┘à ┘êϺ┘äϬÏúÏ»┘èÏ¿Ïî ┘ü┘ç┘ä ┘èϼ┘êÏ▓ ┘àÏ╣ ┘çÏ░Ϻ ┘â┘ä┘ç Ïú┘å ┘èϬÏ▒┘â Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘â┘à Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ¡┘â┘à Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è Ïúϼ┘àÏ╣ Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ│┘ä┘à┘ê┘å ┘ü┘è Ï«┘äϺ┘üÏ® ÏúÏ¿┘è Ï¿┘âÏ▒ ┘êÏú┘ê┘ä Ï«┘äϺ┘üÏ® Ï╣┘àÏ▒Ïî ┘à┘å Ïúϼ┘ä Ï▒Ïú┘è ϿϻϺ ┘äÏ╣┘àÏ▒ ┘êϺϼϬ┘çÏ» ┘ü┘è┘çÏî ┘ü┘èÏñÏ«Ï░ ϿϺϼϬ┘çϺϻ┘çÏî ┘ê┘èϬÏ▒┘â Ï¡┘â┘à┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è Ï¡┘â┘à ┘ç┘ê Ï¿┘ç Ïú┘ê┘ä Ï«┘äϺ┘üϬ┘ç ϬϿÏ╣Ϻ ┘äÏ▒Ï│┘ê┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ÏÁ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ┘êÏ│┘ä┘à ┘êÏúÏ¿┘è Ï¿┘âÏ▒ σ ! Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç┘à ÏÑ┘å ┘çÏ░Ϻ ┘ä┘à┘å Ï╣ϼϺϪϿ ┘àϺ ┘ê┘éÏ╣ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘ä┘ü┘é┘ç Ϻ┘äÏÑÏ│┘äϺ┘à┘èÏî ┘üÏ▒ϼ┘êÏ╣Ϻ ÏÑ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘äÏ│┘åÏ® Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ¡┘â┘àÏ® Ïú┘è┘çϺ Ϻ┘äÏ╣┘ä┘àϺÏíÏî ┘äϺ Ï│┘è┘àϺ ┘ê┘éÏ» ┘âϽÏ▒Ϭ Ï¡┘êϺϻϽ Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é ┘ü┘è ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏ▓┘à┘å ┘âϽÏ▒Ï® ┘àÏ»┘çÏ┤Ï® Ϭ┘åÏ░Ï▒ Ï¿Ï┤Ï▒ ┘àÏ│ϬÏÀ┘èÏ▒ ϬÏÁϺϿ Ï¿┘ç ┘àϪϺϬ Ϻ┘äÏ╣ϺϪ┘äϺϬ.
┘êÏú┘åϺ Ï¡┘è┘å Ïú┘âϬϿ ┘çÏ░Ϻ ÏúÏ╣┘ä┘à Ïú┘å Ï¿Ï╣Ï Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘äϺϻ Ϻ┘äÏÑÏ│┘äϺ┘à┘èÏ® ┘â┘àÏÁÏ▒ ┘êÏ│┘êÏ▒┘èϺ ┘éÏ» Ïúϻϫ┘äϬ ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘â┘à ┘ü┘è ┘àϡϺ┘â┘à┘çϺ Ϻ┘äÏ┤Ï▒Ï╣┘èÏ®Ïî ┘ê┘ä┘â┘å ┘à┘å Ϻ┘ä┘àÏñÏ│┘ü Ïú┘å Ïú┘é┘ê┘ä : ÏÑ┘å Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è┘å Ïúϻϫ┘ä┘êϺ Ï░┘ä┘â ┘à┘å Ϻ┘ä┘ü┘é┘çϺÏí Ϻ┘ä┘éϺ┘å┘ê┘å┘è┘è┘å ┘ä┘à ┘è┘â┘å Ï░┘ä┘â ┘à┘å┘ç┘à ϿϻϺ┘üÏ╣ ÏÑÏ¡┘èϺÏí Ϻ┘äÏ│┘åÏ®Ïî ┘êÏÑ┘å┘àϺ Ϭ┘é┘ä┘èϻϺ ┘à┘å┘ç┘à ┘äÏ▒Ïú┘è ϺϿ┘å Ϭ┘è┘à┘èÏ® Ϻ┘ä┘à┘êϺ┘ü┘é ┘ä┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽÏî Ïú┘è ÏÑ┘å┘ç┘à ÏúÏ«Ï░┘êϺ Ï¿Ï▒Ïú┘è┘ç ┘äϺ ┘äÏú┘å┘ç ┘àÏ»Ï╣┘à ϿϺ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽÏî Ï¿┘ä ┘äÏú┘å Ϻ┘ä┘àÏÁ┘äÏ¡Ï® Ϻ┘éϬÏÂϬ Ϻ┘äÏúÏ«Ï░ Ï¿┘ç Ï▓Ï╣┘à┘êϺÏî ┘ê┘äÏ░┘ä┘â ┘üÏÑ┘å ϼ┘ä ┘çÏñ┘äϺÏí Ϻ┘ä┘ü┘é┘çϺÏí ┘äϺ ┘èÏ»Ï╣┘à┘ê┘å Ïú┘é┘êϺ┘ä┘ç┘à ┘êϺϫϬ┘èϺÏ▒ϺϬ┘ç┘à Ϻ┘äϬ┘è ┘èϫϬϺÏ▒┘ê┘å┘çϺ Ϻ┘ä┘è┘ê┘à ϿϺ┘äÏ│┘åÏ®Ïî ┘äÏú┘å┘ç┘à ┘äϺ Ï╣┘ä┘à ┘ä┘ç┘à Ï¿┘çϺÏî Ï¿┘ä ┘éÏ» ϺÏ│ϬÏ║┘å┘êϺ Ï╣┘å Ï░┘ä┘â ϿϺ┘äϺÏ╣Ϭ┘àϺϻ Ï╣┘ä┘ë ÏóÏ▒ϺϪ┘ç┘àÏî Ϻ┘äϬ┘è Ï¿┘çϺ ┘èÏ¡┘â┘à┘ê┘åÏî ┘êÏÑ┘ä┘è┘çϺ ┘èÏ▒ϼÏ╣┘ê┘å ┘ü┘è Ϭ┘éÏ»┘èÏ▒ Ϻ┘ä┘àÏÁ┘äÏ¡Ï® Ϻ┘äϬ┘è Ï¿┘çϺ ┘èÏ│Ϭϼ┘èÏ▓┘ê┘å ┘äÏú┘å┘üÏ│┘ç┘à Ïú┘å ┘èÏ║┘èÏ▒┘êϺ Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘â┘à Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è ┘âϺ┘å┘êϺ ϿϺ┘äÏú┘àÏ│ Ϻ┘ä┘éÏ▒┘èÏ¿ Ï¿┘ç ┘èÏ»┘è┘å┘ê┘å Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘çÏî ┘â┘àÏ│Ïú┘äÏ® Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é ┘çÏ░┘çÏî ┘üϺ┘äÏ░┘è Ïú┘êÏ»┘ç Ïú┘å┘ç┘à ÏÑ┘å Ï║┘èÏ▒┘êϺ Ï¡┘â┘àϺ Ïú┘êϬÏ▒┘â┘êϺ ┘àÏ░┘çϿϺ ÏÑ┘ä┘ë ┘àÏ░┘çÏ¿ ÏóÏ«Ï▒Ïî Ïú┘å ┘è┘â┘ê┘å Ï░┘ä┘â ϺϬϿϺÏ╣Ϻ ┘à┘å┘ç┘à ┘ä┘äÏ│┘åÏ®Ïî ┘êÏú┘å ┘äϺ ┘è┘â┘ê┘å Ï░┘ä┘â ┘éϺÏÁÏ▒Ϻ Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘äÏúÏ¡┘âϺ┘à Ϻ┘ä┘éϺ┘å┘ê┘å┘èÏ® ┘êϺ┘äÏúÏ¡┘êϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ┤Ï«ÏÁ┘èÏ®Ïî Ï¿┘ä ┘èϼϿ Ïú┘å ┘èϬÏ╣Ï»┘êϺ Ï░┘ä┘â ÏÑ┘ä┘ë Ï╣ϿϺϻϺϬ┘ç┘à ┘ê┘àÏ╣Ϻ┘à┘äϺϬ┘ç┘à Ϻ┘äϫϺÏÁÏ® Ï¿┘ç┘àÏî ┘ü┘äÏ╣┘ä┘ç┘à ┘è┘üÏ╣┘ä┘ê┘å !

Ï▒Ï»: ÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ ┘äϺϬÏÁÏ¡ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é



1210 - " Ïú┘è┘àϺ Ï▒ϼ┘ä ÏÀ┘ä┘é Ϻ┘àÏ▒ÏúϬ┘ç Ͻ┘äϺϽϺ Ï╣┘åÏ» Ϻ┘äÏú┘éÏ▒ϺÏíÏî Ïú┘êϽ┘äϺϽϺ ┘àÏ¿┘ç┘àÏ®Ïî ┘ä┘à Ϭϡ┘ä ┘ä┘ç ϡϬ┘ë
Ϭ┘å┘âÏ¡ Ï▓┘êϼϺ Ï║┘èÏ▒┘ç ".
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏú┘äϿϺ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ│┘äÏ│┘äÏ® Ϻ┘äÏÂÏ╣┘è┘üÏ®:
ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è ( 7/336 ) ┘êϺ┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è " Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ╣ϼ┘à Ϻ┘ä┘âÏ¿┘èÏ▒ " ( Ï▒┘é┘à - 2757 ) ┘à┘å
ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é ┘àÏ¡┘àÏ» Ï¿┘å Ï¡┘à┘èÏ» Ϻ┘äÏ▒ϺÏ▓┘è : ┘åϺ Ï│┘ä┘àÏ® Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘ä┘üÏÂ┘ä Ï╣┘å Ï╣┘àÏ▒┘ê Ï¿┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è ┘é┘èÏ│ Ï╣┘å ÏÑÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘ç┘è┘à Ï¿┘å
Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏúÏ╣┘ä┘ë Ï╣┘å Ï│┘ê┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å Ï║┘ü┘äÏ® ┘éϺ┘ä :
" ┘âϺ┘åϬ Ï╣ϺϪÏ┤Ï® Ϻ┘äϫϽÏ╣┘à┘èÏ® Ï╣┘åÏ» Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï│┘å Ï¿┘å Ï╣┘ä┘è Ï▒ÏÂ┘è Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘å┘çÏî ┘ü┘ä┘àϺ ┘éϬ┘ä Ï╣┘ä┘è Ï▒ÏÂ┘è Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç
Ï╣┘å┘ç ┘éϺ┘äϬ : ┘äϬ┘ç┘åÏú┘â Ϻ┘äÏ«┘äϺ┘üÏ® ! ┘éϺ┘ä : Ï¿┘éϬ┘ä Ï╣┘ä┘è Ϭϩ┘çÏ▒┘è┘å Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘àϺϬϮ ! ϺÏ░┘çÏ¿┘è ┘üÏú┘åϬ ÏÀϺ┘ä┘é
Ïî ┘èÏ╣┘å┘è Ͻ┘äϺϽϺÏî ┘éϺ┘ä : ┘üϬ┘ä┘üÏ╣Ϭ ϿϽ┘èϺϿ┘çϺ ┘ê┘éÏ╣ϻϬ ϡϬ┘ë ┘éÏÂϬ Ï╣ϻϬ┘çϺÏî ┘üÏ¿Ï╣Ͻ ÏÑ┘ä┘è┘çϺ Ï¿Ï¿┘é┘èÏ®
Ï¿┘é┘èϬ ┘ä┘çϺ ┘à┘å ÏÁϻϺ┘é┘çϺÏî ┘êÏ╣Ï┤Ï▒Ï® Ïó┘äϺ┘ü ÏÁÏ»┘éÏ®Ïî ┘ü┘ä┘àϺ ϼϺÏí┘çϺ Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï│┘ê┘ä ┘éϺ┘äϬ : ┘àϬϺÏ╣ ┘é┘ä┘è┘ä
┘à┘å Ï¡Ï¿┘èÏ¿ ┘à┘üϺÏ▒┘éÏî ┘ü┘ä┘àϺ Ï¿┘äÏ║┘ç ┘é┘ê┘ä┘çϺ Ï¿┘â┘ë Ͻ┘à ┘éϺ┘ä : ┘ä┘ê┘äϺ Ïú┘å┘è Ï│┘àÏ╣Ϭ ϼϻ┘èÏî Ïú┘êϡϻϽ┘å┘è
ÏúÏ¿┘è Ïú┘å┘ç Ï│┘àÏ╣ ϼϻ┘è ┘è┘é┘ê┘ä : ( ┘üÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç ) ┘äÏ▒ϺϼÏ╣Ϭ┘çϺ ".
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ê┘çÏ░Ϻ ÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü ϼϻϺÏî ┘ê┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘äϬϺ┘å :
Ϻ┘äÏú┘ê┘ä┘ë : Ï│┘ä┘àÏ® Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘ä┘üÏÂ┘ä ┘ê┘ç┘ê Ϻ┘äÏúÏ¿Ï▒Ï┤ Ϻ┘ä┘éϺÏÂ┘èÏî ┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äϡϺ┘üÏ© :
" ÏÁÏ»┘ê┘é ┘âϽ┘èÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏ«ÏÀÏú ".
┘êϺ┘äÏúÏ«Ï▒┘ë : ┘àÏ¡┘àÏ» Ï¿┘å Ï¡┘à┘èÏ» Ϻ┘äÏ▒ϺÏ▓┘èÏî ┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äϡϺ┘üÏ© :
" ϡϺ┘üÏ© ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘üÏî ┘ê┘âϺ┘å ϺϿ┘å ┘àÏ╣┘è┘å Ï¡Ï│┘å Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ïú┘è ┘ü┘è┘ç ".
┘é┘äϬ : Ï¿┘ä ┘ç┘ê ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü ϼϻϺÏî ┘â┘àϺ ┘èϬϿ┘è┘å ┘ä┘à┘å Ï▒ϺϼÏ╣ Ïú┘é┘êϺ┘ä ÏúϪ┘àÏ® Ϻ┘äϼÏ▒Ï¡ ┘ü┘è┘çÏî ┘ê┘ä┘çÏ░Ϻ ┘éϺ┘ä
Ϻ┘äÏ░┘çÏ¿┘è ┘ü┘è " Ϻ┘äÏÂÏ╣┘üϺÏí " :" ┘éϺ┘ä ÏúÏ¿┘ê Ï▓Ï▒Ï╣Ï® : ┘âÏ░ϺϿÏî ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä ÏÁϺ┘äÏ¡ : ┘àϺ Ï▒Ïú┘èϬ ÏúÏ¡Ï░┘é ϿϺ┘ä┘âÏ░Ï¿ ┘à┘å┘ç ┘ê┘à┘å Ϻ┘äÏ┤ϺÏ░┘â┘ê┘å┘è ".
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ê┘äϺ ┘èϬ┘é┘ê┘ë ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ Ï¿┘é┘ê┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è Ï╣┘éÏ¿┘ç :
" ┘ê┘âÏ░┘ä┘â Ï▒┘ê┘è Ï╣┘å Ï╣┘àÏ▒┘ê Ï¿┘å Ï┤┘àÏ▒Ïî Ï╣┘å Ï╣┘àÏ▒Ϻ┘å Ï¿┘å ┘àÏ│┘ä┘à ┘êÏÑÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘ç┘è┘à Ï¿┘å Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏúÏ╣┘ä┘ë Ï╣┘å
Ï│┘ê┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å Ï║┘ü┘äÏ® ".
┘êÏ░┘ä┘â ┘äÏú┘å Ï╣┘àÏ▒┘ê Ï¿┘å Ï┤┘àÏ▒ ┘àϬ┘ç┘àÏî ┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äϿϫϺÏ▒┘è :
" ┘à┘å┘âÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ ".
┘ê┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘åÏ│ϺϪ┘è ┘êϺ┘äϻϺÏ▒┘éÏÀ┘å┘è ┘êÏ║┘èÏ▒┘ç┘àϺ :
" ┘àϬÏ▒┘ê┘â Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ ".
┘ê┘éϺ┘ä ϺϿ┘å ϡϿϺ┘å :
" Ï▒Ϻ┘üÏÂ┘è ┘èÏ┤Ϭ┘à Ϻ┘äÏÁϡϺϿϮÏî ┘ê┘èÏ▒┘ê┘è Ϻ┘ä┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣ϺϬ Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘äϽ┘éϺϬ ".
┘é┘äϬ : ÏÑÏ░Ϻ ϬϿ┘è┘å Ï░┘ä┘âÏî ┘ü┘à┘å Ϻ┘äÏ╣ϼ┘èÏ¿ ┘àϺ ┘å┘é┘ä┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èÏ« Ï▓Ϻ┘çÏ» Ϻ┘ä┘â┘êϽÏ▒┘è ┘ü┘è ┘âϬϺϿ┘ç "
Ϻ┘äÏÑÏ┤┘üϺ┘é Ï╣┘ä┘ë ÏúÏ¡┘âϺ┘à Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é " ( ÏÁ 24 ) Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘äϡϺ┘üÏ© ϺϿ┘å Ï▒ϼϿ Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘åÏ¿┘ä┘è Ï╣┘éÏ¿ ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ
Ïî ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä :
" ┘êÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ┘ç ÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡Ïî ┘éϺ┘ä┘ç ϺϿ┘å Ï▒ϼϿ Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘åÏ¿┘ä┘è Ϻ┘äϡϺ┘üÏ© Ï¿Ï╣Ï» Ïú┘å Ï│Ϻ┘é ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ ┘ü┘è ┘âϬϺϿ┘ç
( Ï¿┘èϺ┘å ┘àÏ┤┘â┘ä Ϻ┘äÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ Ϻ┘ä┘êϺÏ▒ϻϮ ┘ü┘è Ïú┘å Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é Ϻ┘äϽ┘äϺϽ ┘êϺϡϻϮ ) ".
┘üÏÑ┘å ÏÁÏ¡ ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘ä┘å┘é┘ä Ï╣┘å ϺϿ┘å Ï▒ϼϿ ┘üÏÑ┘å┘çϺ Ï▓┘äÏ® ┘üϺϡÏ┤Ï® ┘à┘å┘çÏî ┘êÏÑ┘äϺ ┘üϺ┘ä┘â┘êϽÏ▒┘è ┘àÏ╣Ï▒┘ê┘ü ┘äÏ»┘ë
Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ¡┘é┘é┘è┘å ┘à┘å Ïú┘ç┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ╣┘ä┘à ϿϺϬϿϺÏ╣┘ç ┘ä┘ç┘ê Ϻ┘ç ┘ü┘è ┘âϽ┘èÏ▒ ┘à┘àϺ ┘è┘å┘é┘äÏî Ïú┘ê┘èÏ¡┘â┘àÏî ┘ê┘à┘å Ï░┘ä┘â
Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ Ϻ┘äÏóϬ┘è Ï¿Ï╣Ï»┘ç.
┘ê┘éÏÁÏ® ÏÑ┘àϬϺÏ╣ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï│┘å Ϻ┘àÏ▒ÏúϬ┘ç ┘ê┘é┘ê┘ä┘çϺ : " ┘àϬϺÏ╣ ┘é┘ä┘è┘ä " ┘ä┘çϺ ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘éϺ┘å ÏóÏ«Ï▒Ϻ┘å Ï╣┘åÏ»
Ϻ┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘è ( 2561 ┘ê2562 ).

Ï▒Ï»: ÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ ┘äϺϬÏÁÏ¡ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é



1211 - " ÏÑ┘å ÏúϿϺ┘â┘à ┘ä┘à ┘èϬ┘é Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ϬÏ╣Ϻ┘ä┘ëÏî ┘ü┘èϼÏ╣┘ä ┘ä┘ç ┘à┘å Ïú┘àÏ▒┘ç ┘àÏ«Ï▒ϼϺÏî ϿϺ┘åϬ ┘à┘å┘ç ϿϽ┘äϺϽ Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ï║┘èÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏ│┘åÏ®Ïî ┘êϬÏ│Ï╣┘àϺϪϮ ┘êÏ│Ï¿Ï╣ ┘êϬÏ│Ï╣┘ê┘å ÏÑϽ┘à ┘ü┘è Ï╣┘å┘é┘ç ".
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏú┘äϿϺ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ│┘äÏ│┘äÏ® Ϻ┘äÏÂÏ╣┘è┘üÏ®:
ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü ϼϻϺ
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ϺϿ┘å Ï╣Ï»┘è ┘ü┘è " Ϻ┘ä┘âϺ┘à┘ä " ( ┘é 236/1 ) ┘êϺ┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è " Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ╣ϼ┘à Ϻ┘ä┘âÏ¿┘èÏ▒ " ┘à┘å
ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é Ï╣Ï¿┘èÏ» Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘ä┘ê┘ä┘èÏ» Ϻ┘ä┘êÏÁϺ┘ü┘è Ï╣┘å ϻϺ┘êÏ» Ï¿┘å ÏÑÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘ç┘è┘à Ï╣┘å Ï╣ϿϺϻϮ Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘äÏÁϺ┘àϬ
┘éϺ┘ä :
" ÏÀ┘ä┘é Ï¿Ï╣Ï ÏóϿϺϪ┘è Ϻ┘àÏ▒ÏúϬ┘ç Ïú┘ä┘üϺÏî ┘üϺ┘åÏÀ┘ä┘é Ï¿┘å┘ê┘ç ÏÑ┘ä┘ë Ï▒Ï│┘ê┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ÏÁ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ┘êÏ│┘ä┘à
┘ü┘éϺ┘ä┘êϺ : ┘èϺ Ï▒Ï│┘ê┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ÏÑ┘å ÏúϿϺ┘åϺ ÏÀ┘ä┘é Ïú┘à┘åϺ Ïú┘ä┘üϺÏî ┘ü┘ç┘ä ┘ä┘ç ┘à┘å ┘àÏ«Ï▒ϼ σ ┘éϺ┘ä.. "
┘üÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç.
┘ê┘ü┘è Ï▒┘êϺ┘èÏ® ┘ä┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘è Ï╣┘å Ï╣ϿϺϻϮ Ïú┘èÏÂϺ ┘éϺ┘ä :
" ÏÀ┘ä┘é ϼϻ┘è Ϻ┘àÏ▒ÏúÏ® ┘ä┘ç Ïú┘ä┘ü ϬÏÀ┘ä┘è┘éÏ®Ïî ┘üϺ┘åÏÀ┘ä┘éϬ ÏÑ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘åÏ¿┘è ÏÁ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ┘êÏ│┘ä┘à ┘üÏ│Ïú┘äϬ┘ç σ
┘ü┘éϺ┘ä : Ïú┘àϺ ϺϬ┘é┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ϼϻ┘â σ ! Ïú┘àϺ Ͻ┘äϺϽϮ ┘ü┘ä┘çÏî ┘êÏú┘àϺ ϬÏ│Ï╣┘àϺϪϮ ┘êÏ│Ï¿Ï╣Ï® ┘êϬÏ│Ï╣┘ê┘å
┘üÏ╣Ï»┘êϺ┘å ┘êÏ©┘ä┘àÏî ÏÑ┘å Ï┤ϺÏí Ï╣Ï░Ï¿┘ç ┘êÏÑ┘å Ï┤ϺÏí Ï║┘üÏ▒ ┘ä┘ç ".
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ç┘èϽ┘à┘è ┘ü┘è " ┘àϼ┘àÏ╣ Ϻ┘äÏ▓┘êϺϪϻ " ( 4/338 ) :
" Ï▒┘êϺ┘ç ┘â┘ä┘ç Ϻ┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘èÏî ┘ê┘ü┘è┘ç Ï╣Ï¿┘èÏ» Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘ä┘ê┘ä┘èÏ» Ϻ┘ä┘êÏÁϺ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ╣ϼ┘ä┘è ┘ê┘ç┘ê ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü ".
┘ê┘âÏ░Ϻ ┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äϡϺ┘üÏ© ┘ü┘è " Ϻ┘äϬ┘éÏ▒┘èÏ¿ " Ïú┘å┘ç ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü.
┘ê┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ░┘çÏ¿┘è ┘ü┘è " Ϻ┘äÏÂÏ╣┘üϺÏí " :
" ÏÂÏ╣┘ü┘ê┘ç ".
┘é┘äϬ : ┘êϺ┘äÏú┘éÏ▒Ï¿ ┘é┘ê┘ä ϺϿ┘å Ï╣Ï»┘è ┘ü┘è┘ç :
" Ϻ┘ä┘êÏÁϺ┘ü┘è ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü ϼϻϺÏî ┘èϬϿ┘è┘å ÏÂÏ╣┘ü┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ï¡Ï»┘èϽ┘ç ".
┘ê┘ü┘è ϬÏ▒ϼ┘àϬ┘ç Ï│Ϻ┘é ┘ä┘ç ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ ┘ü┘è ϼ┘à┘äÏ® ┘àϺ Ïú┘å┘âÏ▒ Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ┘à┘å Ï¡Ï»┘èϽ┘çÏî ┘ê┘âÏ░┘ä┘â ÏÁ┘åÏ╣
Ϻ┘äÏ░┘çÏ¿┘è ┘ü┘è " Ϻ┘ä┘à┘èÏ▓Ϻ┘å "Ïî ┘êÏ░┘âÏ▒ Ïú┘å Ϻ┘ä┘åÏ│ϺϪ┘è ┘êϺ┘ä┘ü┘äϺÏ│ ┘éϺ┘äϺ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘ä┘êÏÁϺ┘ü┘è :
" ┘àϬÏ▒┘ê┘â "Ïî Ïú┘è Ï┤Ï»┘èÏ» Ϻ┘äÏÂÏ╣┘ü.
┘ê┘éϺ┘ä ϺϿ┘å ϡϿϺ┘å ┘ü┘è " Ϻ┘äÏÂÏ╣┘üϺÏí ┘êϺ┘ä┘àϬÏ▒┘ê┘â┘è┘å " ( 2/63 ) :
" ┘à┘å┘âÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ ϼϻϺÏî ┘èÏ▒┘ê┘è Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘äϽ┘éϺϬ ┘àϺ ┘äϺ ┘èÏ┤Ï¿┘ç Ϻ┘äÏúϽϿϺϬÏî ϡϬ┘ë ┘èÏ│Ï¿┘é ÏÑ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘é┘äÏ¿
Ïú┘å┘ç Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ╣Ϭ┘àÏ» ┘ä┘ç ┘üϺÏ│Ϭϡ┘é Ϻ┘äϬÏ▒┘â ".
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ê┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ ┘èÏ▒┘ê┘è┘ç Ϻ┘ä┘êÏÁϺ┘ü┘è Ï╣┘å ϻϺ┘êÏ» Ï¿┘å ÏÑÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘ç┘è┘àÏî ┘ê┘ç┘ê ┘àϼ┘ç┘ê┘ä. ┘éϺ┘ä
Ϻ┘äÏ░┘çÏ¿┘è ┘êϬϿÏ╣┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ╣Ï│┘é┘äϺ┘å┘è : " ┘äϺ ┘èÏ╣Ï▒┘üÏî ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏúÏ▓Ï»┘è : ┘äϺ ┘èÏÁÏ¡ Ï¡Ï»┘èϽ┘ç ".
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ê┘âÏú┘å Ϻ┘äÏúÏ▓Ï»┘è Ï╣┘å┘ë Ï¡Ï»┘èϽ┘ç ┘çÏ░Ϻ. ┘êϺ┘ä┘ä┘ç ÏúÏ╣┘ä┘à.
┘ê┘àÏ╣ ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏÂÏ╣┘ü Ϻ┘äÏ┤Ï»┘èÏ» ┘ü┘è ÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽÏî ┘ü┘éÏ» Ï│┘âϬ Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èÏ« Ï▓Ϻ┘çÏ» Ϻ┘ä┘â┘êϽÏ▒┘è
┘ü┘è ┘âϬϺϿ┘ç Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ┤ϺÏ▒ ÏÑ┘ä┘è┘ç ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ Ϻ┘äÏ│ϺϿ┘éÏî Ï¿┘ä Ïú┘ê┘ç┘à Ïú┘å┘ç ┘äϺ Ï╣┘äÏ® ┘ü┘è┘ç ┘üÏÑ┘å┘ç ┘éϺ┘ä Ï¿Ï╣Ï»
Ïú┘å Ï│Ϻ┘é┘ç ┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é Ϻ┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘è ( ÏÁ 31 ) :
" ┘ê┘àϽ┘ä┘ç ┘ü┘è " ┘àÏ│┘åÏ» Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï▓Ϻ┘é " Ï╣┘å ϼϻ┘ç Ï╣ϿϺϻϮÏî ÏÑ┘äϺ Ïú┘å ┘ü┘è Ï▒┘êϺ┘èÏ® Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï▓Ϻ┘é
Ï╣┘ä┘äϺ " !
┘ü┘à┘ü┘ç┘ê┘à ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ïú┘å Ï▒┘êϺ┘èÏ® Ϻ┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘è ┘äϺ Ï╣┘ä┘ä ┘ü┘è┘çϺÏî Ï«┘äϺ┘üϺ ┘äÏ▒┘êϺ┘èÏ® Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï▓Ϻ┘éÏî ┘ê┘ä┘èÏ│
┘âÏ░┘ä┘âÏî ┘ü┘éÏ» Ï¿┘è┘åϺ ┘ä┘â Ïú┘å ┘ü┘è ÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ Ϻ┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘è Ï╣┘äϬ┘è┘å Ïú┘èÏÂϺÏî ┘ü┘èÏÁ┘èÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ Ï¿Ï░┘ä┘â ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘üϺ
ϼϻϺÏî ┘üÏÑ┘èϺ┘â Ïú┘å ϬÏ║ϬÏ▒ Ï¿┘à┘éϺ┘äϺϬ Ϻ┘ä┘â┘êϽÏ▒┘è ┘ê┘âϬϺϿϺϬ┘ç ┘üÏÑ┘å┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ï│Ï╣Ï® ϺÏÀ┘äϺÏ╣┘ç ┘êÏ╣┘ä┘à┘ç
┘àÏ»┘äÏ│ ÏÁϺϡϿ ┘ç┘ê ┘ëÏî ┘ê┘éÏ» Ï░┘âÏ▒┘åϺ Ï¿Ï╣Ï Ϻ┘äÏú┘àϽ┘äÏ® Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ï░┘ä┘â ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äϼÏ▓Ïí Ϻ┘äÏú┘ê┘ä ┘à┘å ┘çÏ░┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ│┘äÏ│┘äÏ®
Ïî ┘ê┘ä┘äÏ┤┘èÏ« Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï¡┘à┘å Ï¿┘å ┘èÏ¡┘è┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ╣┘ä┘à┘è Ϻ┘ä┘è┘àϺ┘å┘è ┘âϬϺϿ ÏÂÏ«┘à ┘çϺ┘à ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï» Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç
┘êϺ┘ä┘âÏ┤┘ü Ï╣┘å Ïú┘ç┘ê ϺϪ┘ç ┘êÏúÏÂϺ┘ä┘è┘ä┘çÏî ┘êϬÏ╣ÏÁÏ¿┘ç ┘ä┘àÏ░┘çÏ¿┘çÏî Ï╣┘ä┘ë ÏúϪ┘àÏ® Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ ┘êÏ▒ϼϺ┘ä┘çÏî
ÏúÏ│┘àϺ┘ç " Ϻ┘äϬ┘å┘â┘è┘ä Ï¿┘àϺ ┘ü┘è ϬÏú┘å┘èÏ¿ Ϻ┘ä┘â┘êϽÏ▒┘è ┘à┘å Ϻ┘äÏúϿϺÏÀ┘è┘ä "Ïî ┘ê┘ç┘ê ┘ü┘è ÏúÏ▒Ï¿Ï╣Ï® Ïú┘éÏ│Ϻ┘àÏî
┘ê┘éÏ» ┘â┘åϬ ┘é┘àϬ Ï╣┘ä┘ë ÏÀÏ¿Ï╣┘ç ┘êϺ┘äÏ¡┘àÏ» ┘ä┘ä┘ç ┘äÏú┘ê┘ä ┘àÏ▒Ï® ϿϬϡ┘é┘è┘é┘è ┘êϬÏ╣┘ä┘è┘é┘è ┘ü┘è ┘àϼ┘äÏ»┘è┘åÏî Ͻ┘à
ÏÀÏ¿Ï╣ Ï│Ï▒┘éÏ® ┘à┘å Ï¿Ï╣Ï Ϻ┘ä┘åϺÏ┤Ï▒┘è┘å Ïø ┘à┘å┘ç┘à ┘à┘å ÏÁ┘êÏ▒┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘ë ÏúÏ«ÏÀϺϪ┘ç Ϻ┘ä┘àÏÀÏ¿Ï╣┘èÏ® Ï»┘ê┘å Ïú┘è ϼ┘çÏ»Ïî
┘ê┘à┘å┘ç┘à ┘à┘å ÏÀÏ¿Ï╣┘ç Ï¿Ï¡Ï▒┘ü ϼϻ┘èÏ»Ïî ┘êϬÏÁÏ▒┘ü ┘äϺ ┘è┘ä┘è┘éÏî ┘ê┘éÏ» ÏúÏ╣Ï»┘åϺ Ϻ┘ä┘åÏ©Ï▒ ┘ü┘è┘ç ┘àϼϻϻϺÏî
ϺÏ│ϬÏ╣ϻϺϻϺ ┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï╣Ï® ϽϺ┘å┘èÏ® ÏÀÏ¿Ï╣Ï® ┘àÏÁÏ¡Ï¡Ï® ┘à┘å┘éÏ¡Ï®. ┘êϺ┘ä┘ä┘ç ┘ê┘ä┘è Ϻ┘äϬ┘ê┘ü┘è┘é.
Ͻ┘à ┘ê┘é┘üϬ Ï¿Ï╣Ï» Ï│┘å┘è┘å Ï╣┘ä┘ë ÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï▓Ϻ┘é ┘ü┘è " ┘àÏÁ┘å┘ü┘ç ┘ê┘éÏ» ÏÀÏ¿Ï╣ ┘ü┘è Ï¿┘èÏ▒┘êϬ Ï│┘åÏ® (
1392 ┘ç┘Ç ) ┘üÏÑÏ░Ϻ Ï¿┘ç ┘è┘é┘ê┘ä ┘ü┘è┘ç ( 11339 ) : ÏúÏ«Ï¿Ï▒┘åϺ ┘èÏ¡┘è┘ë Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘äÏ╣┘äϺÏí Ï╣┘å Ï╣Ï¿┘èÏ» Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï¿┘å
Ϻ┘ä┘ê┘ä┘èÏ» Ϻ┘äÏ╣ϼ┘ä┘è Ï╣┘å ÏÑÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘ç┘è┘à Ï╣┘å ϻϺ┘êÏ» Ï¿┘å Ï╣ϿϺϻϮ ┘éϺ┘ä : ÏÀ┘ä┘é ϼϻ┘è Ϻ┘àÏ▒ÏúÏ®.. ┘üÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç.
┘ç┘âÏ░Ϻ ┘ê┘éÏ╣ ┘ü┘è┘ç : ÏÑÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘ç┘è┘à Ï╣┘å ϻϺ┘êÏ».. ┘ê┘äÏ╣┘ä┘ç ┘à┘å ϬÏÂ┘ä┘è┘äϺϬ ┘èÏ¡┘è┘ë Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘äÏ╣┘äϺÏíÏî ┘üÏÑ┘å┘ç
┘âϺ┘å ┘âÏ░ϺϿϺ.
┘ê┘çÏ░Ϻ ┘èÏñ┘âÏ» ┘ä┘ä┘éϺÏ▒┘ëÏí ┘àϺ Ï░┘âÏ▒Ϭ┘ç Ïó┘å┘üϺ ┘ü┘è Ï¡┘é Ϻ┘ä┘â┘êϽÏ▒┘èÏî ┘êÏÑ┘äϺ ┘ä┘àϺ ϼϺÏ▓ ┘ä┘ç Ïú┘å ┘èÏ│┘âϬ
Ï╣┘å┘ç ┘ê┘è┘âϬ┘ü┘è Ï¿┘é┘ê┘ä┘ç : " ÏÑ┘å ┘ü┘è┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘äϺ " ! ┘äÏú┘å┘ç ┘äϺ ┘è┘éϺ┘ä ┘çÏ░Ϻ ┘ü┘è ϺÏÁÏÀ┘äϺϡ┘ç┘à ┘ê┘ü┘è┘ç┘à
Ϻ┘ä┘âÏ░ϺϿ ! ! Ï¿┘ä ┘ê┘ü┘è┘çÏú┘èÏÂϺ Ϻ┘äÏ╣┘äϬϺ┘å Ϻ┘ä┘àϬ┘éÏ»┘àϬϺ┘å ┘ü┘è Ï▒┘êϺ┘èÏ® Ϻ┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘è Ϻ┘äϬ┘è Ï│┘âϬ Ï╣┘å┘çϺ Ϻ┘ä┘â┘êϽÏ▒┘è ┘àÏÂ┘ä┘äϺ ┘ä┘ä┘éÏ▒ϺÏí ! ┘üϬÏú┘à┘ä ┘â┘à ┘ü┘è ┘â┘äϺ┘à Ϻ┘ä┘â┘êϽÏ▒┘è ┘à┘å Ϭϻ┘ä┘èÏ│ ┘êϬÏÂ┘ä┘è┘ä. ┘åÏ│Ïú┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ│┘äϺ┘àÏ®.

Ï▒Ï»: ÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ ┘äϺϬÏÁÏ¡ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é



2894 - ( ┘à┘å ÏÀ┘ä┘é Ϻ┘äϿϬϮ Ïú┘äÏ▓┘à┘åϺ┘ç Ͻ┘äϺϽϺ Ïî ┘äϺ Ϭϡ┘ä ┘ä┘ç ϡϬ┘ë Ϭ┘å┘âÏ¡ Ï▓┘êϼϺ Ï║┘èÏ▒┘ç ) .
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏú┘äϿϺ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ│┘äÏ│┘äÏ® Ϻ┘äÏÂÏ╣┘è┘üÏ®:
┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣
Ï▒┘êϺ┘ç ϺϿ┘å Ϻ┘ä┘åϼϺÏ▒ ( 10/169/2 ) Ï╣┘å Ï╣Ͻ┘àϺ┘å Ï¿┘å ┘àÏÀÏ▒ Ï╣┘å Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏ║┘ü┘êÏ▒ Ï╣┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è ┘çϺÏ┤┘à Ï╣┘å Ï▓ϺÏ░Ϻ┘å Ï╣┘å Ï╣┘ä┘è Ï▒ÏÂ┘è Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘å┘ç ┘éϺ┘ä : [ Ï│┘àÏ╣ ] Ï▒Ï│┘ê┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ÏÁ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ┘êÏ│┘ä┘à Ï▒ϼ┘äϺ ÏÀ┘ä┘é Ϻ┘äϿϬϮ ┘üÏ║ÏÂÏ¿ ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä : ϬϬϫÏ░┘ê┘å Ï»┘è┘å Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç - Ïú┘ê ┘éϺ┘ä : ϬϬϫÏ░┘ê┘å Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ϬÏ╣Ϻ┘ä┘ë - ┘çÏ▓┘êϺ ┘ê┘äÏ╣ϿϺ σ ! ┘à┘å ÏÀ┘ä┘é .. Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ .
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ê┘çÏ░Ϻ ÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ ┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣ Ïø Ïó┘üϬ┘ç Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏ║┘ü┘êÏ▒ ┘çÏ░Ϻ - ┘ê┘ç┘ê ÏúÏ¿┘ê Ϻ┘äÏÁϿϺϡ Ϻ┘ä┘êϺÏ│ÏÀ┘è - ┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äϿϫϺÏ▒┘è :
" ϬÏ▒┘â┘ê┘ç " . ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä ϺϿ┘å ϡϿϺ┘å :
" ┘âϺ┘å ┘à┘à┘å ┘èÏÂÏ╣ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ " .
┘êÏ╣Ͻ┘àϺ┘å Ï¿┘å ┘àÏÀÏ▒ Ïø ┘àϽ┘ä┘ç Ïú┘ê ┘åÏ¡┘ê┘ç Ïø ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä ϺϿ┘å ϡϿϺ┘å :
" ┘âϺ┘å ┘à┘à┘å ┘èÏÂÏ╣ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ " .
┘êÏ╣Ͻ┘àϺ┘å Ï¿┘å ┘àÏÀÏ▒ Ïø ┘àϽ┘ä┘ç Ïú┘ê ┘åÏ¡┘ê┘ç Ïø ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä ϺϿ┘å ϡϿϺ┘å :
" ┘âϺ┘å ┘à┘à┘å ┘èÏ▒┘ê┘è Ϻ┘ä┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣ϺϬ Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘äÏúϽϿϺϬ " .
┘ä┘â┘å ϬϺϿÏ╣┘ç ┘éϬ┘èÏ¿Ï® Ï¿┘å ┘à┘çÏ▒Ϻ┘å : ϡϻϽ┘åϺ Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏ║┘ü┘êÏ▒ Ï¿┘ç Ïø ┘ê┘ä┘üÏ©┘ç :
" ┘à┘å ÏÀ┘ä┘é Ϻ┘äϿϬϮ ϺϬϫÏ░ Ï»┘è┘å Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ┘çÏ▓┘êϺ ┘ê┘äÏ╣ϿϺ Ïî ┘êÏú┘äÏ▓┘à┘åϺ┘ç Ͻ┘äϺϽϺ Ïî ┘äϺ Ϭϡ┘ä ┘ä┘ç ϡϬ┘ë Ϭ┘å┘âÏ¡ Ï▓┘êϼϺ Ï║┘èÏ▒┘ç Ïî ┘èϻϫ┘ä Ï¿┘çϺ Ï¿┘äϺ ϫϻϺÏ╣ " .
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ÏúÏ¿┘ê ┘åÏ╣┘è┘à ┘ü┘è " ÏúϫϿϺÏ▒ ÏúÏÁÏ¿┘çϺ┘å " ( 2/164 - 165 ) ┘ü┘è ϬÏ▒ϼ┘àÏ® ┘éϬ┘èÏ¿Ï® ┘çÏ░Ϻ . ┘êÏ░┘âÏ▒ Ïú┘å┘ç Ï▒┘ê┘ë Ï╣┘å┘ç ϼ┘àÏ╣ Ïî ┘ê┘ä┘à ┘èÏ¡┘â ┘ü┘è┘ç ϼÏ▒ϡϺ ┘ê┘äϺ ϬÏ╣Ï»┘è┘äϺ . ┘ê┘ü┘è " Ϻ┘ä┘à┘èÏ▓Ϻ┘å " Ïú┘å┘ç ÏúÏÁÏ¿┘çϺ┘å┘è ┘àÏ┤┘ç┘êÏ▒ Ïî ÏúϽ┘å┘ë Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ┘è┘ê┘åÏ│ Ï¿┘å Ï¡Ï¿┘èÏ¿ Ïî ┘êÏú┘å┘ç ┘âϺ┘å ϼ┘ä┘è┘äϺ . ┘üϺ┘äÏó┘üÏ® ┘à┘å Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏ║┘ü┘êÏ▒ Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ░┘â┘êÏ▒ .
┘êÏ▒┘ê┘ë ÏúÏ¿┘ê Ϻ┘äÏÁ┘äϬ ÏÑÏ│┘àϺÏ╣┘è┘ä Ï¿┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è Ïú┘à┘èÏ® Ϻ┘äÏ░Ï▒ϺÏ╣ ┘à┘å Ï¡┘üÏ©┘ç : ϡϻϽ┘åϺ Ï¡┘àϺϻ Ï¿┘å Ï▓┘èÏ» : ÏúÏ«Ï¿Ï▒┘åϺ Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏ╣Ï▓┘èÏ▓ Ï¿┘å ÏÁ┘ç┘èÏ¿ Ï╣┘å Ïú┘åÏ│ Ï¿┘å ┘àϺ┘ä┘â ┘éϺ┘ä : Ï│┘àÏ╣Ϭ ┘àÏ╣ϺÏ░ Ï¿┘å ϼϿ┘ä Ï▒ÏÂ┘è Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘å┘ç ┘è┘é┘ê┘ä : ┘éϺ┘ä Ï▒Ï│┘ê┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ÏÁ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ┘êÏ│┘ä┘à : .... ┘üÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç ┘àϫϬÏÁÏ▒Ϻ Ï¿┘ä┘üÏ© :
" ┘à┘å ÏÀ┘ä┘é ┘ä┘äÏ¿Ï»Ï╣Ï® Ïú┘äÏ▓┘à┘åϺ┘ç Ï¿Ï»Ï╣Ϭ┘ç " .
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è ( 7/327 ) Ïî ┘ê┘âÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äϻϺÏ▒┘éÏÀ┘å┘è ( ÏÁ 433 ) ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä :
" ÏÑÏ│┘àϺÏ╣┘è┘ä Ï¿┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è Ïú┘à┘èÏ® ┘çÏ░Ϻ ┘â┘ê┘ü┘è ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ " .
┘êÏ▒┘ê┘ë Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è ┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é ÏúÏ¿┘è Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï¡┘à┘å Ϻ┘äÏ│┘ä┘à┘è : Ïú┘åÏ¿Ïú┘åϺ ÏúÏ¿┘ê Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï│┘å Ϻ┘äϻϺÏ▒┘éÏÀ┘å┘è Ϻ┘äϡϺ┘üÏ© ┘éϺ┘ä :
" ÏÑÏ│┘àϺÏ╣┘è┘ä Ï¿┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è Ïú┘à┘èÏ® Ϻ┘ä┘àÏÁÏ▒┘è ( ┘âÏ░Ϻ ) ┘àϬÏ▒┘ê┘â Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ " .
( Ϭ┘åÏ¿┘è┘ç ) : ϬÏÁÏ¡┘ü ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èÏ« Ϻ┘ä┘åÏ¿┘çϺ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è ┘âϬϺϿ┘ç " Ϻ┘ä┘üϬϡ Ϻ┘ä┘âÏ¿┘èÏ▒ " ┘ü┘ê┘éÏ╣ ┘ü┘è┘ç ( 3/210 ) : " ┘à┘å ÏÀ┘äÏ¿ Ϻ┘äÏ¿Ï»Ï╣Ï® ..... " !
┘êÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ Ïú┘åÏ│ Ï░┘âÏ▒┘ç ϺϿ┘å Ï¡Ï▓┘à ┘ü┘è " Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ¡┘ä┘ë " ( 10/164 ) ┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é ÏÑÏ│┘àϺÏ╣┘è┘ä ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ïî ┘ä┘â┘å┘ç ϼÏ╣┘ä┘ç ┘à┘å ┘àÏ│┘åÏ»┘ç ┘ä┘à ┘èÏ░┘âÏ▒ ┘àÏ╣ϺÏ░Ϻ ┘ü┘è┘ç Ïø ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä :
" Ï¡Ï»┘èϽ ┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣ Ï¿┘äϺ Ï┤┘â " .

Ï▒Ï»: ÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ ┘äϺϬÏÁÏ¡ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é



3776 - ( Ïú┘è┘àϺ Ï▒ϼ┘ä ÏÀ┘ä┘é Ϻ┘àÏ▒ÏúϬ┘ç Ͻ┘äϺϽϺ┘ï Ï╣┘åÏ» Ϻ┘äÏú┘éÏ▒ϺÏí Ïú┘ê Ͻ┘äϺϽϺ┘ï ┘àÏ¿┘ç┘àÏ® Ïø ┘ä┘à Ϭϡ┘ä ┘ä┘ç ϡϬ┘ë Ϭ┘å┘âÏ¡ Ï▓┘êϼϺ┘ï Ï║┘èÏ▒┘ç ) .
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏú┘äϿϺ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ│┘äÏ│┘äÏ® Ϻ┘äÏÂÏ╣┘è┘üÏ®:


ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü ϼϻϺ┘ï
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç Ϻ┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ╣ϼ┘à Ϻ┘ä┘âÏ¿┘èÏ▒" (1/ 133/ 1) Ïî ┘êϺ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è ┘ü┘è "Ï│┘å┘å┘ç" (7/ 336) Ï╣┘å ┘àÏ¡┘àÏ» Ï¿┘å Ï¡┘à┘èÏ» Ϻ┘äÏ▒ϺÏ▓┘è : ÏúÏ«Ï¿Ï▒┘åϺ Ï│┘ä┘àÏ® Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘ä┘üÏÂ┘ä Ïî Ï╣┘å Ï╣┘àÏ▒┘ê Ï¿┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è ┘é┘èÏ│ Ïî Ï╣┘å ÏÑÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘ç┘è┘à Ï¿┘å Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏúÏ╣┘ä┘ë Ïî Ï╣┘å Ï│┘ê┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å Ï║┘ü┘äÏ® ┘éϺ┘ä :
┘âϺ┘åϬ Ï╣ϺϪÏ┤Ï® Ϻ┘äϫϽÏ╣┘à┘èÏ® Ï╣┘åÏ» Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï│┘å Ï¿┘å Ï╣┘ä┘è - Ï▒ÏÂ┘è Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘å┘ç - Ïî ┘ü┘ä┘àϺ ┘éϬ┘ä Ï╣┘ä┘è - Ï▒ÏÂ┘è Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘å┘ç - ┘éϺ┘äϬ : ┘äϬ┘ç┘åϪ┘â Ϻ┘äÏ«┘äϺ┘üÏ® ! ┘éϺ┘ä : Ï¿┘éϬ┘ä Ï╣┘ä┘è Ϭϩ┘çÏ▒┘è┘å Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘àϺϬϮ σ! ϺÏ░┘çÏ¿┘è ┘üÏú┘åϬ ÏÀϺ┘ä┘é Ïî ┘èÏ╣┘å┘è Ͻ┘äϺϽϺ┘ï Ïî ┘éϺ┘ä : ┘üϬ┘üÏ╣┘äϬ ϿϽ┘èϺϿ┘çϺ Ïî ┘ê┘éÏ╣ϻϬ ϡϬ┘ë ┘éÏÂϬ Ï╣ϻϬ┘çϺ Ïî ┘üÏ¿Ï╣Ͻ ÏÑ┘ä┘è┘çϺ Ï¿Ï¿┘é┘èÏ® Ï¿┘é┘èϬ ┘ä┘çϺ ┘à┘å ÏÁϻϺ┘é┘çϺ Ïî ┘êÏ╣Ï┤Ï▒Ï® Ïó┘äϺ┘ü ÏÁÏ»┘éÏ® Ïî ┘ü┘ä┘àϺ ϼϺÏí┘çϺ Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï│┘ê┘ä ┘éϺ┘äϬ : (┘àϬϺÏ╣ ┘é┘ä┘è┘ä ┘à┘å Ï¡Ï¿┘èÏ¿ ┘à┘üϺÏ▒┘é) Ïî ┘ü┘ä┘àϺ Ï¿┘äÏ║┘ç ┘é┘ê┘ä┘çϺ Ïî Ï¿┘â┘ë Ïî Ͻ┘à ┘éϺ┘ä : ┘ä┘ê┘äϺ Ïú┘å┘è Ï│┘àÏ╣Ϭ ϼϻ┘è Ïø Ïú┘ê ϡϻϽ┘å┘è ÏúÏ¿┘è Ïî Ïú┘å┘ç Ï│┘àÏ╣ ϼϻ┘è ┘è┘é┘ê┘ä : (┘üÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç) ┘äÏ▒ϺϼÏ╣Ϭ┘çϺ . ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è :
"┘ê┘âÏ░┘ä┘â Ï▒┘ê┘è Ï╣┘å Ï╣┘àÏ▒┘ê Ï¿┘å Ï┤┘àÏ▒ Ïî Ï╣┘å Ï╣┘àÏ▒Ϻ┘å Ï¿┘å ┘àÏ│┘ä┘à ┘êÏÑÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘ç┘è┘à Ï¿┘å Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏúÏ╣┘ä┘ë Ïî Ï╣┘å Ï│┘ê┘èÏ» Ï¿┘å Ï║┘ü┘äÏ®" .
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘â┘êϽÏ▒┘è ┘ü┘è Ï▒Ï│Ϻ┘äϬ┘ç "Ϻ┘äÏÑÏ┤┘üϺ┘é" (ÏÁ 28) - Ï¿Ï╣Ï» ┘àϺ Ï╣Ï▓Ϻ┘ç ┘ä┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘è ┘êϺ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è - Ï╣┘éÏ¿┘ç :
"┘êÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ┘ç ÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡ Ïî ┘éϺ┘ä┘ç ϺϿ┘å Ï▒ϼϿ Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘åÏ¿┘ä┘è Ϻ┘äϡϺ┘üÏ© Ï¿Ï╣Ï» Ïú┘å Ï│Ϻ┘é Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ ┘ü┘è ┘âϬϺϿ┘ç : (Ï¿┘èϺ┘å ┘àÏ┤┘â┘ä Ϻ┘äÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ Ϻ┘ä┘êϺÏ▒ϻϮ ┘ü┘è Ïú┘å Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é Ϻ┘äϽ┘äϺϽ ┘êϺϡϻϮ)" (1) .
┘ê┘ä┘à ┘èϬÏ╣┘éÏ¿┘ç Ï¿Ï┤┘èÏí Ïø ┘à┘àϺ ┘èÏ»┘ä Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ïú┘å┘ç ┘à┘êϺ┘ü┘é ┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘äϬÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡ Ïî ┘ê┘çÏ░Ϻ Ïú┘àÏ▒ Ï╣ϼ┘èÏ¿ Ïî ┘äϺ Ï│┘è┘àϺ ┘à┘å ϺϿ┘å Ï▒ϼϿ Ïø ┘üÏÑ┘å Ϻ┘äÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ ┘äϺ ┘èϡϬ┘à┘ä Ϻ┘äϬϡÏ│┘è┘å Ïî ┘üÏÂ┘äϺ┘ï Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘äϬÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡ ! ┘üÏÑ┘å Ï│┘ä┘àÏ® Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘ä┘üÏÂ┘ä ÏÁÏ»┘ê┘é ┘âϽ┘èÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏ«ÏÀÏú . ┘ê┘àÏ¡┘àÏ» Ï¿┘å Ï¡┘à┘èÏ» Ϻ┘äÏ▒ϺÏ▓┘è ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü ┘â┘àϺ ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äϬ┘éÏ▒┘èÏ¿" Ïî Ï¿┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ▒ϺÏ▓┘è ┘éÏ» ϺϬ┘ç┘à┘ç Ï║┘èÏ▒ ┘êϺϡϻ ϿϺ┘ä┘âÏ░Ï¿ Ïî ┘êϬÏ│Ϻ┘ç┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ¿Ï╣Ï ┘ü┘è ÏÑÏ╣ÏÀϺϪ┘ç Ï¡┘é┘ç ┘à┘å Ϻ┘äϼÏ▒Ï¡ Ïø ┘ü┘éÏ» ┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ç┘èϽ┘à┘è ┘ü┘è "┘àϼ┘àÏ╣ Ϻ┘äÏ▓┘êϺϪϻ" (4/ 339) :
"Ï▒┘êϺ┘ç Ϻ┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘è Ïî ┘ê┘ü┘è Ï▒ϼϺ┘ä┘ç ÏÂÏ╣┘ü Ïî ┘ê┘éÏ» ┘êϽ┘é┘êϺ" .
┘üÏÑ┘å ┘éϺ┘ä ┘éϺϪ┘ä : Ïú┘ü┘äϺ ┘èϬ┘é┘ê┘ë Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ Ï¿ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é Ï╣┘àÏ▒┘ê Ï¿┘å Ï┤┘àÏ▒ Ϻ┘äϬ┘è Ï╣┘ä┘é┘çϺ Ϻ┘äÏ¿┘è┘ç┘é┘è σ ┘üÏú┘é┘ê┘ä : ┘â┘äϺ Ïø┘üÏÑ┘å Ï╣┘àÏ▒Ϻ┘ï ┘çÏ░Ϻ ┘âÏ░ϺϿ ┘èÏ▒┘ê┘è Ϻ┘ä┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣ϺϬ Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘äϽ┘éϺϬ Ïø ┘ü┘äϺ ┘èÏ│ϬÏ┤┘çÏ» Ï¿┘ç ┘ê┘äϺ ┘âÏ▒Ϻ┘àÏ® .
┘êϺÏ╣┘ä┘à Ïú┘å┘ç ┘äϺ ┘è┘êϼϻ Ï¡Ï»┘èϽ ÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡ ÏÁÏ▒┘èÏ¡ ┘ü┘è ÏÑ┘è┘éϺÏ╣ Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é Ï¿┘ä┘üÏ© Ͻ┘äϺϽϺ┘ï - Ͻ┘äϺϽϺ┘ï Ïî ┘ü┘äϺ ϬÏ║ϬÏ▒ Ï¿┘â┘äϺ┘à Ϻ┘ä┘â┘êϽÏ▒┘è ┘ü┘è ┘âϬϺϿ┘ç "Ϻ┘äÏÑÏ┤┘üϺ┘é" Ïø ┘üÏÑ┘å┘ç Ï║┘èÏ▒ ┘àÏ┤┘ü┘é Ï╣┘ä┘ë ┘å┘üÏ│┘ç Ïø ┘üÏÑ┘å┘ç ┘èϬ┘ü┘é ┘àÏ╣ Ϻ┘åÏ¡Ï▒Ϻ┘ü┘ç Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘äÏ│┘åÏ® Ïø ┘âϬÏú┘ê┘è┘ä┘ç Ï¡Ï»┘èϽ ϺϿ┘å Ï╣ϿϺÏ│ ┘ü┘è "ÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡ ┘àÏ│┘ä┘à" Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ïú┘å┘ç ┘ü┘è Ï║┘èÏ▒ Ϻ┘ä┘àϻϫ┘ê┘ä Ï¿┘çϺ ! ┘ê┘à┘å ÏúÏ▒Ϻϻ ┘à┘üÏ▒┘é Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘é ┘ü┘è ┘çÏ░┘ç Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ│Ïú┘äÏ® ┘ü┘ä┘èÏ▒ϺϼÏ╣ ┘âϬϿ Ï┤┘èÏ« Ϻ┘äÏÑÏ│┘äϺ┘à ϺϿ┘å Ϭ┘è┘à┘èÏ® ┘êϺ┘äÏÑ┘àϺ┘à ϺϿ┘å Ϻ┘ä┘é┘è┘à ┘êÏ║┘èÏ▒┘çϺ ┘à┘å ÏúϪ┘àÏ® Ϻ┘äÏ│┘åÏ® ┘êϺ┘äÏ░ϺϿ┘è┘å Ï╣┘å┘çϺ .
__________
(1) ┘ê┘å┘é┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘å┘ç Ïú┘èÏÂϺ ϺϿ┘å Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘ä┘çϺϻ┘è ┘ü┘è " Ï│┘èÏ▒ Ϻ┘äϡϺϽ ÏÑ┘ä┘ë Ï╣┘ä┘à Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é Ϻ┘äϽ┘äϺϽ " ( ┘é 206 / 2 )

Ï▒Ï»: ÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ ┘äϺϬÏÁÏ¡ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é



6102 - ( ÏÑ┘å ÏÑÏ¿┘ä┘èÏ│ ┘è┘èÏ╣Ͻ ϼ┘å┘êÏ»┘ç ┘â┘ä ÏÁϿϺϡ ┘ê┘àÏ│ϺÏí Ïø ┘ü┘è┘é┘ê┘ä: ┘à┘å
ÏúÏÂ┘ä Ï▒ϼ┘äϺ┘ï Ïú┘âÏ▒┘àϬ┘çÏî ┘ê┘à┘å ┘üÏ╣┘ä ┘âÏ░Ϻ ┘ü┘ä┘ç ┘âÏ░ϺÏî ┘ü┘èÏúϬ┘è ÏúÏ¡Ï»┘ç┘à ┘ü┘è┘é┘ê┘ä:
┘ä┘à ÏúÏ▓┘ä Ï¿┘ç ϡϬ┘ë ÏÀ┘ä┘é Ϻ┘àÏ▒ÏúϬ┘çÏî ┘éϺ┘ä: ┘èϬÏ▓┘êϼ ÏúÏ«Ï▒┘ëÏî ┘ü┘è┘é┘ê┘ä: ┘ä┘à ÏúÏ▓┘ä Ï¿┘ç
ϡϬ┘ë Ï▓┘å┘ëÏî ┘ü┘èϼ┘èÏ▓┘ç ┘ê┘è┘âÏ▒┘à┘çÏî ┘ê┘è┘é┘ê┘ä: ┘ä┘àϽ┘ä ┘çÏ░Ϻ ┘üϺÏ╣┘à┘ä┘êϺÏî ┘ê┘èÏúϬ┘è ÏóÏ«Ï▒
┘ü┘è┘é┘ê┘ä: ┘ä┘à ÏúÏ▓┘ä Ï¿┘ü┘äϺ┘å ϡϬ┘ë ┘éϬ┘äÏî ┘ü┘èÏÁ┘èÏ¡ ÏÁ┘èÏ¡Ï® ┘èϼϬ┘àÏ╣ ÏÑ┘ä┘è┘ç Ϻ┘äϼ┘å
┘ü┘è┘é┘ê┘ä┘ê┘å ┘ä┘ç: ┘èϺÏ│┘èÏ»┘åϺ ┘àϺ Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è ┘üÏ▒Ï¡┘â ┘ü┘è┘é┘ê┘ä: ÏúÏ«Ï¿Ï▒┘å┘è (1) ┘ü┘äϺ┘å Ïú┘å┘ç ┘ä┘à ┘èÏ▓┘ä Ï¿Ï▒ϼ┘ä ┘à┘å Ï¿┘å┘è ÏóÏ»┘à ┘è┘üϬ┘å┘ç ┘ê┘èÏÁÏ»┘ç ϡϬ┘ë ┘éϬ┘ä Ï▒ϼ┘äϺ┘ï ┘üϻϫ┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘åϺÏ▒Ïø
┘ü┘èϼ┘èÏ▓┘ç ┘ê┘è┘âÏ▒┘à┘ç ┘âÏ▒Ϻ┘àÏ® ┘ä┘à ┘è┘âÏ▒┘à Ï¿┘çϺ ÏúϡϻϺ┘ï ┘à┘å ϼ┘å┘êÏ»┘ç Ͻ┘à ┘èÏ»Ï╣┘ê ϿϺ┘äϬϺϼ Ïø
┘ü┘èÏÂÏ╣┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ï▒ÏúÏ│┘ç Ïî ┘ê┘èÏ│ϬÏ╣┘à┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç┘à ) .
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏú┘äϿϺ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ│┘äÏ│┘äÏ® Ϻ┘äÏÂÏ╣┘è┘üÏ®:
┘à┘å┘âÏ▒ ϼϻϺ┘ï Ï¿┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘äϬ┘àϺ┘à .
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ÏúÏ¿┘ê ┘åÏ╣┘è┘à ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘ä┘èÏ®" (8/28 - 129) ┘à┘å
ÏÀÏ▒┘è┘é ÏúÏ│┘àϺÏ╣┘è┘ä Ï¿┘å ┘èÏ▒┘èÏ» : Ͻ┘åϺ ÏÑÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘ç┘è┘à Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘äÏúÏ┤Ï╣Ͻ : Ͻ┘åϺ ┘üÏÂ┘è┘ä Ï¿┘å Ï╣┘èϺÏ Ï╣┘å
Ï╣ÏÀϺÏí Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘äÏ│ϺϪϿ Ï╣┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï¡┘à┘å Ϻ┘äÏ│┘ä┘à┘è Ï╣┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è ┘à┘êÏ│┘ë Ϻ┘äÏúÏ┤Ï╣Ï▒┘è ┘èÏ▒┘üÏ╣┘ç
ÏÑ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘åÏ¿┘è ÏÁ┘Ä┘ä┘æ┘Ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘æ┘Ä┘ç┘Å Ï╣┘Ä┘ä┘Ä┘è┘Æ┘ç┘É ┘ê┘ÄÏ│┘Ä┘ä┘æ┘Ä┘à┘Ä .
┘é┘äϬ : ┘ê┘çÏ░Ϻ ÏÑÏ│┘åϺϻ ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü Ïø ÏÑÏ│┘àϺÏ╣┘è┘ä Ï¿┘å ┘èÏ▓┘èÏ» ┘ä┘à ÏúÏ╣Ï▒┘ü┘ç Ïî ┘ê┘èϡϬ┘à┘ä Ïú┘å┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è
┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äϼÏ▒Ï¡ ┘êϺ┘äϬÏ╣Ï»┘è┘ä" (1/1/ 205) :
" ÏÑÏ│┘àϺÏ╣┘è┘ä Ï¿┘å ┘èÏ▓┘èÏ» Ïî ϫϺ┘ä ÏúÏ¿┘è Ïî ┘êÏ╣┘à ÏúÏ¿┘è Ï▓Ï▒Ï╣Ï® Ïî Ï▒┘ê┘ë Ï╣┘å Ϻ┘äÏ│┘åÏ»┘è Ï¿┘å Ï╣Ï¿Ï»┘ê┘è┘ç Ïî
┘êÏÑÏ│ϡϺ┘é Ï¿┘å Ï│┘ä┘è┘àϺ┘å Ïî ┘êÏ╣ϿϻϺ┘äÏÁ┘àÏ» Ϻ┘äÏ╣ÏÀϺÏ▒ Ïî ┘êÏ╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï¿┘å ┘çϺÏ┤┘à . Ï▒┘ê┘ë Ï╣┘å┘ç ÏúÏ¿┘è .
Ï│Ϫ┘ä ÏúÏ¿┘è Ï╣┘å┘ç σ ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä : ÏÁÏ»┘ê┘é " .
┘êÏÑÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘ç┘è┘à Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘äÏúÏ┤Ï╣Ͻ Ïî ┘ê┘ç┘ê : Ϻ┘äϿϫϺÏ▒┘è ϫϺϻ┘à Ϻ┘ä┘üÏÂ┘è┘ä Ï¿┘å Ï╣┘èϺÏ Ïî ┘êϽ┘é┘ç
Ï¿Ï╣ÏÂ┘ç┘à Ïî ┘ä┘â┘å ┘éϺ┘ä ϺϿ┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è ϡϺϬ┘à (1/1/88) :
"Ï│Ïú┘äϬ ÏúÏ¿┘è Ï╣┘å┘ç Ïî ┘êÏ░┘âÏ▒Ϭ ┘ä┘ç Ï¡Ï»┘èϽϺ┘ï Ï▒┘êϺ┘ç Ï╣┘å ┘àÏ╣┘å Ïî Ï╣┘å ϺϿ┘å ÏúÏ«┘è Ϻ┘äÏ▓┘çÏ▒┘è Ï╣┘å
Ϻ┘äÏ▓┘çÏ▒┘è σ ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä : ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ï¡Ï»┘èϽ ϿϺÏÀ┘ä ┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣ Ïî ┘â┘åϺ ┘åÏ©┘å Ï¿┘Ç (ÏÑÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘ç┘è┘à Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘äÏúÏ┤Ï╣Ͻ)
Ϻ┘äÏ«┘èÏ▒ Ïø ┘ü┘éÏ» ϼϺÏí Ï¿┘àϽ┘ä ┘çÏ░Ϻ ! " .
┘êÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç ÏÑÏ¿┘å ϡϿϺ┘å ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äϽ┘éϺϬ" ! ┘àÏ╣ Ïú┘å┘ç ┘éϺ┘ä ┘ü┘è┘ç (8/66) :
"┘èÏ║Ï▒Ï¿ Ïî ┘ê┘èϬ┘üÏ▒Ï» Ïî ┘ê┘èÏ«ÏÀϪ ┘ê┘èϫϺ┘ä┘ü" !
┘ü┘ç┘ä ┘à┘å ┘âϺ┘å ┘çÏ░┘ç ÏÁ┘üϬ┘ç ┘è┘â┘ê┘å Ͻ┘éÏ® σ! ┘ê┘éÏ» ┘è┘é┘ê┘ä ┘ü┘è Ï¿Ï╣Ï Ï▒ϼϺ┘ä┘ç (6/98) :
"Ï»┘äÏ│ Ï╣┘å Ïú┘åÏ│ Ïî ┘èÏ«ÏÀϪ ┘âϽ┘èÏ▒Ϻ┘ï " σ!
┘êÏ╣ÏÀϺÏí Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘äÏ│ϺϪϿ ┘âϺ┘å ┘éÏ» ϺϫϬ┘äÏÀ Ïî ┘ê┘üÏÂ┘è┘ä Ï¿┘å Ï╣┘èϺÏ ┘ä┘à ┘èÏ░┘âÏ▒ ┘ü┘è┘à┘å Ï│┘àÏ╣
┘à┘å┘ç ┘éÏ¿┘ä Ϻ┘äϺϫϬ┘äϺÏÀ . ┘ä┘â┘å ┘éÏ» Ï▒┘êϺ┘ç Ï╣┘å┘ç Ï│┘ü┘èϺ┘å Ï╣┘å Ï╣ÏÀϺÏí Ï¿┘ç ┘àϫϬÏÁÏ▒Ϻ┘ï .
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç ϺϿ┘å ϡϿϺ┘å ┘ü┘è "ÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡┘ç " (44/63) Ïî ┘ê┘äÏ░┘ä┘â ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼϬ┘ç ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡Ï® "
(1280) Ïî ┘êÏÁÏ¡Ï¡┘ç Ϻ┘äϡϺ┘â┘à (4/ 350) ┘ê┘êϺ┘ü┘é┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ░┘çÏ¿┘è Ïî ┘ê┘ç┘ê ┘â┘àϺ ┘éϺ┘äϺ .
┘ê┘ä┘çÏ░Ϻ Ϻ┘ä┘àϫϬÏÁÏ▒ Ï┤Ϻ┘çÏ» ÏúÏ«ÏÁÏ▒ ┘à┘å┘ç ┘à┘å Ï¡Ï»┘èϽ ϼϺϿÏ▒ Ï╣┘åÏ» ┘àÏ│┘ä┘à ┘êÏ║┘èÏ▒┘ç ┘à┘å Ï▒┘êϺ┘èÏ®
Ϻ┘äÏúÏ╣┘àÏ┤ Ï╣┘å ÏúÏ¿┘è Ï│┘ü┘èϺ┘å Ï╣┘å┘ç Ïî ┘ê┘â┘åϬ Ï«Ï▒ϼϬ┘ç ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡Ï®" Ïú┘èÏÂϺ┘ï Ï¿Ï▒┘é┘à (3261) .
Ͻ┘à ϿϻϺ ┘ä┘è ┘ü┘è┘ç ÏÑÏ┤┘âϺ┘ä Ï│Ï¿Ï¿┘ç - ┘êϺ┘ä┘ä┘ç ÏúÏ╣┘ä┘à - Ϻ┘äϺϫϬÏÁϺÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è ┘ê┘éÏ╣ ┘ü┘è┘ç ┘à┘å Ï¿Ï╣ÏÂ
Ϻ┘äÏ▒┘êϺϮ Ïî Ïú┘ê ┘à┘å Ï╣┘åÏ╣┘åÏ® Ϻ┘äÏúÏ╣┘àÏ┤ Ïî ┘üÏÑ┘å ┘ü┘è┘ç :
"Ͻ┘à ┘èϼ┘èÏí ÏúÏ¡Ï»┘ç┘à ┘ü┘è┘é┘ê┘ä : ┘àϺ ϬÏ▒┘âϬ┘ç ϡϬ┘ë ┘ü┘ÄÏ▒┘æ┘Ä┘éϬ Ï¿┘è┘å┘ç ┘êÏ¿┘è┘å Ϻ┘àÏ▒ÏúϬ┘ç Ïø ┘ü┘èÏ»┘å┘è┘ç ┘à┘å┘ç
┘ê┘è┘é┘ê┘ä : ┘å┘ÉÏ╣┘à┘Ä Ïú┘åϬ! ┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏúÏ╣┘àÏ┤ : ÏúÏ▒Ϻ┘ç ┘éϺ┘ä : ┘ü┘è┘äϬÏ▓┘à┘ç " .
┘üÏ©┘å┘åϬ Ïú┘å┘ç Ï│┘éÏÀ ┘à┘å┘ç ┘é┘ê┘ä ÏÑÏ¿┘ä┘èÏ│ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è ┘üÏ▒┘é : "Ïú┘êÏ┤┘â Ïú┘å ┘èϬÏ▓┘êϼ " Ïî ┘â┘àϺ
Ï│┘éÏÀ ┘à┘å┘ç ┘éÏÁÏ® Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è ┘ä┘à ┘èÏ▓┘ä Ï¿┘ç ϡϬ┘ë ┘éϬ┘ä Ïî ┘ê┘ç┘ê Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è ┘éϺ┘ä ┘ä┘ç ÏÑÏ¿┘ä┘èÏ│ : ┘åÏ╣┘à Ïø Ïú┘åϬ .
┘ê┘çÏ░Ϻ ϽϺϿϬ ┘ü┘É┘è Ï¡┘ÄÏ»┘É┘èϽ┘É Ï│┘ü┘èϺ┘å Ϻ┘äÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡ . ┘êϺ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï│ϿϡϺ┘å┘ç ┘êϬÏ╣Ϻ┘ä┘ë ÏúÏ╣┘ä┘à .
Ͻ┘à Ï▒Ïú┘èϬ Ϻ┘ä┘üÏÂ┘è┘ä Ï¿┘å Ï╣┘èϺÏ ┘éÏ» ϬϺϿÏ╣┘ç ÏÑÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘ç┘è┘à Ï¿┘å ÏÀ┘ç┘àϺ┘å Ï╣┘å Ï╣ÏÀϺÏí Ï¿┘å
Ϻ┘äÏ│ϺϪϿ Ï¿┘ä┘üÏ© Ïú┘ÄÏ«┘ÆÏÁ┘ÄÏ▒┘Ä ┘à┘å ┘ä┘üÏ©┘ç ┘êÏ▓Ϻϻ Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç Ïø ┘ê┘ç┘ê :
"ÏÑ┘å ÏÑÏ¿┘ä┘èÏ│ Ï¿Ï╣Ͻ ϼ┘å┘êÏ»┘ç ÏÑ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ│┘ä┘à┘è┘å Ïî ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä : Ïú┘è┘â┘à Ïú┘ÄÏÂ┘Ä┘ä┘æ┘Ä Ï▒ϼ┘äϺ┘ï Ïî Ïú┘Å┘ä┘ÆÏ¿┘ÉÏ│┘Å┘ç┘ŠϺ┘äϬ┘æ┘ÄϺϼ┘Ä Ïƒ
┘üÏÑÏ░Ϻ Ï▒ϼÏ╣┘êϺ Ïî ┘éϺ┘ä ┘äÏ¿Ï╣ÏÂ┘ç┘à : ┘àϺ ÏÁ┘åÏ╣Ϭσ ┘éϺ┘ä : Ïú┘ä┘é┘èϬ Ï¿┘è┘å┘ç ┘êÏ¿┘è┘å ÏúÏ«┘è┘ç Ï╣ϻϺ┘êÏ®! ┘éϺ┘ä :
┘àϺ ÏÁ┘åÏ╣Ϭ Ï┤┘èϪϺ┘ï Ïø Ï│┘ê┘ü ┘èÏÁϺ┘äÏ¡┘ç . Ͻ┘à ┘è┘é┘ê┘ä ┘ä┘äÏóÏ«Ï▒ : ┘üÏú┘åϬ ┘àϺ ÏÁ┘åÏ╣Ϭ σ ┘éϺ┘ä : ┘àϺ Ï▓┘äϬ Ï¿┘ç ϡϬ┘ë ÏÀ┘ä┘é Ϻ┘àÏ▒ÏúϬ┘ç! ┘éϺ┘ä : ┘àϺ ÏÁ┘åÏ╣Ϭ Ï┤┘èϪϺ┘ï Ïø Ï╣Ï│┘ë ┘èϬÏ▓┘êϼ ÏúÏ«Ï▒┘ë . ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä ┘ä┘äÏóÏ«Ï▒ : ┘àϺ
ÏÁ┘åÏ╣Ϭ σ ┘éϺ┘ä : ┘ä┘à ÏúÏ▓┘ä Ï¿┘ç ϡϬ┘ë Ï┤Ï▒Ï¿ Ϻ┘äÏ«┘àÏ▒! ┘éϺ┘ä : Ïú┘åϬ Ïú┘åϬ!
Ͻ┘à ┘è┘é┘ê┘ä ┘ä┘äÏóÏ«Ï▒ : ┘üÏú┘åϬ ┘àϺ ÏÁ┘åÏ╣Ϭ σ ┘éϺ┘ä : ┘àϺ Ï▓┘äϬ Ï¿┘ç ϡϬ┘ë Ï▓┘å┘ë! ┘éϺ┘ä : Ïú┘åϬ
Ïú┘åϬ!
Ͻ┘à ┘è┘é┘ê┘ä ┘ä┘äÏóÏ«Ï▒ : ┘üÏú┘åϬ ┘àϺ ÏÁ┘åÏ╣Ϭ σ ┘éϺ┘ä : ┘àϺ Ï▓┘äϬ Ï¿┘ç ϡϬ┘ë ┘éϬ┘ä! ┘ü┘è┘é┘ê┘ä : Ïú┘åϬ
Ïú┘åϬ ! " .
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç Ϻ┘äÏúÏÁÏ¿┘çϺ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äϬÏ▒Ï║┘èÏ¿ " (Ï▒┘é┘à 1213 ┘ê 1468) .
┘êÏÑÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘ç┘è┘à Ï¿┘å ÏÀ┘ç┘àϺ┘å Ͻ┘éÏ® Ïî ┘ê┘ä┘â┘å┘ç ┘ä┘à ┘èÏ░┘âÏ▒ Ïú┘èÏÂϺ┘ï ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ▒┘êϺϮ Ï╣┘å Ï╣ÏÀϺÏí ┘éÏ¿┘ä
ϺϫϬ┘äϺÏÀ┘ç Ïø ┘ü┘ç┘ê Ϻ┘äÏ╣┘äÏ® Ïî ┘êϺÏÂÏÀÏ▒ϺϿ┘ç ┘ü┘è ÏÂÏ¿ÏÀ┘ç Ï▓┘èϺϻϮ ┘ê┘å┘éÏÁϺ┘ï Ïî ┘êϺϫϬ┘äϺ┘üϺ┘ï ┘ü┘è Ï¿Ï╣ÏÂ
Ϻ┘äϼ┘à┘ä ┘à┘å Ϻ┘äÏúÏ»┘äÏ® Ï╣┘ä┘ë ϺϫϬ┘äϺÏÀ┘ç Ïø ┘ü┘äϺ ┘èÏ╣Ϭ┘àÏ» ┘à┘å┘ç ÏÑ┘äϺ Ï▒┘êϺ┘èÏ® Ï│┘ü┘èϺ┘å Ï╣┘å┘ç ┘â┘àϺ Ϭ┘éÏ»┘à .
┘êϺ┘ä┘ä┘ç ÏúÏ╣┘ä┘à .
__________
(1) Ϻ┘äÏúÏÁ┘ä : (ÏúÏ¡Ï» Ï¿┘å┘è) Ïø ┘êϺ┘äϬÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡ ┘à┘å "Ϻ┘äϼϺ┘àÏ╣ Ϻ┘ä┘âÏ¿┘èÏ▒" Ïî ┘ê┘éÏ» Ï╣Ï▓Ϻ┘ç ┘ä┘Ç "Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘ä┘èÏ®" .

Ï▒Ï»: ÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ ┘äϺϬÏÁÏ¡ ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏÀ┘äϺ┘é



6340 - ( ÏÑ┘É┘å┘æ┘Ä Ïº┘ä┘ä┘æ┘Ä┘ç┘Ä Ï¬┘ÄÏ╣┘ÄϺ┘ä┘Ä┘ë ┘è┘ÄÏú┘Æ┘à┘ÅÏ▒┘Å┘â┘Ä Ïú┘Ä┘å┘Æ Ï¬┘ÅÏ▒┘ÄϺϼ┘ÉÏ╣┘Ä Ï¡┘Ä┘ü┘ÆÏÁ┘ÄÏ®┘Ä Ï▒┘ÄÏ¡┘Æ┘à┘ÄÏ®┘ï ┘ä┘ÉÏ╣┘Å┘à┘ÄÏ▒┘Ä ) .
┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏú┘äϿϺ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ│┘äÏ│┘äÏ® Ϻ┘äÏÂÏ╣┘è┘üÏ®:
┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣ .
ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼ┘ç Ϻ┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘è ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ╣ϼ┘à Ϻ┘ä┘âÏ¿┘èÏ▒" (17/291 - 292) : ϡϻϽ┘åϺ
Ïú┘ÄÏ¡┘Æ┘à┘ÄÏ»┘Å Ï¿┘å ÏÀ┘ÄϺ┘ç┘ÉÏ▒┘É Ï¿┘å Ï¡┘ÄÏ▒┘Æ┘à┘Ä┘ä┘ÄÏ®┘Ä Ï¿┘å ┘è┘ÄÏ¡┘Æ┘è┘Ä┘ë : Ï¡┘ÄÏ»┘æ┘ÄϽ┘Ä┘å┘É┘è Ï¡┘ÄÏ▒┘Æ┘à┘Ä┘ä┘ÄÏ®┘Å Ï¿┘å ┘è┘ÄÏ¡┘Æ┘è┘Ä┘ë : [Ͻ┘Ä┘å┘ÄϺ] (*) ϺϿ┘Æ┘å┘Å
┘ê┘Ä┘ç┘ÆÏ¿┘ì: Ï¡┘ÄÏ»┘æ┘ÄϽ┘Ä┘å┘É┘è Ï╣┘Ä┘à┘ÆÏ▒┘Å┘ê Ï¿┘å ÏÁ┘ÄϺ┘ä┘ÉÏ¡┘ì Ϻ┘ä┘ÆÏ¡┘ÄÏÂ┘ÆÏ▒┘Ä┘à┘É┘è┘æ┘Å Ï╣┘Ä┘å┘Æ ┘à┘Å┘êÏ│┘Ä┘ë Ï¿┘å Ï╣┘Ä┘ä┘É┘è┘æ┘ì Ï╣┘Ä┘å┘Æ Ïú┘ÄÏ¿┘É┘è┘ç┘É Ï╣┘Ä┘å┘Æ Ï╣┘Å┘é┘ÆÏ¿┘ÄÏ®┘Ä
Ï¿┘å Ï╣┘ÄϺ┘à┘ÉÏ▒┘ì Ϻ┘ä┘Æϼ┘Å┘ç┘Ä┘å┘É┘è┘æ┘É:
Ïú┘Ä┘å┘æ Ϻ┘ä┘å┘æ┘ÄÏ¿┘É┘è┘æ┘Ä ÏÁ┘Ä┘ä┘æ┘Ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘æ┘Ä┘ç┘Å Ï╣┘Ä┘ä┘Ä┘è┘Æ┘ç┘É ┘ê┘ÄÏ│┘Ä┘ä┘æ┘Ä┘à┘Ä ÏÀ┘Ä┘ä┘æ┘Ä┘é┘Ä Ï¡┘Ä┘ü┘ÆÏÁ┘ÄÏ®┘Ä Ïî ┘ü┘ÄÏ¿┘Ä┘ä┘ÄÏ║┘Ä Ï░┘Ä┘ä┘É┘â┘Ä Ï╣┘Å┘à┘ÄÏ▒┘Ä Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘ä┘ÆÏ«┘ÄÏÀ┘æ┘ÄϺϿ┘ÉÏî ┘ü┘Ä┘ê┘ÄÏÂ┘ÄÏ╣┘Ä Ïº┘äϬ┘æ┘ÅÏ▒┘ÄϺϿ┘Ä Ï╣┘Ä┘ä┘Ä┘ë
┘êϼ┘ç┘ç (*) Ïî ┘ü┘Ä┘é┘ÄϺ┘ä┘Ä: ┘à┘ÄϺ ┘è┘ÄÏ╣┘ÆÏ¿┘ÄÏú┘ŠϺ┘ä┘ä┘æ┘Ä┘ç┘Å Ï¿┘É┘â┘Ä ┘è┘ÄϺ ϺϿ┘Æ┘å┘Ä Ïº┘ä┘ÆÏ«┘ÄÏÀ┘æ┘ÄϺϿ┘É Ï¿┘ÄÏ╣┘ÆÏ»┘Ä ┘ç┘ÄÏ░┘ÄϺ !┘ü┘Ä┘å┘ÄÏ▓┘Ä┘ä┘Ä Ï¼┘ÉÏ¿┘ÆÏ▒┘É┘è┘ä┘Å Ï╣┘Ä┘ä┘Ä┘è┘Æ┘ç┘É Ïº┘äÏ│┘æ┘Ä┘äϺ┘à┘Å
┘ü┘Ä┘é┘ÄϺ┘ä┘Ä: ... ┘üÏ░┘âÏ▒┘ç.
┘é┘äϬ ┘ê┘çÏ░Ϻ ┘à┘êÏÂ┘êÏ╣ Ïî Ïó┘üϬ┘ç ÏúÏ¡┘àÏ» Ï¿┘å ÏÀϺ┘çÏ▒ ┘çÏ░Ϻ : ┘éϺ┘ä ϺϿ┘å Ï╣Ï»┘è ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘ä┘âϺ┘à┘ä"
(1/196):
"ÏÂÏ╣┘è┘ü ϼϻϺ┘ï Ïî ┘è┘âÏ░Ï¿ ┘ü┘É┘è Ï¡┘ÄÏ»┘É┘èϽ┘É Ï▒Ï│┘ê┘ä Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ÏÁ┘ä┘ë Ϻ┘ä┘ç Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç ┘êÏ│┘ä┘à ÏÑÏ░Ϻ Ï▒┘ê┘ë Ïî┘ê┘è┘âÏ░Ï¿ ┘ü┘É┘è
Ï¡┘ÄÏ»┘É┘èϽ┘É Ïº┘ä┘åϺÏ│ ÏÑÏ░Ϻ ϡϻϽ Ï╣┘å┘ç┘à".
Ͻ┘à Ï│Ϻ┘é ┘ä┘ç Ï¿Ï╣Ï Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘âϺ┘èϺϬ ϩϺ┘çÏ▒Ï® Ϻ┘äÏ¿ÏÀ┘äϺ┘å . ┘ê┘éÏ» ┘âÏ░Ï¿┘ç Ϻ┘äϻϺÏ▒┘éÏÀ┘å┘è ┘êϺϿ┘å ϡϿϺ┘å Ïî
┘êϬ┘éÏ»┘àϬ ┘ä┘ç Ï¿Ï╣Ï Ϻ┘äÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ Ϻ┘äϬ┘è Ϭϻ┘ä Ï╣┘ä┘ë ┘âÏ░Ï¿┘ç Ïî ┘üϺ┘åÏ©Ï▒┘çϺ Ï¿Ï▒┘é┘à (139 ┘ê 1923) .
┘ê┘éÏ» Ï║┘ü┘ä Ï╣┘å┘ç Ϻ┘ä┘ç┘èϽ┘à┘è Ïî ┘ü┘éϺ┘ä ┘ü┘è ┘à┘êÏÂÏ╣┘è┘å ┘à┘å "┘àÏ╣ϼ┘à┘ç" (4/334 ┘ê9/244) : "Ï▒┘êϺ┘ç Ϻ┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘è Ïî ┘ê┘ü┘è┘ç Ï╣┘àÏ▒┘ê Ï¿┘å ÏÁϺ┘äÏ¡ Ϻ┘äÏ¡ÏÂÏ▒┘à┘è ┘ê┘ä┘à ÏúÏ╣Ï▒┘ü┘ç Ïî ┘êÏ¿┘é┘èÏ® Ï▒ϼϺ┘ä┘ç
Ͻ┘éϺϬ" !
┘âÏ░Ϻ ┘éϺ┘ä ! ┘ê┘ç┘è Ï║┘ü┘äÏ® Ï╣ϼ┘èÏ¿Ï® ┘à┘å┘ç Ïî ┘ü┘éÏ» ┘êϺ┘ü┘é Ϻ┘äϻϺÏ▒┘éÏÀ┘å┘è Ï╣┘ä┘ë ┘é┘ê┘ä┘ç ┘ü┘è┘ç :
"┘âÏ░ϺϿ" ┘ü┘è Ïú┘âϽÏ▒ ┘à┘å Ï¡Ï»┘èϽ ┘êϺϡϻ Ïî ┘ê┘à┘å┘çϺ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽϺ┘å Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ┤ϺÏ▒ ÏÑ┘ä┘è┘ç┘àϺ Ïó┘å┘üϺ┘ï Ïî ┘ü┘Äϼ┘Ä┘ä┘æ┘Ä ┘à┘å
┘äϺ ┘èÏ│┘ç┘ê ┘ê┘äϺ ┘è┘åÏ│┘ë !
┘êÏ╣┘àÏ▒┘ê Ï¿┘å ÏÁϺ┘äÏ¡ Ϻ┘äÏ¡ÏÂÏ▒┘à┘è : ┘èϡϬ┘à┘ä Ïú┘å ┘è┘â┘ê┘å Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è ┘ü┘è "Ͻ┘éϺϬ ϺϿ┘å ϡϿϺ┘å"
(8/486):
"Ï╣┘àÏ▒┘ê Ï¿┘å ÏÁϺ┘äÏ¡ Ϻ┘äÏÁϺϪÏ║ Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ▒┘êÏ▓┘è ÏúÏ¿┘ê Ï¡┘üÏÁ : ┘èÏ▒┘ê┘è Ï╣┘å ϺϿ┘å Ϻ┘ä┘àϿϺÏ▒┘â Ïî ϡϻϽ┘åϺ
Ï╣┘å┘ç Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï│┘å Ï¿┘å Ï│┘ü┘èϺ┘å Ïî ┘êÏ╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï¿┘å ┘àÏ¡┘à┘êÏ» ".
┘é┘äϬ : ┘üÏÑ┘å┘ç ┘à┘å ┘çÏ░┘ç Ϻ┘äÏÀÏ¿┘éÏ® . ┘êϺ┘ä┘ä┘ç ÏúÏ╣┘ä┘à .
Ͻ┘à Ï▒Ïú┘èϬ ┘äϺϿ┘å ÏÀϺ┘çÏ▒ ┘àϬϺϿÏ╣Ϻ┘ï Ï╣┘åÏ» ÏúÏ¿┘è ┘åÏ╣┘è┘à ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äÏ¡┘ä┘èÏ®" (2/50) ┘éϺ┘ä : ϡϻϽ┘åϺ
┘àÏ¡┘àÏ» Ï¿┘å Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ©┘üÏ▒ : Ͻ┘åϺ ϼÏ╣┘üÏ▒ Ï¿┘å ÏúÏ¡┘àÏ» Ï¿┘å ┘èÏ¡┘è┘ë Ϻ┘äÏ«┘ê┘äϺ┘å┘è: Ͻ┘åϺ ÏúÏ¡┘àÏ» Ï¿┘å
Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï¡┘à┘å Ï¿┘å ┘ê┘çÏ¿ : Ͻ┘åϺ Ï╣┘à┘è Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç Ï¿┘å ┘ê┘çÏ¿ : ϡϻϽ┘å┘è Ï╣┘àÏ▒ Ï¿┘å ÏÁϺ┘äÏ¡ Ï╣┘å
┘à┘êÏ│┘ë Ï¿┘å Ï╣┘ä┘è ... Ï¿┘ç.
┘âÏ░Ϻ ┘ê┘éÏ╣ ┘ü┘è┘ç : (Ï╣┘àÏ▒ Ï¿┘å ÏÁϺ┘äÏ¡) ... ┘ü┘äϺ ÏúÏ»Ï▒┘è Ïú┘ç┘ê Ï«ÏÀÏú ┘à┘å Ϻ┘ä┘åϺÏ│Ï« Ïú┘ê Ϻ┘äÏÀϺϿÏ╣ σ Ïú┘à
┘ç┘ê ┘âÏ░┘ä┘â ┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏ▒┘êϺ┘èÏ® σ ┘êÏ│┘êϺÏí ┘âϺ┘å ┘çÏ░Ϻ Ïú┘ê Ï░Ϻ┘â Ïî ┘üÏÑ┘å ϼÏ╣┘üÏ▒ Ï¿┘å ÏúÏ¡┘àÏ» Ϻ┘äÏ«┘ê┘äϺ┘å┘è ┘çÏ░Ϻ
┘ä┘à Ïúϼϻ ┘ä┘ç ϬÏ▒ϼ┘àÏ® Ïî ┘ü┘äÏ╣┘ä┘ç Ï│Ï▒┘é┘ç ┘à┘å ϺϿ┘å ÏÀϺ┘çÏ▒.
Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ïú┘å Ï┤┘èÏ«┘ç ÏúÏ¡┘àÏ» Ï¿┘å Ï╣Ï¿Ï» Ϻ┘äÏ▒Ï¡┘à┘å Ï¿┘å ┘ê┘çÏ¿ - ┘àÏ╣ ┘â┘ê┘å┘ç ┘à┘å Ï┤┘è┘êÏ« ┘àÏ│┘ä┘à -
┘ü┘éÏ» ϺϫϬ┘ä┘ü┘êϺ ┘ü┘è┘ç Ïî ┘â┘àϺ ϬÏ▒Ϻ┘ç ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äϬ┘çÏ░┘èÏ¿" Ïî ┘ê┘éÏ» ┘éϺ┘ä ϺϿ┘å Ï╣Ï»┘è ┘ü┘è ┘âϬϺϿ┘ç "Ϻ┘ä┘âϺ┘à┘ä" (1/184) : "Ï▒Ïú┘èϬ Ï┤┘è┘êÏ« Ïú┘ç┘ä ┘àÏÁÏ▒ Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è┘å ┘äÏ¡┘éϬ┘ç┘à ┘àϼ┘àÏ╣┘è┘å Ï╣┘ä┘ë ÏÂÏ╣┘ü┘ç".
Ͻ┘à Ï│Ϻ┘é ┘ä┘ç ÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ ┘à┘àϺ Ïú┘å┘âÏ▒ Ï╣┘ä┘è┘ç Ïî ┘ê┘âÏú┘å┘ç ÏúÏ┤ϺÏ▒ Ï¿┘é┘ê┘ä┘ç Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ░┘â┘êÏ▒ ÏÑ┘ä┘ë Ïú┘å Ïú┘ç┘ä Ï¿┘äÏ»┘ç
ÏúÏ╣Ï▒┘ü Ï¿┘ç ┘à┘å Ϻ┘äÏ║Ï▒ϿϺÏí Ϻ┘äÏ░┘è┘å Ï│┘àÏ╣┘êϺ ┘à┘å┘ç . ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ░┘çÏ¿┘è ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ║┘å┘è" Ï╣┘éÏ¿┘ç :
"┘é┘äϬ : ┘ä┘ç ÏúϡϺϻ┘èϽ ┘äϺ ϬϡϬ┘à┘ä " . ┘ê┘éϺ┘ä Ϻ┘äϡϺ┘üÏ© :
"ÏÁÏ»┘ê┘é ϬÏ║┘è┘æ┘ÄÏ▒ Ï¿ÏúÏ«Ï▒Ï®".
┘êϺÏ╣┘ä┘à Ïú┘å┘å┘è ÏÑ┘å┘àϺ ÏúÏ«Ï▒ϼϬ Ϻ┘äÏ¡Ï»┘èϽ ┘ç┘åϺ ┘ä┘é┘ê┘ä┘ç ┘ü┘è┘ç : "Ï▒Ï¡┘àÏ® ┘äÏ╣┘àÏ▒" Ïî ┘êÏÑ┘äϺ Ïî ┘üÏ│ϺϪÏ▒┘ç
ÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡ Ïî ϼϺÏí ┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘é Ï»┘ê┘å┘çϺ Ïî ┘ü┘ç┘è ┘à┘å┘âÏ▒Ï® Ïî ┘ê┘ü┘è Ï¿Ï╣Ï ÏÀÏ▒┘é┘ç Ï▓┘èϺϻϮ : "┘üÏÑ┘å┘çϺ ÏÁ┘êϺ┘àÏ®
┘é┘êϺ┘àÏ®" Ïî ┘ü┘çÏ░┘ç ÏúÏÁÏ¡ Ïî ┘äÏú┘å┘çϺ Ï▒┘ê┘èϬ ┘à┘å ÏÀÏ▒┘é ┘è┘é┘ê┘è Ï¿Ï╣ÏÂ┘çϺ Ï¿Ï╣ÏÂϺ┘ï Ïî ┘êϬϼϻ Ï¿┘èϺ┘å Ï░┘ä┘â
┘à┘üÏÁ┘äϺ┘ï ┘ü┘è "Ϻ┘äÏÁÏ¡┘èÏ¡Ï®" (2007) Ϻ┘ä┘àϼ┘äÏ» Ϻ┘äϫϺ┘àÏ│ Ïî ┘ê┘éÏ» ÏÀÏ¿Ï╣ ┘êϺ┘äÏ¡┘àÏ» ┘ä┘ä┘ç ϬÏ╣Ϻ┘ä┘ë.
__________
(*) ┘âÏ░Ϻ ┘ü┘è ÏúÏÁ┘ä Ϻ┘äÏ┤┘èÏ« Ï▒Ï¡┘à┘ç Ϻ┘ä┘ä┘ç ϬÏ╣Ϻ┘ä┘ë Ïî ┘ê┘ü┘è Ϻ┘äÏÀÏ¿Ï▒Ϻ┘å┘è" : Ï╣┘ä┘ë Ï▒ÏúÏ│┘ç Ïî ┘ê┘àϺ Ï¿┘è┘å
Ϻ┘ä┘àÏ╣┘â┘ê┘üϬ┘è┘å ┘à┘å┘ç Ïú┘èÏÂϺ┘ï . (Ϻ┘ä┘åϺÏ┤Ï▒) .